Based on 65 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
811 Evesham Rd, Magnolia, NJ 08049
Phone: (856) 346-2500
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
AJDM
The wait time was a little extended, BUT that’s okay. Everyone has to understand , that as a business especially in the food industry. People are short staffed, and making food could be time consuming. And that’s anywhere you go. At least, the person making your food is cooking with love, patience, and are working super hard . So everyone should learn how to be patient with them ! Anywho, They have a great variety of different things to pick from. I ordered fried pickles, which I’ve never had. But, I can say it was a tremendous first experience 🙂 Garlic knots were different from other locations, typically they are small but these garlic knots were huge AND tasty . And it’s good to stand out from other businesses. For the pizza we ordered a Sicilian style Magnolia Pizza. The pizza was not too seasoned but I’d say for me that is perfect ! My family did like the wings, I’m not a fan of BBQ but they said they were great . And I believe the owner is who I talked to, she was very open and sweet. Great job on bringing a great great pizza shop to the area !:)
… more
Jennifer Jackson
Oh, my gosh! Delicious! When I can get home with a pizza, and the cheese is still thick and melty, I’m in heaven! The flavor is so good!
… more
Eric Weist
The Sicilian pie was delicious!!! Also ordered chicken tenders and fried pickles. The kitchen was super clean and service was super fast despite being short handed. Gena was super attentive while handling our food and made sure I was well taken care of. I am a stickler for clean kitchens and safe food handling. They abided by all of the safety standards and made sure a quality product was served!!
… more
luis gonzalez
I waited a yr to try this pizza and boy was it worth it it was an amazing pizza made the old school way and it’s harder and harder to find a quality pizza like this. Please understand that if a pizza is a bargain it isn’t a quality pizza. My friend had a pizza steak and he loved it. Oh and Gina makes fresh croutons talk about putting love into food. Get staff are good people and very friendly. Too bad i live so far.
… more
Amanda Flynn
We moved to Runnemede recently, and will literally drive past other pizzerias to get to Gena’s. Gena herself makes all of the food with great attention to detail. The Sicilian has an excellent crisp crust under all that doughy goodness. We recommend getting extra sauce because you’ll want it to dip that golden, delicious crust. Most importantly, Gena’s was clean and I can most certainly trust that any food that comes from her kitchen is well above standard.
… more
Alyssa Cowling
We have ordered from Gena’s from months- it’s our go to pizza spot. The food is always phenomenal, and the service is also great. Never had a bad experience. I truly think the more less-stellar reviews were one off experiences because I can’t ever imagine the same experience. Again, thank you for the delicious food and courteous service!
… more
J R
Gena and her staff put alot of love and care in each dish prepared in their kitchen. It is worth the wait. Everything there is terrific. I will definitely be more of a regular.
… more
B Anne M
We love Gena’s – the food is always hot and fresh. Cheesesteaks stuffed with lots of meat and cheese and the roll is always nice and fresh. Fries and wings are crispy and I always appreciate a really good Mild sauce tangy and delish! Gena always says Hello! and I love the people answering the phone are nice and don’t keep saying that it? that it? LOL Keep up the great work!
… more
J R
I love seeing small businesses thrive, and I will support this one through and through. I’ve had cold hoagies, cheesesteaks, pizza, etc. I’ve seen Ms. Gena throw together some meals that are diet specific for my Pops. (Special requests aren’t shunned here.) ALL OF MY VISITS start with warm service and end with a full belly, super satisfied with her attention to detail and flavor. She wants her patrons to feel valued and respected, and she does this through quality food, fair prices, conversation, and getting to know the community. My family appreciates Gena and her staff! Give her spot a visit. I guarantee you’ll feel part of the family right away.
… more
Ashley Stanton
I’ve recently started ordering from Gena’s, I’ve ordered multiple different items and each item has been great quality and absolutely delish. I’m very picky with fried pickles, hers are one of the best I’ve had. Garlic knots are nice and fresh plus you get a lot for your money. Pizza and Cheesesteak were great also! Will definitely continue ordering and highly recommend!! Cannot believe I waited this long to order!!
… more
… View more