Based on 139 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
9853 Johnnycake Ridge Rd, Mentor, OH 44060
Phone: (440) 350-1500
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Siana Stewart Blanchard
I ordered 2 small pizzas, 10 wings 5 plain , 5 with honey mustard sauce, when I tell you these wings were raw, pale , I called yo tell them , Kevin the manager telling me the wings were precooked for 7 minutes, and if I wanted it cooked , I should have said cooked crispy, I told KEVIN I should I tell you how to do your job, than he proceeded to say there’s nothing he can do, I told him what kind of establishment doesn’t take customers complaints seriously. They are not in the right business. This food is garbage.Never again
… more
Gregory Pastor-Hall
Don’t rate them off of DoorDash, first off. If you’re reading this, I’ve probably had a lot more pizza than you. And I mean that. Probably over 100 different pies. This place offers the best pickup-service New York style pizza in the county, hands down. They could use some rehab on the building and maybe more consistency. But that’s life.
… more
Faith Katherine
awful experience, I wanted to really give this place a chance with the other reviews. now I am just convinced that the other reviewers have zero taste buds. this pizza was the most awful pizza I’ve tried and I go to TONS of pizza joints. my daughter couldn’t even eat it and as a pizza lover, that says something. cheese was disgusting and socky/sour, pizza was rock hard and inedible. for the price? save your money and choose something else.
… more
john eee
This pizza was boring at best. It arrived so cold it was stiff which is the antithesis of a good New York style pizza. I also ordered extra cheese and as the photo attests I did not get that. The salad is good.
… more
Rico Zuñiga
Love the thin crust, personally I like it cooked a little longer for the crisper crust. The garlic sauce is great.
… more
Ryan C
Update: l had P&P again at a lunch event and the traditional pie was significantly better than the sheet pizza I had previously.
… more
Jathin Joestat
Let me start off by saying that this is the best authentic New York style pizza I’ve had in Ohio. It seems like the workers there put a lot of heart into making these pizzas. Wouldn’t change a thing.
… more
H B
Placed an order, when it arrived the honey mustard sauce had opened and spilled all over the food, we were missing 3 items, they brought back one item and when I called them about the other missing items they were kind of condescending to me saying maybe I added to the order, and was I sure I ordered what was missing. I read my email and told them on my screen it says onion rings, they continued to disagree with me and said on thier screen it was Jojo fries.
… more
Jordan Greene
Nice place owners went out of there way to make sure everything was ok
… more
Love Hope
horrible customer service when I walked in I had to wait on someone to come to the front. the pizza had no sauce on it, I was so upset spent over $50 and the pizza sucked. I tried talking to management and they don’t care about the customers at all.
… more
… View more