New York Slices Menu – Highland Park, IL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Highland Park, IL

Take-out restaurant offering thin-crust pizza, hot subs, basic pasta dishes & other grub, Based on 127 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

New York Slices 60035

Address:
1843 2nd St, Highland Park, IL 60035

Phone: (847) 432-6979

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 3:30–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
3:30–8 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 3:30–8 PM
Wednesday 11:30 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–8 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–9 PM

Menu

FOOD
10″ Personal Cheese $10.95
10″ Gluten Free Pizza $12.95
Large 16″ NY Cheese
Feeds 3-4
$17.95
XLarge 20″ NY Cheese
Feeds 4-6
$20.95
16″ Pasta Pizza
Baked Penne On Top Our Cheese Pie
$18.95
16″ Veggie
Spinach, Caramelized Onion, Red & Green Peppers
$20.95
16″ Spinach & Garlic
AWESOME!
$18.95
16″ NY White Pizza
Ricotta/Mozz, Rosemary, Tomato, Spinach
$19.95
16″ Pepperoni & Bacon
What else can we say.. AMAZING!
$18.95
16″ Spicy (Pep & Sausage)
Nino Says En Fuego- Spicy NYS Sauce, Pepperoni & Sausage
$18.95
16″ Pie Of The Day
At Least 2 Toppings- Call for Daily Specials
$18.95
16″ Half Specialty $16.95
16″ Protein Combo $20.95
16″ The Un-Kosher $18.95
16″ Hawaii Five O $18.95
16″ Meat Lovers $18.95
20″ Pasta Pizza
Baked Penne On Top Our Cheese Pie
$24.95
20″ Veggie
Spinach, Caramelized Onion, Red & Green Peppers
$25.95
20″ Spinach & Garlic
AWESOME!
$24.95
20″ NY White Pizza
Ricotta/Mozz, Rosemary, Tomato, Spinach
$24.95
20″ Pepperoni & Bacon
What else can we say.. AMAZING!
$24.95
20″ Spicy (Pep & Sauaage)
Spicy NYS Sauce, Pepperoni & Sausage
$24.95
20″ Pie Of The Day
At Least 2 Toppings- Call for Daily Specials
$23.45
20″ Half Specialty $20.95
20″ Protein Combo $27.95
20″ The Un-Kosher $23.95
20” Hawaii Five O $24.95
20″ Meat Lovers $24.95
Sicilian – Pan Style (Allow 2 Hour Prep Time)
Thick, Fluffy Crust, NYS Sauce & Cheese
$20.95
Grandma’s Pizza – Pan Style (Allow 2 Hour Prep Time)
Smoked Mozz, Crushed Plum Tomatoes, Roasted Garlic
$22.95
10″ Pasta Pizza $12.95
10″ Veggie $12.95
10″ Spinach & Garlic $12.95
10″ NY White Pizza $12.95
10″ Pepperoni & Bacon $12.95
10″ Spicy (Pep & Sausage) $12.95
10″ Pie Of The Day $12.95
10″ Protein Combo $13.95
10″ The Un-Kosher $12.95
10″ Hawaii 5 O $12.95
10″ Meat Lovers $12.95
Salad
6 Toppings
$7.95
Side Salad $5.95
Maddison Square Garden
Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Mozzarella Cheese
$7.95
Caesar Salad
Crispy Romaine, Parmesan Cheese, Homemade Croutons
$7.95
Penne $6.95
Spaghetti $6.95
Bowtie $6.95
Shells $6.95
Baked Penne W/ Cheese $7.95
Italian Ice $1.95
One Scoop $3.25
Two Scoop $3.99
Pints $6.99
Cookie $2.55
Brownies $3.00
Milk Shake $5.99
RB Float $4.99
Sm Cake $30.00
Med Cake $38.00
Lrg Cake $45.00
Cookie Sundae $3.99
Ice Cream Sandwich $3.99
$1 Cookie $1.00
5 Jumbo Buffalo Wings
Mild-Medium-Spicy
$7.95
10 Jumbo Buffalo Wings
Mild-Medium-Spicy
$13.95
15 Jumbo Buffalo Wings $20.95
20 Jumbo Buffalo Wings $27.95
Chicken Fingers $6.95
Chicken Fingers/FF $8.95
Fries $2.95
Jalapeño Popper $5.95
Mozzarella Sticks $6.95
Meatball Sub $7.95
Chicken Parmesan $7.95
Italian Beef $7.95
Philly Cheesesteak $7.95
C-Parm/FF $9.95
ITALBEEF/FF $9.95
Meatball/FF $9.95
Philly/FF $9.95
Chicken Parm Plate
with Pasta & Garlic Knots
$12.95
Italian Rolls
Caramelized Onions & Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, and Veggies
$4.95
Broccoli Swirl
NYS Pizza Dough Baked With A Broccoli & Cheese Center
$4.95
Garlic Knots (Each)
New York Style Garlic Knots- $.45 each
$0.50
Garlic Knots (4)
New York Style Garlic Knots- 4 FOR $1
$1.75
Pizza Sliders
4 Small Pizza Sandwiches with Cheese and NYS Sauce. Add Toppings for $.50
$5.95
Cheese Fritters
Baked Mozzarella Squares
$1.00
Special Order $0.00
Cheese Calzone $6.95
Pepperoni Calzone $7.95
Sausage Calzone $7.95
Spinach & Mushroom Calzone $7.95
16″ Frozen Cheese $11.95
16″ Frozen Veggie $11.95
16″ Frozen Sausage $12.95
16″ Frozen Pepperoni $12.95
DRINKS
SODA CANS $1.65
Bottled Water $1.75
FOUNTAIN DRINK $2.25
San Pellegrino $2.25
Apple Juice $1.95
San Pellegrino $5.00
Bottled Water $1.75
Coke Can $1.65
Diet Coke Can $1.65
Sprite Can $1.65
6 Pack Can $9.00
CATERING
Half Pan Penne W/ Butter $25.99
Half Pan Penne W/ Sauce $27.99
Half Pan Spaghetti W/ Butter $25.99
Half Pan Spaghetti W/ Sauce $27.99
Full Pan Penne W/ Butter $44.99
Full Pan Penne W/ Sauce $46.99
Full Pan Spaghetti W/ Butter $44.99
Full Pan Spaghetti W/ Sauce $46.99
12 Pan House Salad $29.99
12 Pan Caesar Salad $29.99
12 Pan Central Park $34.99
12 Pan Soho Salad $34.99
Full Pan House Salad $37.99
Lg Central Park $45.99
Lg Soho Salad $45.99
Full Pan Caesar Salad $37.99
Cheese Pizza 20″ (8 Slices) $20.95
20″ Pie $20.95
20″ 8 Cut Cheese $20.95
20″ 12 Cut Cheese $20.95
Veggie Pizza 20″ (8 Slices) $24.95
20″ Veggie $24.95
20″ Veggie 8 Cut $24.95
20″ Veggie 12 Cut $24.95
Italian Beef Sandwich (Catering) $47.95
Meatball Sandwich (Catering) $47.95
Veggie Rolls $5.95
Pepperoni Rolls $5.95
Sausage Rolls $5.95
15 Garlic Knots $9.75
20 Garlic Knots $13.00
25 Garlic Knots $16.25
1 Dozen Chocolate Chip Cookies $27.00
THURSDAY SPECIAL
Large 16″ Cheese Pizza $9.95
SUNDAY
16″ Pizza & 5 Wings $19.95
Create Your Own – Personal Pizza $8.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jane Provow
This is the WORST pizza I’ve ever eaten! Cardboard crust, no flavor sauce, there were 11 pieces of onion and the sausage was cut from a roll. I don’t even think it was real. I want my money back! I wouldn’t even give it to my dogs! So GROSS!

… more

Dylan Ivanov
Classic Highland Park staple selling New York style pizza slices along with various other sides and Italian dishes. The slices that are on display range from simple cheese to slices with combinations of various interesting toppings. This was the first and only place I’ve tried a slice with pasta on top and I was not disappointed!

… more

Steeve Rivas
Great New York style pizza, which is what I’ve been looking for. There was a slight sweetness in the sauce that I wasn’t a huge fan of but the dough was classic NY pizza dough. Over all it was great.

… more

Michaela Kratochvilová
We stopped by for a quick slice of pizza and can’t say enough, so crispy and just the right amount of cheese! Delicious!

… more

Boi you just talks to much I say you Unhealthy
All the employees are so welcoming and kind. Especially maya. They got that Gucci Louie Vuitton pizza. Top tier. This is the Usain bolt of pizza, the fastest and best.

… more

Melissa Erickson Orsi
It is true New York style pizza. Of course not the same as if I’m NY, but it gets the job done. If you’re a garlic dan, thee spinach and garlic is very good; pepperoni was okay. We had a takeout order, quoted 30 minutes and it was warm and ready upon arrival – easy as can be.

… more

Brittany G
The pizza is actually really good. The delivery is good as well. I’m giving them a low rating because they don’t fulfill the order properly.

… more

Henrietta Filipas
Although the pizza is good, the delivery service is terrible! This is not deep dish and it shouldn’t take that long to get a pizza. It took them over an hour to get my pizza to me! They used door dash and the person who delivered the pizza just left it on the floor next to the door and didn’t even bother to ring the bell. I even gave a very generous, 20% tip. A few weeks back I ordered from them and an hour later I got a cold pizza. At least the delivery guy rang the bell that time. I thought this was just a fluke, so I gave them another chance today. Bad idea. I used to enjoy the pizza from this place. Now I will never order from there again.

… more

Jolita Narkus
I’ve been ordering from this place for the last 4 years and always had a good experience until tonight. The girl who answered the phone was totally not in the working condition, had to repeat order three times. She said they ran out of ham at 4 pm, thats weird. When we finalized order she just hang up not giving time frame when to expect. Called them an hour later and the guy said that driver is leaving right now. 40 min later called them back and he told me that he will check the refrigerator (have no idea why would he check refrigerator). Got back to me and told that driver is going back to the store and will pick up my pizza for delivery as he did not do that before and will be another 45-55 min. I understand that is shortage of workers and people have to be patient but 3 hours for pizza delivery i think its too much. I canceled the order and they lost me as a customer.

… more

E. Samson
We ordered two Chicken Parm Plates and found them quite good for a pizza-style restaurant. The staff was friendly, the meal was ready for pickup on time and it was still hot by the time I got home. Also had a side salad which was quite good.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions