Gourmet pizza & other Italian steak & seafood dishes are made at this informal, longtime bar/eatery. Based on 712 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4837 W Lake Rd, Mayville, NY 14757
Phone: (716) 753-5200
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jess T
The menu sounded phenomenal and it was huge with lots to choose from. When we got there the place was packed so it seemed very promising. However, our food was terrible! The seafood carbonara tasted like someone blew a hint of butter scent on it and there was absolutely no seasoning. The shrimp & tiny pieces of lobster were tasteless as well. The spaghetti & meatballs was drier than the Sahara there must have been a sauce shortage? Don’t let the picture fool you once mixed it really wasn’t enough. The only sorta good things were the honey mustard wings (even though those were overcooked) and the Italian wedding soup. Maybe this place has really good “something” we obviously didn’t order to warrant the traffic?? We did take out hence why this highly expensive food didn’t go straight back to where it came from. $70 wasted won’t return.
… more
Cecala Ismyname
Pizza rolls, pictured were amazing. I had the chicken parm and date had a traditional cheese pizza. Both were very very good!
… more
Andrew Lih
Nice restaurant for those wanting something more tasty than the Chautauqua standard fare across the street. Had fresh mozzarella salad, crispy calamari and really good garlic butter wings. They were a bit on the overly fried side but the flavors were top notch. Would definitely recommend.
… more
Joey Ciccotti
Ordered for the entire family. Ordered 50 mild wings, a cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, a Neapolitan pizza, and a gluten free pizza and everyone enjoyed their food. Price was very reasonable for the amount of food we ordered and service was very fast and friendly. Our only complaint was that we only got a tiny bag of celery for our order of 50 wings. Other than that, everything was delicious!
… more
Randy Turner
This was our first time visiting and we were celebrating our anniversary. We enjoy Italian food and thought we would give them a try. I had the homemade lasagna and the server had recommended the Alfredo sauce which was absolutely the best lasagna that I have ever had. The service was prompt and the wait staff were all very upbeat and courteous. We will definitely return and highly recommend to others to give them a try.
… more
Karen R
Even though they are remodeling so their dining area is small right now. It’s still cozy, and they do a very good job of seating quickly. The food is always wonderful. We had the Supreme Pizza and BBQ wings. The pizza was the best we’ve ever had. Done perfectly with just the right amount of toppings.
… more
chris mead
so – the food was okay as expected. the porch is wonderful, servers great – unusual for most restaurants they could add anchovies to their caesar! woot! the prime rib was fattier than wanted but seasoning was solid and it was rare – just like we wanted it to be.
… more
Youroccasionbydesign Thegifteryea
We came in from Buffalo for our Anniversary weekend. We are admitted Pizza snobs… holy moly!! This place is AMAZING! Chicago pizza with sausage is a must! Calzone….incredible! Wonderful place!
… more
Emery Boyle-Scott
The calzones are amazing, they have so much flavor and cheese. The perfect lunch (and dinner) meal on the patio. I recommend stopping whenever you’re in town.
… more
Jeffrey Currier
You know, Andriaccio’s is one of the only food options available in my area. I must say, the staff is always nice, but the food never wows me. I was thoroughly disappointed this week, with a stop by for lunch. (I was meeting colleagues, and going to an event at Chautauqua Institution afterward.). I had the Calzone, which frankly was terrible. Undercooked green pepper pieces, baked in a mountain of tasteless mozzarella, wrapped in pizza dough. When I say tasteless, I mean it. They were out of iced tea, like regular iced tea. Only offering the sweet raspberry type. Ugh. I’ve had two things there I like over the years…the meat all sub, and the spaghetti and meatballs. The sauce is great. Like I said, the staff is great, but hells bells, I’m convinced they only stay alive because they are the only game in town. PLEASE make your food tastier, don’t overcook your calamari, give your pizza some zest! I WANT to love you. Sign me, Always Disappointed.
… more
… View more