Local pizzeria located directly between Granville/Heath/Newark Ohio slinging on our favorite style of pizza (not too thick, not too thin – Goldilocks style!). Our dough and sauce are all made in house, with a variety of toppings to choose from. Large cereal cookies in varying flavors available at the shop every week too!
Follow us on FB and IG for weekly specials!
Based on 139 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2050 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 281-3030
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tim Jones
Best staff. I swear every time I go in they treat you like your family. Food is amazing. Check for the monthly specials on Facebook.
… more
Jacob G
Pizza is consistently very well made, have yet to have had a bad pizza from them after 4 visits. The cookies are excellent, it is worth it to just get the cookies alone. Staff have been super nice and helpful. Recommend the “Doug” and “Captain Planet” pizzas.
… more
Mark (idoubbleyou)
This place was great. The pizza was nice and fluffy. Its so hard to find a nice fluffy pizza. The staff was great. Only complaint I wish they had indoor dining. Definitely give this place a try.
… more
Brooke Hooper
Absolutely amazing! Pizza Nerds is simply the best! I tried it for the first time today while we driving through Newark, and am so thrilled we remembered Pizza Nerds after seeing it on multiple pizza groups on Facebook. It was unbelievable! I got the Mario and added sausage and it was perfect. The crust was chewy, crunchy, flavorful, and the honey was just the icing on the cake for the pizza. It added this amazing sweet flavor to the crust too that I loved. The sausage was so good too! It was not your typical big unappetizing sausage pieces. It was finely chopped up and cooked so yummy and crunchy and tasted fresh. The pepperonis were also crunchy and the cheese was cooked to perfection. The crust has the perfect shade of brown crisp on its edges and it was presented so beautifully! It was just a perfect pizza! Definitely my new favorite. The owners were also super sweet and so friendly. Really awesome people and pizza! Will definitely be coming back soon for sure, and I already can’t wait!!! I’m so sad I live out of town, and won’t be able to have it every week!! ❤️❤️❤️
… more
Sarah Moore
The best pizza you will ever have.
… more
David Melvin
My wife and I went here for her birthday. We ordered a half Doug, 1/2 white sauce with pepperoni bacon and jalapeños. When we arrived, they told us that they put jalapeños on the entire pizza, and gave us a new pizza and additional ranches, along with the (slightly) off pizza. What customer service!
… more
Jen Brilmyer
FANTASTIC shop. BEST pizza I’ve ever had and AMAZINGLY delicious cookies. I would get food from here over and over again. The staff is super friendly and kind. They have the coolest decor in there-an homage to the 90’s. Again, the owners are literally the best people on the planet and they make an incredible product and they’re super good looking. Would visit again x1000.
… more
Brian Crowthers
This place has been on my to-go pizza places for a while now, after some convincing my kids and I picked up a pepperoni and cheese and I will say it was pretty dang good!!!
… more
Sean McCullough
Elder millennial so great 90s atmosphere. Staff is super friendly. Unique takes on classic Detroit pizza. Got the captain planet hesitantly, but great flavor– basil, peppers mushrooms were very complementary. Keep it up guys! You’ve got a loyal customer!
… more
Brandon
Loved the Doug pizza. I will be coming back to try other types.
… more
… View more