New York-style pizza & other casual Italian dishes, showcased at an enduring strip-mall eatery. Based on 386 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
840 W 23rd St, Panama City, FL 32405
Phone: (850) 769-9466
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
MR. JOE
Small little establishment in strip mall. Ordered the garlic knots and 16 in. Cheese pizza. Omg the garlic knots came out warm and tasty. The wife absolutely loved the garlic butter under the knots And the marinara sauce. The cheese pizza was fantastic. One of the best I’ve had. Wine bottles hang on the wall. Music quietly playing. Will return to try other menu items
… more
Andrew Diaz-Recurt
Atmosphere/cleanliness: Quiet, calming Italian music really sets the mood. It’s quaint but could use some serious updating to the tables, chairs, and decor. Perhaps some simple table cloths with stunning center pieces with a fresh paint job and new lighting structure would be a low cost investment and bring much needed new life. Bathrooms need a serious wipe down on the walls, fresh paint, and less clutter.
… more
April Vinzant
I would have missed it if we weren’t looking for it. Cute little place on the corner with a family atmosphere. Food was really good.
… more
Jared McDaniel
My aunt and uncle took me here since I begged them to eat Italian with me. I ordered a calzone and it was AMAZING! The co-owner also was our server and was super efficient and friendly. Their menu will make your mouth water and there are quite a few options. Highly recommended by me! The atmosphere is nice, but the tables are close enough to hear personal conversations, and the music could be louder. Other than that, love the food and the sweet tea!
… more
Michael Husava
Pizza was good. Fresh mushrooms are always a plus. Just seemed to be light on the sauce. Hand tossed crust also another plus.
… more
San
Absolutely disgusting! I ordered the lunch chicken parm and my mom ordered the lunch lasagna. The meals comes with salads and the lettuce was wilted. We told our waitress that the lettuce was brown and she said “Well it is the summer time so lettuce gets brown”. Instead of offering a new salad she gave us an extra bread stick. When the actual food came in i cut into my chicken and I knew right then and there that it was going to be gross and I was absolutely right! Chicken wasn’t crispy and tasted rubbery. My mom’s lasagna was nasty also. The meat almost looked grey wasn’t edible. I took one bite which was the chicken and the waitress still charged me for the full meal. A waste of almost $40. Should’ve went to Nick’s or Olive Garden if i wanted good Italian food. Will be calling the health department on Monday morning!
… more
Shannon Nicole
Been coming here for years. Love the girls that work up there and everything is always fresh and hot! I’ve never had a bad experience here! It’s a must have! It’s also been in Panama City for almost 50 yrs!! It’s a piece of the history of Bay County! ❤️
… more
T H
Dined in with my grandkids ordered a med ham pizza and some fries. The pizza was really good and I loved the crust. Our server was very nice too and didn’t take long for our order to cook. Will return again for pizza.
… more
DJ
The pizza was pretty good but the toppings reminded me of that old commercial, “where’s the beef.”
… more
Sage Crosby
Great music, great food. Love this little hole in the wall. It was overall a pleasant experience and very quiet. The service was quick and great.
… more
… View more