Serving a classic Manhattan taste in Holly Springs, NC, the old country way. With award-winning service, amazing food, and multiple options to dine-in, carry out or delivery, we’re confident you will find your visit to our Holly Springs, NC location like nothing else.
Casual outfit offering New York-style pizza, along with pasta, wings & sandwiches. Based on 876 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
305 Matthews Dr, Holly Springs, NC 27540
Phone: (919) 367-6667
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
John N
The vibe is fantastic, employees were great. Pizza was good, salad on lunch special was tiny (pictured).
… more
Nate Lambert
We picked up an order from here, because they had the best reviews in Holly Springs. Either Holly Springs has no taste or someone paid for these reviews. The pizza is not bad tasting (like eww), it just literally has zero taste. The dough taste like cardboard and has the same consistency of the boxes my kids Christmas presents were shipped from Amazon. Yeah I know what you’re thinking… you eat cardboard… well tonight, yes I did. ♂️ The sauce lacks any flavor at all, which to me makes a true NY style pizza joint. I don’t believe I have eaten a more bland pizza in my life… zero flavor. Needles to say this was our first and last stop.
… more
PLUS Dueling Pianos
We own PLUS Dueling Piano Bar and Back Then Bar and Grill. We appreciate other local businesses that go the extra mile to provide a great product and service. This place never disappoints! The good is consistently really good and the staff is always attentive and friendly. If you’re looking for a tasty meal and you’re in the area, take the time to give this place a try. We should all do our part to support local business’s that go above and beyond… This place deserves your support!
… more
Unique Broughton
Today was my family and I first time trying out this pizza place and everything about was nice. The young lady who took our order was very friendly and polite.
… more
Kendall Triplett
We ordered delivery for a large party. The pizza was delivered right on time and the delivery driver was extremely accommodating. He realized the marinara sauce was left out of the order and he went back to the restaurant to get it and brought it back to us. Excellent service, excellent pizza.
… more
Dennis Barrington
Update:
… more
Tamara Mapula
We ordered pizza and wings today for the first time from you and loved them both. Charles the delivery person was so nice and prompt. And, he was a pleasure to talk to. There is a place in Boston called Arbuckles that had the best wings I ever had and I’ve been looking for a replacement for 30 years and I found them here at Manhattan. Love the crispiness and size and flavor. And the pizza had a great thin crust and ample toppings. And you’re close to home which is even better! We’ll be repeat customers for sure!
… more
Dia S
I went to this establishment a few weeks ago. First let me start off by saying the food was good but as my husband and I walked up to the register we looked at the menu for a few minutes. When we were finally ready to order the young black and white girl just stared at us. They would not say may I help you. .. which was so disappointing. We just stared at each other this was such an awkward and uncomfortable moment. I would suggest that the manager or owner of this establishment retrain your cashiers let them know all customers should be treated with dignity, and respect. All customers should be immediately greeted/acknowledged and they should learn to give exceptional customer service to all your customers.
… more
Nelson Andrade
This is a family owned business and they put their heart and soul into their products. I love their Mediterranean Pizza. You look at the ingredients and you question if it’s something you should eat but then you take a bite and that’s where you realize how good it is.
… more
Ned Shipley
Got my pizza and garlic knots delivered 30 minutes ago. The knots, weren’t knots, they just balls of bread, that came without a side sauce. And The pizza was ok. My MAJOR issue was that the pepperoni on the pizza was not cooked on the pizza. It was put in a fryer then added to my pizza after the fact. As someone who has worked in a pizza shop for years this “trick” other than looking and tasting like it was fried. This way of cooking the pepperoni also tells on its self as the pepperoni is super greasy but there is no pepperoni greasy on the pizza. Why would there be. It was fried let cool in the basket then put on the pizza after it came out. This is also the reason that not 1 pepperoni stuck to my pizza. Because they were cooked separately.
… more
… View more