Based on 369 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
716 Mill St, Watertown, NY 13601
Phone: (315) 782-7272
Website: https://www.papatinospizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gaspi corgi
Trash. Doughy pizza, tasted like Digiorno. Almost certain the cheese was old. Saddest part were the wings. Clearly old it truly was disgusting that they would have the nerve to serve someone this. Like am I an animal? SAVE YOUR MONEY. Called to let the manager know this is certainly not acceptable, brad I think his was name was, and he was rude and never acknowledged the fact that it was unenjoyable meal for a paying customer. Instead he had the nerve to say “nobody else has complained about them tonight.” I don’t care what others have done I’m talking about MY NASTY WINGS. This place is trash and ran very trashy. Pictures attached. SAVE YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY!! They literally never even try to make it right. Bad business, vultures!
… more
Trinity Plate
We have ordered food for delivery ( through door dash) 3 times. 2 out of the 3 times half of our split topping pizza has been beyond wrong. Pur door dash order says we ordered half pineapple/ Bacon Xtra cheese, the other half banana peppers/ gyro meat/ Xtra cheese and green olives. The receipt from here says instead of pineapple, pepperoni? How does that get lost in the order? The simpler of the two halves has been the side that gets messed up each time, at least this time it was edible. I refrained from leaving a review, hoping it was just normal human error and not a total mess up on all fronts. The food used to be great, but something has changed. For 2 years now we’ve ordered (through 3rd party deliveries) and never had a problem. In the last 4 months that has changed. 2 out of three in 4 months isnt the best odds.
… more
Stephanie Bloss
I cannot understand how all of the people working could allow a feathers COVERED wing go through the cooking sausing and packaging process and not expect someone to get upset. This is just disgusting with lack of respect for customers and respect for the business itself.
… more
Jessica Collins
What happened to the wings, ordered honey mustard wings and they were dry … and no more celery and blue cheese when ordering wings unless you want to pat extra… what a let down!!!! Had to add my own sauce….
… more
Sasha Neville
Not like I remember! My delivery arrived later than what they said by 15mins, they had the wrong address, when pizza came it was hard and really crunchy, and my wings were shriveled up so there was no meat! Very disappointed in this place they used to have the best wings!!
… more
Nicole Welser
Have given them a second chance after they gave my pizza away and I had to wait 25 more min for a new one to be made. Wouldn’t give it to me for free because it was a coupon I had. This past time order 20 wings say 35-40min… an hour later wings are finally done and are not at xtra crispy! Had to repeat my order three times over the phone because apparently it is too difficult to understand!
… more
TheKylebroerman
Had a large calzone and mozzarella sticks on 2 occasions. The mozzarella sticks taste like old oil and the calzone had the two topping on either side and didn’t have a even ratio throughout and was just mozzarella through most of it . However the large calzone was pretty big (was a dinner and lunch for me) and their Marinara was pretty good
… more
Teresa Reichel
Ordered my grandson a chicken parmesan sub and they got it wrong but my grandson said it was fine what they gave him so I didn’t call. My pizza sub had more sauce than it did pepperoni. Usually like this place but it was just meh this time.
… more
Alissa Arno
Pizza was great the chicken fingers..or whatever the burnt brick is (no chicken inside) was the worst thing I’ve ever bought and I even tipped but someone put that in a box and sent it home with me anyways… unfortunately this ruined the 1st ordering experience with this place and I likely won’t order anything again because anyone who saw that “chicken finger” and sold it anyways God only knows what else they would try to serve me!
… more
mandy starks
Came in from out of town looking for authentic Italian pizza,they did not disappoint. Super fast & friendly delivery.very happy customer
… more
… View more