Based on 110 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
14469 Old 41 N, Oaktown, IN 47561
Phone: (812) 745-4175
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mason Ellis
This was my first time eating here and the food was delicious. When I was looking at my plate of food, it reminded me of a Thanksgiving meal. I’m in a power wheelchair and the small gravel in the parking lot caused it to burry itself. Inside, there was little room to maneuver around but the food was great.
… more
JR Davis
This is a place I’m reluctant to rate, it’s so good I don’t want everyone showing up there! The fried chicken here is pan fried and seasoned perfectly. The ham balls are amazing. Their fruit salad, pasta salad, tomato salad…..it’s just better than anywhere! That fried chicken though, it’s my favorite. It’s a buffet of all you can eat, but the best part is you walk through and pick what you want and they put it on a plate. It is just so much better than wondering who has been touching all the utensils in a buffet line and where their fingers have been! Don’t forget the homemade pie and the rolls with real butter. ( no margarine or fake butter spread) GREAT JOB McKinley’s! I’ve ate here numerous times and have never been disappointed.
… more
Kathy Meyer
A very family oriented place, service is prompt and employees very help and friendly. The main lady is as sweet as honey so kind and easy to talk to you feel as if you’ve known her forever.The food is out of this world all homemade and fresh. This is my new favorite place. I have to travel an hour or so to get there but it is definitely worth it.
… more
Karen Eddy
We met family members there because it’s a wonderful place to gather. All the food on the buffet was delicious & tasted home cooked. Like a holiday spread, piping hot & everyone was so friendly. A favorite!!
… more
Don Annis
Nice family buffet out in the country. The food is always good. The service is very friendly and polite, but frequently inattentive. Need a spoon or napkin? Unless you want a long wait, you better get up and it it yourself.
… more
Linda Snyder
Great place to take or meet friends. The food is delicious and tastes just like my Mother had cooked. Reservations needed. Cash only (call for price). Family friendly.
… more
Michael Chou
Nice restaurant in Oaktown. The tomatos were perfectly ripe and the salad and beets were a plesant surprise. The fried chicken had great taste but it was a bit dry. Never had ham ball so they were interesting and the sliced ham was perfect. The slaw and the cooked cabbage was fresh and yummy. Disappointed with the cantaloupe and the watermelon on the bar as they didn’t taste very ripe. The service and the staff were friendly and helpful. The peach pie/cobblerish dessert was worth a second slice.
… more
Annabelle Holscher
Find yourself here & your in a friend’s home. They are great for in season fruits & veggies. The best is, their resteraunt. It’s beautiful & rustic, & a wonderful buffet. You will find everything homemade. The best noodles, fried chicken & homemade pies . Soooo good!
… more
Charlie Stout
Visited after running an errand one evening with my wife. Liked the chicken and home made potatoes, didn’t like the ham balls or super hard to navigate buffet. They also only take cash or checks.
… more
Duane Smith
Great place to get eat! Great food! Grateful Service! Great get away from fast food! This was my grandfather,father and my son’s favorite place to get away to eat. Thank you McKinley’s!
… more
… View more