Based on 200 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
8757 Smoky Row Rd, Powell, OH 43065
Phone: (614) 764-1611
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bill Konves
Excellent pizza, wing and stromboli. Great service too. Charred pepperoni appetizer… Perfect. Cracker crisp crust. All things we have had are good.
… more
Luke Knapke
This place is pretty solid. They have some good pizza at a decent price. Really crispy thin crust that stayed pretty crisp even after traveling in a box. Staff was very helpful and polite. Toppings were good. Not too skimpy but also not over heaped so that the pizza didn’t cook. All around solid stop for pizza.
… more
Ricky Edwards
Has a old school flavor to it something that most pizzas places have just lost over the years, part of it is the old school brick ovens but the other part of it is the ingredients they use. The pepperoni has a lot of flavor but they also do another thing most companies don’t do any more they season it, and put parmesan cheese on it. Absolutely have to go back again loved it.
… more
Jason Shaffer
We have lived in the area for 10yrs now and Carlucci’s always delivers a solid pizza that is reasonably priced. The crust is light, thin, slightly crispy with the just right amount of chew. The sauce is excellent and is savory with just a hint of spice and sweetness that works well. The cheese is the perfect blend that melts well and is delicious and fresh. The other toppings are all of excellent quality and freshness. We usually get a pepperoni and sausage, the ezzo pepperoni is perfect and the crumbled sausage is an excellent Italian style that pairs well with the spice of the pepperoni.
… more
Dayne Zinser
I love their pizza! I’ve been enjoying their food for many years at the Dublin location until 2019 now I use the Powell location. Excellent staff at the Powell location. I miss the location that used to be 2 miles from our house but now I drive to Powell EVERY week to get my pizza & sub. The pepperoni they use is 5 star and one of the reasons I crave their pizza pies and cracker crust
… more
Joseph Reese
Great pizza, got it well done and the crush was perfect. The wings are a bit bigger than most places, they were sauced generously (spicy garlic and garlic parm) which had a lot of flavor.
… more
Jay Conley
Super disappointed. They claim “the best Stromboli in ohio” well that is definitely a false claim unless they mean best profit for the maker. I just paid 15 bucks for a small with very little toppings! I was still hungry when finished. The dough was more like bread than a Stromboli dough (which was terrible). My wife got a sub that looks like they cooked it with a torch. I gave it a shot because of they’re claim of the best but I feel like I was lied to and robbed honestly. This was my first time ordering there. Next door is The Filling Station and their pizza is amazing
… more
Damon Reynolds
Amazing customer service!! First time here & it’s worth the drive.
… more
Patrick P
Great pizza – there is a bra next door that is cool if you need to wait.
… more
Kip L
Best Columbus style pizza in NW Columbus. Only a handful of old school family owned legends in the metro area can compete with this magical za. And the staff is always great too
… more
… View more