Based on 260 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
227 S 3rd St, Palmyra, WI 53156
Phone: (262) 495-2659
Website: https://www.facebook.com/nite.inn
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 5:30–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5:30–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jill Kessenich
We enjoyed two of the German dishes, great cocktails and Key Lime cheesecake. Service was excellent, even though there were only 2-3 staff people. Disappointed the bar wasn’t open and busy, but I know post COVID issues still are around. Thought it was a very good value. We’ve enjoyed the fish fry in the past, as well.
… more
Chad Bartell
Definitely a neat experience, walk in order at the door. Grab a seat at the bar and relax. When the food is ready, they send you to a table in the dining room. Walleye was Fantastic, light and flaky. Gf had the baked Cod, she said it was Fantastic as well. Key lime pie did not disappoint.
… more
Paul Sucharski
Our favorite fish fry by far. We live 35 minutes away, but since discovering Nite Cap back in 2018 we’ve been there over 50 times. It’s one of those fish fry meals where everything is great – the fish, real potato pancakes, the fries, the coleslaw, even the bread and tartar sauce are top notch – and it’s just a fun experience… like stepping back into 1973, in a good way. The walleye and shrimp are also excellent. We’ve stopped in 2 or 3 times for the German food as well, and enjoyed that very much, but we’re more hooked on the fish 🙂
… more
Nick Cairns
My buddy brought me to experience a classic ‘sconni fish fry and this place didn’t disappoint. Glad I was with experienced friends as I would have had no idea I needed to know what to order as I walked in.
… more
Sarah Weiss
Had the fish fry with potato pancakes. Dinner was really good. Pancakes were crispy on the outside and creamy in the middle. The fish was lightly coated but crispy. Flaky and moist. We will be back.
… more
Steve Armin
Went for a Friday night fish fry. I have no complaints about the quality of food; both the fish and potato pancakes were good. If you’re ok with one serving and maybe just one extra piece, I think you’ll enjoy your visit. But, as a big eater, I tend to be drawn to all-you-can-eat and I get the impression they go out of their way to make getting additional helpings as inconvenient as possible. When you want more they bring you only one piece at a time and, when the waitress drops it off, don’t expect to see her again for another 20 minutes. The strategy works; I think it took an extra 45 minutes for me to get 2 more pieces. I wanted one more but didn’t feel like waiting another 25 minutes for it. Fortunately, there are still a few other places that offer A-U-C-E fish fry and I can get a few extra pieces without investing the extra hour to hour and a half.
… more
Shelly Hewitt-Rogers
Shrimp, cod(ayce), potato pancakes all very good. Schaum Tort was a fresh, light ending to a good meal. The servers are pleasent & efficient. Drinks are strong. Have the Chocolate Martini- yummy!
… more
k a
I had a Wednesday night Walleye fish supper. There potato pancakes are delicious, especially with applesauce. My family has been going there for years. They are a local legend.
… more
Keith Kler
This is hands down the best Friday fish fry around. Only $10 per meal. The three pieces of fish were awesome, the potato pancakes were delicious and even the rye bread was the best I have ever had! You can get fries if you don’t like potato pancakes.
… more
Linda Porter
The 6 of us had a great time at Nite Cap. People are friendly and attentive. Food and drinks are delicious. Atmosphere is comfortable.
… more
… View more