Lost Key Tap seeks to bring an elevated, chef-driven menu to downtown Wrightstown. Set directly between Green Bay and Appleton, Lost Key Tap brings a taste of big-city flavor to small-town Wisconsin. Chef Curt Lambpert offers a curated menu composed of a made-from-scratch fare, ranging from favorites such as house-made pastrami reubens to risotto and grilled salmon.
Based on 134 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
505 Washington St, Wrightstown, WI 54180
Phone: (920) 532-9090
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: lostkeytap.comexploretock.com
Reviews
Kyra LaRue
Incredible food! I had the cheesy rice (risotto) and it was wicked good. My partner had the macadamia nut crusted walleye, and we shared and I am so happy we did, Lost Key has a high quality menu. Our waitress and host were fantastic and our chef even came over to see if we had a good meal! The atmosphere is really nice too, they have good taste in music -where we sat had a cool vibe / view and their bar is sweet. They went above and beyond in service, and care taken with both the food and the incredible humans who make it happen. We will definitely be back!
… more
Derrick Stewart
The wife and I checked this place out last night for the first time and really enjoyed it! I love the huge wrap around bar. The drinks were really good and the bar tender was friendly and very efficient! There was some really good live music while we were dining and it was at the perfect volume. You can still enjoy a conversation while listening. The food was excellent! Great flavors and cooked to perfection. The server was very attentive and made recommendations. We will absolutely be back again!
… more
Daniel Roeder
Wait staff was polite and prices seemed to align with the environment.
… more
Dan Korb
Great experience the minute we walked in the place. Had to wait for the rest of our party so we had a drink at the bar. Bartender was prompt and knowledgeable of the drinks available. Hostess seated us when we were all ready. Our waitress was awesome with service and attending to our needs. Great atmosphere and great food!! Was not our first visit and will not be our last. The owner even stopped at our table to inquire how everything was and if there was anything we needed.
… more
Ashley J
Food was really good! Only thing that was a bummer was my burger was rare instead of medium, pink all the way through with no grey, center was cool. My husbands steak was rare as well, but he’ll eat it that way. I still ate half of my burger until I got to the cool center and I’ll reheat it on my own stove as leftovers. Wings were delicious, loved the seasoning. And the beer battered bacon is so crisp! The burger comes with onion rings on top and I hope they make them an appetizer soon as they were great!
… more
Mickenzie Hubbartt
Excellent! I had the walnut crusted walleye and my significant other had the ribeye, both were delicious:) Staff was friendly and accommodating. It was also nice to have the chef come out and ask us how everything was. Highly recommend, thank you.
… more
Melanie Reinl
A group of ladies and I decided to try lost key tap. We drove out to wrightstown from Appleton and we’re late because the snowy winter weather was worse than we thought. We called ahead and they were happy to hold our table/reservation until we arrived which was about 10 minutes late. They immediately sat us we all got drinks and plenty of time to chat and ordered when we were ready. The atmosphere is so relaxed and the room is very light with mirrors and lighting and so nice. There’s an area where there could be entertainment a band, etc. There’s several large booths and a row of tables on each side of the bar centered in the middle. The food was delicious I personally had the macadamia encrusted walleye over some veggies and it was pretty amazing. Everyone at our table enjoyed their food and are waitress was very attentive and helpful even when she was rushed with other tables. Definitely give the lost key tab a try if you haven’t been there chances are you’ll definitely go back.
… more
Hannah Rose
Loved the beautiful atmosphere and professional kind service from everyone! Wonderful place! Fantastic signature cocktails (Sangria is my favorite not too sweet!) and you can’t go wrong with all of their house made fresh food and sauces! Top notch restaurant. I will be back and be bringing friends and family on the future! Great time for a classy date night, business meeting, and any time you need a beautiful enjoyable time. I highly recommend!
… more
Heather Raymaker
Started out Saturday off with Yoga and Mimosas at Lost Key Tap as part of a special event. The venue is beautiful and I did yoga on the floor and it was spotless! . After yoga enjoyed a fabulous homemade Bloody Mary serviced with a mine Miller high life bottle, absolutely delicious. We the. Enjoyed the Burrata as an appetizer and had the Cuban and Pasteami Reuben. All of the favors were on point, the crispy thin fries with garlic and parsley were finger licking good. We are looking forward to come back anf enjoy dinner soon.
… more
Emily
Nice, new place for food and brews. Decent selection of craft beer on tap. Would be nice to see some more local stuff or more interesting beers. I was very excited that they had Downeast Cider on tap! The food was good and came out quickly on a quiet day.
… more
… View more