Neighborhood spot for personal pizzas plus Italian comfort foods from pasta to fish dinners. Based on 161 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1008 Oyster Bay Rd, East Norwich, NY 11732
Phone: (516) 624-7800
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 1–9:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Paul D (Diddy)
My wife and I love coming here for dinner. Amazing Italian food and service. Some of the best dirty martini’s in town
… more
John Giglio
Best Italian Food in NYC metro area I always come her when I’m on Long Island and this place is better than any Italian spot in NYC Try the Chicken Francese with a side of escarole it’s the best. 5 Stars Espresso is top notch. Cool owner
… more
Chris
Unbelievably disappointed doesn’t cover it. Had a medium sized party for a Birthday dinner and couldn’t have had worse service. The fried calamari was absolutely disgusting, chewy and stringy. The hot antipasto was just as bad with gewey clams and a mess of what attempted to be rolitini. Our Waiter who was unbelievably incompetent was asked multiple times for different items for the table and would just walk away. The waiter also messed up by not putting in my order to just come back and offer something else like I didn’t already order that HE screwed up. Overall terrible experience and will never be visiting again. Go to literally anywhere else to eat.
… more
Thalita Verônica
The best barense pizza and chocolate cake in the world!!!
… more
Angelica
Under any circumstance do not give this shady, disgusting owner any of your money. If you are looking to waste a few bucks, you’d be better off putting it into a paper shredder, atleast there it would go to better use. The lack of care for customers and the owner’s semi-boisterous attitude leaves you with the most disheartening dinning experience possible. Perhaps you should have more care for the people giving you their business? Lackluster food from an even more lackluster owner. Order at your own risk.
… more
Joseph Maffei
Shady owners. If you are booking a party get EVERYTHING in writing from these guys. There is a reason these guys don’t provide a contract. One owner will quote you one thing and then day of your party they will charge you a completely different price. Food is mediocre at best.
… more
Norman Hollander
I go here with 2 friends every couple of months. Delicious food and very nice staff. A recommend.
… more
Jane Nelson
Have had very good dinners here, and some definite misses. Service can be good, but also sporadic. The other day ordered pizza for takeout. Was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. When person got there to pick it up 12 minutes after we called in the order, only then did they start to make our pizzas. Have had much better pizzas from there. Sparse toppings. So hit or miss in food and in service. Can be very good, even if bit pricey.
… more
Daniel Easley
The food was terrific but our waiter Albert was definitely lacking in the customer service area. From the moment the 4 of us walked in he seemed to annoyed we were there and an inconvenience to him. He rolled his eyes when he was asked if we could keep our tickets separate(2 groups of 2 so 2 tickets) when asked about menu items he was rude and condescending(what comes on a platter). There were several other instances of him not being very customer service oriented. Had it not been for his rude and appathetic attitude this restraunt would have received 5 stars from me.
… more
Jessica Baehr
I’ve lived in this community for seven years and had always heard such great things about La Pizzetta. I was ready to love this place but was very disappointed. The food was fine but our waiter was unfriendly and most unhelpful. With out even saying hello he asked for our order. Someone else brought our food and our waiter continued to help the people around us but completely ignored us. Eventually the host (who I assume is the owner as well) cleared our table and got us our check. He also wasn’t the friendliest of people but was at least more attentive than our waiter. I am not sure why we were treated this way. We are a nice, quiet young family who were just looking to have a nice night out together. I will not be returning.
… more
… View more