New York Sub Menu – Dallas, TX

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Dallas, TX

A True Mom and Pop Sandwich Shop. Big New York Style Deli Sandwiches with a twist… All of our meats come from local ranchers and are cooked in house! We use only the highest quality all natural ingredients and organic produce. Our shop has been in the same location since 1974, it is filled with good vibes and great memories. Come play our vintage arcade games, let the kids run around and enjoy our old school mechanical rides, and feel good about feeding them and yourself a wholesome meal while supporting local family business.

Based on 250 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

New York Sub 75205

Address:
3411 Asbury St, Dallas, TX 75205

Phone: (214) 522-1070

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–3:30 PM
Saturday 11 AM–3:30 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–8 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Sandwiches & Salads
The Italian
AMAZINGLY GOOD Deitz & Watson Pepperoni, Imported Italian Hard Salami, Imported Italian Capicola with Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Texas Club
Turkey ham and thick cut bacon off from local ranchers piled high with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oregano, and Thousand Island
$10.85
THE OMG
Grilled Jalapeño Cheddar Bread. Double Melty Cheese. Texas Ham. Thick Cut Bacon. Grilled Tomato. 1000 island. Parm Sprinkle.
O M G
$10.85
The French Dip
A Chicago style Italian beef sandwich with toasted bread melted cheese thinly sliced prime rib dipped in our homemade Au jus sauce. Comes with hot peppers on top and a side of the sauce for dipping.
$13.70
Turkey Pastrami Reuben
(Dallas Observers Favorite) This Gigantic Sub comes Packed with Our Hot Turkey Pastrami, Barrel Cured Sauerkraut, Homemade Pickles, Italian Oregano and Russian dressing. OMG!
$10.85
Garden Veggie
REAL Whole Wheat Bread with ALL the veggies (INCLUDES banana peppers and pickles) Add a homemade Veggie patty for 2 bucks more (under extras) Please write white bread or other in the notes if you don’t want it on wheat.
$7.45
BLT
Bacon Lettuce Tomato (DON’T FORGET TO ADD MAYO)
$8.00
Ham & Cheese
Wright Texas Pit Ham. Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Ham, Cheese & Salami
Wright Texas Pit Ham. Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Imported Italian Hard Salami. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano. It’s Awesome.
$10.85
Ham, Cheese & Capicolla
Wright Texas Pit Ham. Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Imported Italian Capicola. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano. It’s Awesome.
$10.85
Salami & Cheese
Imported Italian Hard Salami with Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Salami, Cheese & Capicolla
Imported Italian Hard Salami, Imported Italian Capicola with Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Turkey (No Cheese)
All Natural, Local (Waco TX.) Honeysuckle White Turkey. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Turkey & Cheese
All Natural, Local (Waco TX.) Honeysuckle White Turkey. Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Turkey, Cheese & Ham
All Natural, Local (Waco TX.) Honeysuckle White Turkey. Wright Texas Pit Ham. Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Peppered Turkey, Capicolla & Cheese
All Natural, Local (Waco TX.) Honeysuckle White Turkey. Marinated and brined with Black Pepper. Imported Italian Capicola. Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Capicolla & Cheese
Tons of Imported Capicola with Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$10.85
Pepperoni & Cheese
AMAZINGLY GOOD Deitz & Watson Pepperoni and Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano.
$9.70
All Cheese
TONS of Wisconsin F&A Farms Provolone Cheese. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano. ASK FOR IT HOT!
$8.00
Every Stop On The New York Subway
Don’t Ask Just Eat. Then have a nap.
$16.00
Tuna Fish
Solid White Albacore Tuna and The tiniest bit of Hellman’s Mayo. Made fresh twice daily. Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano. ASK FOR IT ON TOASTED WHEAT WITH PICKLES AND SPICKY MUSTARD (AK’S WAY)
$10.85
Grilled Palm Beach (Pimento Cheese)
Served Hot on Grilled Pretzel Bread! Includes Pimento Cheese, Homemade Pickles, Loaded with Fresh Shredded Lettuce, Razor Thin Onion, Roma Tomato, and Italian Oregano. GREAT with 1000 island. COMES on pretzel when available, please let us know in the notes if you want something different
$10.85
Meatball & Cheese
Melty Cheese, Homemade Meatballs, Marinara Sauce, More Melty Cheese, Parmesan and Oregano. (Great with Peppers)
$10.85
Pizza Sub
Melty Cheese on both sides of bread, homemade pizza sauce, LOADED with pepperoni all baked together and sprinkled with parmesan and oregano.
$10.85
Chef Liam’s Mac N Cheese
A classic creamy yellow mac. Little chef approved. BIG KIDS LIKE IT TOO 😉
$6.85
The Cuban
Its a Cuban! Served on our special Cuban bread
$10.85
Reuben
(Dallas Observers Favorite) This Gigantic Sub comes Packed with Our Hot Pastrami, Barrel Cured Sauerkraut, Homemade Pickles, Italian Oregano and Russian dressing. OMG!
$13.70
Hot Dogs-Texas Raised Angus Beef-Made in Ft. Worth
Chicago Style
Texas Raised Angus Beef-Made in Ft. Worth
Poppy seed bun, relish, pickle, tomato, sport pepper, onion, yellow mustard, celery salt
$7.45
Dallas Dog– Have It Your Way
Texas Raised Angus Beef-Made in Ft. Worth
Tell us in the notes how you like it
$7.45
Hot Link
Peggy Sue’s Texas Hot Link on a bun.. Let us know what you want on it (i.e. Pickles Mustard )
$12.60
Kids Dog- Mustard And Ketchup
Plain Dog, mustard and or ketchup only.. Let us know or else we will put both
$4.60
Kids Hot Dog – Texas Raised Angus Beef
Mustard and or Ketchup just let us know
$4.60
N.Y. Style
Texas Raised Angus Beef-Made in Ft. Worth
Sauerkraut, chopped onion, brown mustard.
$7.45
Texas Dog
State Fair Worthy Texas Angus Beef Dog with chili, cheese, jalapeños, onion..
$13.70
KIDS!
KIDS Lemonade
100% pure cane sugar lemonade
$1.45
Kids Sub
Like a regular sub with less meat. Tell us in the notes how your kid likes it. We will make it that way.
$6.00
KIDS Punch
Delaware Punch
$1.45
Pizza Sub
Melty Cheese on both sides of bread, homemade pizza sauce, LOADED with pepperoni all baked together and sprinkled with parmesan and oregano.
$8.55
Meatball Sub
Melty Cheese, Homemade Meatballs, Marinara Sauce, More Melty Cheese, Parmesan and Oregano. (Great with Peppers)
$8.55
Mac And Cheese !
All natural Wisconsin cheddar cheese homemade gooey delicious mac & cheese
$6.85
Catering
Box Lunches
Comes with a half sub, homemade pickle, bag of chips and homemade cookie. Minimum 7 orders.
$14.25
Kids Platter
20 three inch subs choose turkey and cheese, ham and cheese or a mix.
$57.00
Meat & Cheese Platter
Assortment of fine meats and cheeses.
$85.50
Buffet
Buffet price is per person, minimum 10 orders. A build your own sandwich buffet comes with a selection of all of our meats, cheeses, breads, veggies and toppings. Everything you need to create your own masterpiece. Includes a bag of chips and a homemade cookie for each person.
$16.00
Party Platter
Choose up to 5 kinds of subs. 20 three inch subs. Platters come with plates, napkins and
a bottle of our special sauce. Condiments upon request.
$85.50

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Charles Vernters Jr.
Really enjoyed this experience. It was like an old deli Bodega from the east coast. All the sandwiches are pretty simple but are really made with good quality products. My favorite is the French Dip because of the taste, amount of meat, peppers & dip sauce. A little messy but SO GOOD. We’ve had about 4 different sandwiches & they’ve all been really good. You also have the option to have the sandwiches toasted too.

… more

sophia maas
Oh my goodness will you be full for days after eating half of a sandwich here. Absolutely delicious too

… more

Nate H
High quality, next level sandwiches and food presentation. Lots of fine touches here (preserved antique games, compostable containers, decor)- I was most impressed with the service- We’ve had wonderful conversations here, which is the kind of thing that’s missing from most places. I crave these sandwiches and fries if I go long without them- irreplaceable.

… more

Carolina Tardelli
Very cool place but the bread is too thick.

… more

Jennifer houlihan
Found this sandwich shop right off the beaten path – was amazing!!! I got a half meatball sandwich on a white hoagie roll, and I will tell you, it is one of the best meatball sandwich I recall ever having. The roll was soft, the meatballs were super tender, the sauce was great and it was perfectly cheesy. Really can’t ask for ask more!! I also got half of a roast beef hoagie which had cheese, lettuce and onion. The roast beef was excellent, I just needed a bit more mayo and salt and pepper. My husband got a turkey club hoagie, he really liked it, just needed a bit more seasoning like me. The interior is cute, with some arcade games scattered throughout. Overall, it was really good, looking forward to another meatball sandwich!! Oh, the sandwiches are huge!!!

… more

Lady G Gourmet pastries
The Chicago dog was so massive and good.

… more

Chavid Winberg
Fast Fun clean would be words I would describe this store as. And let me tell you what it is about as New York as eating a pretzel on the Staten Island Ferry as you go under the Statue of Liberty.

… more

Matthew Portman
Great sandwich and great place all around! We were greeted when we came in and the people behind the counter really made us feel at home.

… more

Dan K
Great service, cool atmosphere. Owner gave us two cookies for fun. They have lots of homemade goods as well. Probably one of the best sub shops here in Dallas I’ve been to so far.

… more

ES Raphael
Very friendly sandwich shop. I had the barbecue brisket which is more Texas style than New York style but regardless of what you call it, it’s a good sandwich. Super props for the retro pinball game in the shop. Colorful and fun. $17 for a whole sandwich and a diet Coke was the price of lunch.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions