Airy counter-serve joint with late-night delivery & a menu of pizzas, sandwiches & more. Based on 956 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
231 E North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53212
Phone: (414) 562-4444
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 10 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: nypdwi.com
Reviews
Angie “Tina/Tino” Roberts
Great Sundae’s were in the making for me and my family of 4 this day, However the party that sadden my spirit was that this one lady thought it was okay to not only cough in her hands, but receive money and make out for without washing her hands….. Wrong on all levels Lady But a huge shootout to the one Lady that did see the importance, jumped into position and made the best Sundae’s ever for us.
… more
Ritz A
The location was clean and she was friendly when I walked in. I ordered the chicken Alfredo. It’s too creamy and not enough chicken. The Guy’s ate it thou, then I got to eat & found hair. All the men has on hats & my hair is red. Ruined my appetite.
… more
M Ware
Excellent service, call in orders ready upon arrival. Variety of menu selections. Have tried several menu offerings and found the meals to be favorable. The pizza no doubt is New York style. Definitely would recommend them for an unexpected event or occasion .
… more
Paula Smith
If you want (OLD FOOD) here’s the place to get it from!!!! I ordered a corn beef sandwich with fries, the corn beef was sooo DRY and CRUNCHY it wasn’t edible at all oh and the fries DRY and OLD.
… more
David Shaker
All in all really good food, I good wings that were great, but I am disappointed that I can’t get pizza by the slice. When I go to something that tells me it’s NY style pizza I expect to be able to get a couple slices and not need to buy a whole pie.
… more
christian may
Ordered a pound of boneless hot wings they wasn’t hot at all taste like vinegar and very small for a pound and I ordered a perch dinner the fish was hard not delivered hot and had no taste at all!! That’ll be my last time ordering from them worst 35 bucks I’ve spent in my life
… more
Magnifying Collections
I requested to have my pizza half cheese and half sausage as usual and it was incorrect. So I called to request a new one and they told me they don’t make it that way. I inform the young man i get it that way every time i order. He continues to tell me I am lying. Then I requested to speak w/a manager (You can here him say to the person can you tell her that we don’t do half and half pizzas) and he puts a lady on the phone he just yells we don’t do half and half on the first as I was trying to talk. Then I yell her that’s not acceptable and requested my order correct because they could called and informed me. She says well we don’t. The both of them was so unprofessional and I am livid. I have always had great experience with them today ha made me not want to ever shop with them again. My fries are soggy and my fish is half done very soft. The location is 231 E North Avenue
… more
Symphony Hailey
Love nypd the food was awesome some of the best fried mushrooms in town . Cashier very nice and great customer service . Gyro burger was off the chain appreciate your services … will recommend
… more
Giancarlo Sanchez Gutierrez
I moved from NYC and walked in thiking I would find slices like in NY but I was wrong I didn’t want to order a pie just to get some besides the pictures in the reviews don’t really look like a NY style. I’ll change the review when I try them if if.
… more
Deveyon Boone
I’ve ordered from this More than once and they got all my orders wrong I ordered chicken last night the chicken was so greasy like you can squeeze it and grease will come out chicken wasn’t cooked through all the way forgot my bread sticks and tried to say I had em because they wasn’t at the store I’ve talked to the manager and he was rude I will be taking this to contact 6 cuz establishment is very rude and I do recommend nobody to order from them.
… more
… View more