Carry-out chain featuring chicken wings, signature breadsticks & pizza tossed from housemade dough. Based on 295 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
318 W Market St, Tiffin, OH 44883
Phone: (419) 448-5000
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Angela Hull
My kids love the pizza, but the service and quality are horrible. Your better off driving the extra 100 feet to Domino’s. Placed and order online, picked it up when it said it was done – cold and burnt lol. The manager would not reimburse or comp me unless I drove back to show them the burnt product.
… more
Karree Martin
This is single handedly the WORST little Caesar’s on the planet of the earth. It doesn’t matter what you order or how you order it. The pizza is always the exact same. Raw. The dough is ALWAYA raw. You ask to make it week done. Nah. Still raw. You ask for modifications such as light sauce. Nah. Ask for Parmesan and butter on the crust. Nah. You’re getting a plain pepperoni pizza with toppings not even up to the crust !! I have ordered here multiple times hoping it will change and it never does. I am SO disappointed. Where I moved from had an EXCELLENT Little Caesar’s. Honestly I was a regular after moving here I was very very disappointed.
… more
Lois Lowe
I was so excited because the pretzel pizza came back. So they didn’t have the cheese for the pizza. I went ahead and got pizza and sticks. Very good. The crew was busy. The only thing is while I sat there I noticed that the cold pop refrigerator was very dusty and dirty. It hadn’t been pulled out for a while because there was cobwebs.
… more
Rayze Wolfebane
It honestly depends on what time of day you go in on whether your food will be made properly or not and more often than not anytime I’ve ordered doordash or ordered ahead my food has been cold or messed up in some form or another on the other hand when I go in person especially later in the evening they always make my pizza perfect and fresh and the crew is awesome the night crew definitely has a better attitude than any of the day crew people
… more
Tiffany Schaade
Actually I told myself I’d never go back every single time I go there the pizza is always so gross and nasty. But Anna angel I think her name is is seriously a rock star I will now be going back when she is working she was so kind and u could tell she made our pizza with love and care it was fabulous and my kids loved it. So thank u Anna angel at tiffin little Caesars pizza u were absolutely amazing
… more
Hannah Terry
Pathetic lol… To the person below that commented and asked if the owners changed… No. the owner is the same joke that’s been the owner: they did change managers tho which is why it went to hell. When Courtney left… it was Over with. Side note the girl had her hair brush laying on the counter as I walked in.. ew.
… more
Mark Rogers
Over the years I’ve been to this location with having several issues, getting un cut pizza or burnt pizza, even getting corrected on how I ask for pizza even to the point of seeing employees sitting on tables messing with each other I had hopes that it’s hot or miss but this evening when I went in. It was to see employees being slow, with one wearing bedroom shorts, so I figured I’d place a order only to have the young lady look confused at me an the cash register, my order was 34.00 I gave her 40.00 not only could she not figure out the change, was then I was told they have no cash. This location gets worse an worse.
… more
Nina Baldinger
Italian cheese bread was raw. Then when called they didn’t answer the phone and kept hanging up instead of answering. Definitely don’t recommend
… more
T K (TSWT)
They have good pizza if u get it made freash don’t ever order a hot and ready during peak hours…
… more
Dennis Weaver
Had nothing ready and the young guy cashier thinks no one can hear him when he walks behind the pizza warmers cussing up a storm and saying he is just gonna walk out of here. Great customer service lol not. Also rude as can b
… more
… View more