Based on 127 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1234 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 348-0055
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Meng Thao
Good pizza. Carry out only. Can get busy so expect at least 15 minutes wait.
… more
Doug B
I’ve ordered from Slingin’ Pizza several times and have never been disappointed! The pies are baked to the perfect crispness and they certainly don’t skimp on the toppings. Stop ordering overpriced pizzas from chains and support this place!
… more
Brian P
This was my go to pizza place. I am really disappointed that they stopped cutting their pizza into normal “triangular” slices. Round pizza should not be cut into little random rectangular pieces. It made me very sad, and I might have cried a little.
… more
Adam Hughes
Had a mix up and ruined my pizza. Owner tried to give it to me for free. I refused. I know accidents happen and wasn’t a big deal. The remake was worth the wait! It was excellent! Very nice people and very tasty pizza. I would recommend artisan crust.
… more
D Smyff
I can’t say tht me and the Queen were impressed by this place,the veggies on the pie were from a can and tasted JUST like they did smh
… more
Jennie Miller
We placed our order on line before they opened. When we arrived they were pulling the last pizza out of the oven. The young lady that helped us was nice and the Pizza’s were great! We had a BLT pizza (which I will be getting again), a pepperoni, meat lovers, and the works ( I think that’s what is called similar to a supreme). All of them were delicious….I will be going back and try more than just pizza…great job guys!!!!!
… more
Tara Stafford
Hands down best pizza I have had. I grew up eating Michael’s pizza, which is what this started out as, and I love it. Then new artisan crust is amazing. Not only is it great pizza, but fantastic customer service! I incorrectly ordered my pesto chicken pizza(choose 10” instead of 12”) thinking I was getting artisan. When delivered I called thinking they made the mistake, but it was actually me, and they still made me a new one and re delivered. I will continue to recommend.
… more
Sherri k (SherriK)
The first time I ordered, the pizza looked just like the pic and tasted amazing. Ive ordered about 5 more times and it’s just been… meh. The middle of the pizza seems to always be under cooked and the Greek pizza has no flavor at all. The BBQ chicken pizza is my son’s favorite and always tastes good after you put the toppings back on (like I said the middle do hold the toppings). The pepperoni is good. Delivery is good too – no probs.
… more
Wayne Beemer
Pretty darn good Pizza, nice thin crust, very generous with the toppings. Their Chicken, Meatball, and Sausage sandwiches are good too. And they Deliver. Service was good also. Will defiantly go again. For the record there are no Pizza places in Ohio that I would give 5 stars to, so this is top rated. I love that this is family owned and operated and NOT a franchise chain.
… more
Blake Wolfinger
The hand toss sourdough is awesome! I wish they would go back to square slices instead of the pie cut. That’s my only complaint. I rarely give out 5 stars. You would have to impress me to get that fifth star. You can’t go wrong with them.
… more
… View more