Based on 164 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout
Address:
11255 OH-800 NE, Magnolia, OH 44643
Phone: (330) 866-2397
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 2–8 PM |
| Thursday | 2–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 2–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 2–8 PM |
Reviews
Vicky Wantz
The pizza was very good and I’m sure as we try other foods you have the stars will get better.. Good job guys.. The young man who waited on us was very nice.
… more
Jaime Hamilton
Pizza is great, but menu you post on Facebook does not indicate prices for specialty pizzas or toppings. When your menu shows $15.50 for a pizza w/ 1 topping and additional toppings are extra, we didn’t quite expect it to double in price for 3 more toppings. Think $56 for 2 meat pizzas with an added topping is a little steep. Love the quality though and the sauce is great, on the sweeter side if you like that. The crust also has a sweet after taste. All toppings tasted fresh and good quality. Only downside was the confusion with pricing, would suggest adding pricing of all pizzas including the specialties on your menu and the price of toppings. I feel this would be a simple way to avoid further confusion. Unfortunately for this price, will not be returning.
… more
Bob Shaffer
Pizza was comparable to a Chef Boyardee pizza in a box kit. Would not recommend it to anyone. They said they sold a lot of broasted chicken, so I might give it a try one day.
… more
sherry fritz
Bought a party pizza. Easily fed our family of seven for two days. The service was good and helpful. The atmosphere is a pizza store without tables. Also bought a specialty pizza last week which was delicious.
… more
John
I don’t know what you did to your pizza but the one we got last night was like it came from a completely different place. Everything from the crust to the sauce, toppings and cheese was so inferior to what it used to be
… more
Sandra Jones
I’ve always bought Crossroads pizza from either Malvern or Carrollton but, thought I’d give Magnolia’s a try. I live central to all 3.
… more
Tarrian McClead
This is my favorite pizza place ever! It’s a half a hour away and there is no place to eat inside but we travel for it often because it’s so good! The staff always provides great customer service but It’s the sweet sauce that does the trick and the garlic crust that is soooo delicious! Even my young daughter who hates crust eats it lol! Also I love their boneless hot wings!! 10 out of 10 will always recommend.
… more
Cindy Artino
The pizza is good and I felt fairly priced.
… more
Terri Lemasters
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten.
… more
Devin Piatt
My partner was given food poisoning from the Chicken and I got sick from the sausage. The entire pizza was, for some reason, salted. There were piles of salt in the corner of the box. The sauce is sweet, which is unsettling for an entirely salty everything else. The pepperoni puffs was a piece of dough with a singular slice of pepperoni in it and was extremely greasy for no reason. I’ve never once had to throw away pretty much a whole pizza, the entire order was $40 and it was a waste.
… more
… View more