Italian Pizzeria, Restaurant and Banquet Hall serving the best in traditional homemade foods since 1967. Our specialties include pizza, pasta, veal, chicken, and many favorite Italian dishes. A family style restaurant; Located in Upstate Potsdam New York, catering to large groups, teams and special occasions /events. Eat in, take out or free delivery!
Old-school restaurant serving pizza & classic Italian entrees, plus beer & cocktails. Based on 519 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
10 Market St, Potsdam, NY 13676
Phone: (315) 265-3420
Website: http://sergispizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 2–9 PM |
| Thursday | 2–9 PM |
| Friday | 2–10 PM |
| Saturday | 2–10 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kyle Hughes
An extremely lovely establishment, with staff that all seemed extremely nice. Even as a gluten free person I was actually able to find great enjoyment in my meal, the gluten free crust was a bit tough but the flavor was satisfactory. I loved the atmosphere and the staff, the wait was a bit longer than expected, having ordered at 5:45 and not seeing our last dish (mine) til 7. But I’d say if you have the time to wait, I highly recommend it, good food, nice staff, wonderful environment. Just keep in mind it’s a busy sit down restraunt and you have got yourself a wonderful meal. My biggest flaw was me not factoring in how busy it was that day.
… more
Michael Kahle
A really nice place that is beautifully decorated. Service is top notch, the waitresses check back often and are friendly. I would say from my experience, stick to the pizza. I had a Caesar salad that was disappointing. The lettuce was soaked in Italian dressing, not Caesar and the chicken was cold and breaded rather than grilled. The breading on the chicken was soggy and for a minute I worried the chicken was raw because it had a strange texture. My daughter had the spaghetti and she said the noodles were kinda soft and soggy feeling as well. The pizza however was delicious so stick to that and you’ll love this place. The other odd thing is that there are tables stuffed In the isles making it hard for patrons and staff to get to and from the booths. I assume it’s to pack as many people in as possible but it really ruins the atmosphere. Just my opinion.
… more
Troy Kent
Thanks to the generosity of some friends, I recently had two pizzas from this restaurant delivered to Long Sault, ON, and both of the pizzas were absolutely delicious! I’m a huge fan of pizza and I am not the easiest customer to satisfy, but Sergi’s pizzas passed the test! I especially liked the crust and the pizza sauce! If you are in the area and enjoy good pizza as much as I do, you need to make a stop here! You will not be disappointed!
… more
Claudiu Carter
An extra large all dressed no sausage pizza from here is overkill even if I haven’t eaten all day. On some days I’ve eaten an entire extra large from some other pizza places. Sergi’s has pizza the way I would want to see it, substantial, but not over-powering crust, delicious sauce and a good helping of toppings. I tend to cook from scratch and not eat out so this was a bit of a treat and a treat it was, thanks!
… more
Jen S
First time here, ordered take out. The inside is very nicely decorated and welcoming to eat inside. I go to the counter and let the lady (with the black hair) know that I am here for my pickup order and give her my name. She goes about her business with running dough through the machine and cashing out two other people. After standing there for about 20 minutes I asked her if my order was ready. She picks up the phone and calls in the back and says to the people that work back there with an attitude, “Where’s the order for ____?” I’m thinking how would the people in the back know I was standing out there if she did not call them to let them know in the first place. A nice young gentleman immediately comes out with my order. When I got home. The food was just as disappointing as the service from the lady at the counter. Huge chunks of sausage on the pizza which we ended up tossing out. My 17-year-old said her dinner was “Meh”. And my other 17-year-olds chicken alfredo had a black hair in it so we tossed that too. Which by the way, while I was standing at the counter waiting for my food. The lady with the black hair handling the money at the register would turn around and stick her hand in the bin of shredded mozzarella cheese that the pizza guy was using and play with it, which is beyond my comprehension. No gloves on, nothing after handling money. That should have been my first sign! Maybe they need a visit from the health department. Never again!
… more
Michael Cyr
Been a customer since 67. In HS we’d stop in for a pie after cruising and before dinner…it was always perfect. They added to the menu when they moved but the pizza has always been the star. When I went to CCT, Sergis za was always Sunday dinner. Over the years the zas have stayed pretty much the same… noticed the sausage has changed, not as much fennel…but still good. I also noticed that the sauce was a bit heavy on oregano. I’ve never noticed that before. I’ve learned to ask for my.pie to be cooked for a few minutes more…that way it’s not doughy. That great cheese needs to brown.
… more
Jason Purdy
What a great team at Sergi’s .. very customer focused and go over and above to satisfy!
… more
Kristin Hebert
Absolutely disgusting! The food is horrible tasteless, gross food. Absolutely no one seems to care how it’s made.
… more
Scott Schluter
Great Hawaiian pizza. Thick crust. Great pizza rolls, dunno why they aren’t calzones and available with all pizza toppings.
… more
Victoria Lorenzi
This place is a wonderful family-owned restaurant. The interior is cutely decorated. The smell of the food is amazing as it fills up the room. Very inviting atmosphere. It’s a seat yourselves type of restaurant. Reasonably priced. Also a very short walk from the SUNY Potsdam campus, about 20 minutes. I recommend this to all of the new students and family members that are visiting this town.
… more
… View more