At My Pie, we pride ourselves on being your neighborhood pizzeria. Our New York authentic pie is built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives. Our motto is local, fresh, fast! We love to source our produce locally, we make all of our doughs and sauces fresh daily and our pies cook up in a New York minute. Our dough and sauces are made fresh, daily using only the best ingredients. Once you taste a My Pie you’ll be hooked! Our quality and flavor far surpass the competition and we’re sure you’ll feel the same way. My Pie is truly a modern classic. It is a place where each guest has the opportunity to custom build their own dining experience. My Pie is located on the corner of Main Street and Shady Lane in Dothan, AL.
Based on 320 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3835 W Main St Suite 3, Dothan, AL 36305
Phone: (334) 305-0100
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Corey Bailey
Staff was friendly and welcoming. We ordered the New York Style, Mr. White, and one pizza with half buffalo chicken. They were great, the buffalo chicken was ok. I would say they have the best New York style pizza in Dothan that I’ve found so far. We’ll definitely be coming back!
… more
Josh Ridlehoover
Food was amazing …garlic knots where amazing pizza was amazing to .. no complaints will be back for sure
… more
Kaska H
I love the idea of a pizza “bar” where you can create your own moving down the line. I ordered calzone, it was OK. Definitely had better but for $10 it was worth it. Could be a little more done than it was. Overall good experiance.
… more
John Gorman
Service was slowed by under staffing. Couldn’t purchase alcohol because no one was of age to sell. Post Covid shouldn’t be an issue? Sign even states they’re short staff and customers should be patient? Soda machine was not working, ice machine wasn’t working. Had to ask for option on beverage… after purchase… staff didn’t remember to after realizing the machine was out of service. Food was average, nothing to write home about. I’m sure staff meant well but without supervision it is clear it’s an operation just trying to meet demand.
… more
john sanders
absolutely love this place! The food quality is always outstanding, and the service is always above the top! If you’re in the Dothan area, and you want great service, and great food, had a great price, you need to stop here!
… more
Steve Frank Films
Very friendly! Great cauliflower “keto” crust! Wish you could leave a tip at checkout on credit card…don’t carry much cash anymore ☹️
… more
Robyn Martinez
Love the the food but unfortunately when I asked if I could get just flats for wings I was told no! I will find another place to go weekly!
… more
Lama Lama
The service was great and the food was outstanding! Pizza and calzone were freshly out of the oven and perfectly baked, and their cauliflower crust was really good. I was satisfied.
… more
Antwayn Spencer
The desert buns were the highlight. The pizza was 7/10. I ordered the NY, and it was not New York, more like New Jersey.
… more
Anthony Roofner
Hands down one of best pizza spots in Dothan. Build your own pizza or select a pre-made and you’ll be surprised how much you get for the price and quality. Friendly staff and great food
… more
… View more
