Familiar American pub grub & a full bar in a historic space with live music nights. Based on 273 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
107 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Phone: (516) 922-9293
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jasmine Cha
The Homestead has the best burger that I’ve had in a while. We stopped by during our trip to Oyster Bay and couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Our server, Katie, was super nice and attentive despite having lots of tables. The lunch menu felt like such a steal and had lots of options. Our group of four ordered two Sriracha burgers, the Texas burger, and the fig and prosciutto pizza and everything was amazing. The burger patty was so much thicker than I was expecting (I had to include a picture just to show how thick it is) and the fries were perfectly crispy. We went on a Monday and there was plenty of street parking nearby. The prices were extremely reasonable and we were absolutely stuffed after.
… more
Dana D’Amico
Hidden little gem . We Sat in the courtyard in the sun.. the homestead salad was huge and really good. Loved the baked clams..it contained the whole clam not just a bread filler the ahituna tartar looked amazing but i didnt eat it ( im not a fish gal). The lobster bisque wasnt anything to write home about. There were no pices of lobster in it…Nor the taste of sherry. The things i look for in a lobster bisque.. i had the crab stuffed shrimp with crispy rissota patty. They were ok but not much crab meat in them .i wasnt impressed with risotto it tasted kind of starchy or pasty.. but thats just my opinion. Salmon was cooked well but it had the nuts on top not necessarily crusted. unfortunately my daughter found around siv small bones in her salmon..so just be cqreful
… more
Gary Miller
The food was surprisingly good! I had short ribs my wife had chicken “schnitzel” with mushroom gravy. Both were very good. We both had a decent IPA from Garvies Point. They also have live music, so a good place to hang out
… more
Marion NYC
Excellent big pretzel! Nice and warm and soft and tasty! This is off the main strip in Oyster Bay with all the stores and restaurants to check out! Food was good. The inside has a lot of history and very nicely preserved. We had lunch there but I think it’s probably has more action at night. I recommend checking this place out.
… more
Vivian M
The best oreo martini I have ever had!!!
… more
Howard
We visited when they were a somewhat rushed for service and therefore had to wait a little, but the staff were friendly and understanding (we had young kids with us that needed food thrown into them). The space and decor is dark but well designed as a warm feeling space erring on the traditional pub design. The menu looks to be regular pub-grub but actually is a higher standard: the burger was quality (a generously proportioned) but the pulled pork was fantastic.
… more
Josh K
I’ve been to the homestead on multiple different occasions and have really enjoyed their food and hospitality. Recently this past weekend I was there with 14 people that we had made reservations for on a Sunday afternoon.
… more
Mara Leonardi
Great food, great waitress. Good beer selection. Solid neighborhood restaurant. Everyone enjoyed their food and we felt right at home. I can’t believe I’d never been here before.
… more
Clara Samuels
Very friendly bartenders and atmosphere. The bacon cheeseburger actually knocked my socks off. The meat was definitely quality. Highly recommend for a good time and good food!
… more
ed hoffman
My fiance and i had a wonderful time there. There atmosphere was cozy even at the outdoor tables. The food was excellent (definitely get the mussels) the service was excellent even though it was our watresses (stephanie) first night there. She couldn’t accommodate us enough. The absolute cherry on top was the live music which absolutely rocked and made the nights experience that much more perfect. Big shout out to bob-tony trio
… more
… View more