Seat-yourself joint with a retro vibe supplying New American pub grub, happy hours & weekend brunch. Based on 689 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085
Phone: (614) 846-1107
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–2 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
ryan
we stopped here on our way home from a concert in columbus desperately searching for a sit-down restaurant with parking. this place happened to be next to another spot we were wanting to check out, so we stopped by! and boy we didn’t regret it. i believe the owner or one of the managers asked us very kindly to change tables for a larger group, which we had no problem with because we hadn’t even ordered drinks yet. he insisted he buy us some donuts for the trouble, so incredibly kind, PLUSSS the donuts were delish. my boyfriend got the chicken & waffles, and i got the pesto egg sandwich. everything was great and only around $20 for two. think about coming here!!!
… more
Peri (Smoppet)
A little spot my sister and I spied while leaving her doc appointment. We spontaneously went inside for lunch! It was seat yourself and wasn’t busy. I ordered pulled pork the day before from somewhere else, but ordered it again here because I was having an obsession. The food was great! I’d definitely love to visit again when I’m on that side of town.
… more
Elise Garber
When I found OTC line, I was pretty excited by the menu options. There was a good variety, including a lot of options for children, which is important for my child with food issues.
… more
Steve Costa
Nice place! Very good food and menu. Bloody Mary’s and service were also top notch.
… more
Benjamin Cooksey
My wife and I went to Over The Counter for the first time. It is a really nice place, lots of seating, many TVs playing sports games and various other things. My wife had the Rueben and said it was amazing. The BLT was also great, and so was the Mac and cheese (we had already eaten a bit of our food before I thought to take a picture). Seems like they probably have crayons and paper available for kids because they had a whole wall covered with kids’ drawings. The service was great. They also had clean bathrooms. Would definitely come back.
… more
DeEtte DeWeese
Bartender knew her wine ! She listened and suggested something that did NOT disappoint. She then had me exhale as I sipped and I tasted the chocolate She was referring to. What a fantastic experience!!
… more
Ben S.
I loved the lively atmosphere early on a Saturday morning. Music playing, TVs on, and conversations swirling. We kept hearing new champagne bottles pop as the Mimosas were very popular! My kids liked that they had classic cartoons on some of the TVs.
… more
Scott Johnson
Went there to have lunch w a former co-worker. It was my first time there and I will say this is an AMAZING place! The food is “off-the-hook”! Our server was AMAZING! I was unaware of this place before last Thursday but it was “the bomb”
… more
Brittney H
We heard about Over the counter from Yelp while looking for a lunch spot. It was very busy when we arrived with seat yourself service. Luckily we spotted a table that was open pretty quick or we would have been lost.
… more
Kevin Wilson
Fantastic!! Good food, great service! Here’s the cherry on the cake. I also work there. And it’s great, too. The management team are so down to earth and friendly and they care. We joke at times, too.they are better than some of the bigger restaurants around.
… more
… View more