Long-running counter-serve pizza joint also serving stromboli, calzones & Italian entrees. Based on 545 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
755 Memorial Pkwy #205, Phillipsburg, NJ 08865
Phone: (908) 859-0759
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dee Dee
Second and last time. The man who touched the crusts of my pizza without using gloves, also handled my money without using gloves. Very very unsanitary. I only ate the part at the tip of my pizza where I knew wasn’t touched by unclean hands. Too late to try other pizzerias. Pizza did not have lots of flavor. Disappointment after hearing people rave about Nicholosi’s pizza. $2.50 slice. No oil which makes pizza taste good. Sauce was good, but nothing else was above average. Anyway failed my sanitation test so that’s it.
… more
Chuck Mound
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App, this Pizzeria was once recognized as the Best in Warren County. I finally had to chance to pur it to the test. First off, this place was reat hard to find. It is tucked away as part of this massive medical complex. Had to do a few Laos before final finding the location. Not the most friendly service at the counter. The place was clean and had a ton of Pizza Nostalgia. The price was good for 2 slices and a fountain drink for $7.50. However the paper straws are aweful for the drinks. The slice was very greasy and chewy. Crust had no taste and was not crisp. Sauce was the highlight and they were not shy to use it. Very Good. Overall middle of the road compared to the rest of the state. I would give them another try next time in the area. This time I will be able to find the Pizzeria.
… more
John Brescia
Been coming here since I was little. I can’t even remember when I started coming here. My father knew Angelo in Queens. I’m a pizza maker nowadays and I love this place. They have those old classic ovens that have been there longer than me and the pizza is just special.
… more
Dan Perez
The pizza is perfect and it’s no wonder why Nicolosi’s is the longest running pizzeria in Jersey. Sicilian and regular pizza is the only thing on the menu since 1964 which is probably why they are so good at it. The pizza has a perfect blend of a great homemade sauce with really good cheese topped off with a very good amount of oregano. The flavor brings you back to how really really good pizza tasted back in the day. The location is family owned and the family and staff are always friendly and greet you as soon as you walk in. Nicolosi’s also delivers and is the fastest at it too. Generally less than 30 minutes or less from the time you order. I highly highly recommend trying Nicolosi’s if you are a pizza lover!
… more
Sam
Food is decent . Definetly better around . Wouldn’t go out of my way for this place . Also it’s 2023 and they are still cash only . Forced to use atm with a fee.
… more
Becky Konapelsky
Excellent pizza! Great family owned restaurant. I will definitely go back!
… more
Kevin Sirotnak (Personal)
A hometown favorite! You can’t go wrong with a slice here. Crispy crust, flavorful sauce, yummy cheese and topped with pepperoni. Add your garlic, oregano and pepper flakes if you like. Wash it down with a soda. Go all the way! No diet here.
… more
Renato Santamaria
The Pizza was fantastic! A gentleman by the name of Jarred helped me out. The service and food were both high quality.
… more
Dondeana Dickey
Best pizza I have had in New Jersey so far, it’s legit! Sauce is incredible. Cash only though!! Still gets 5 stars, I’ll know for next time.
… more
Annie Blue
Not sure why there are mixed reviews, but this is definitely high on my “best pizza” list. The sauce is the best. The crust is thin yet crispy. Light and delicious. Tried the Sicilian as well…the bottom is crisp, and the dough was thick and soft, like biting into a cloud. Some bites more saucy, others more cheesy. Might ask for extra cheese next time. Absolutely delicious. Can’t wait to go back. Staff was friendly.
… more
… View more