I Love NY Pizza & Subs Menu – Orlando, FL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Orlando, FL

Pies, slices, stromboli & Italian dishes round out the menu at this unpretentious pizzeria. Based on 471 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

I Love NY Pizza & Subs 32835

Address:
6602 Old Winter Garden Rd, Orlando, FL 32835

Phone: (407) 293-7020

Website:

Hours

Saturday 10 AM–10 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–10 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–10 PM
Thursday 10 AM–10 PM
Friday 10 AM–10 PM

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Senen Quinonez
The best pizza in the whole entire galaxy. If you can find a pizza place better, I’ll give you $1,000,000 cash personally. There hasn’t ever been a place such as this one. The owners must have the Midas Touch because everything they make is GOLD! The Lord of Lords must have blessed this shop because I have yet to find another experience like this. I LOVE NY PIZZA & SUBS. THEYRE THE BEST OF BEST.

… more

Dee Lewis
The pizza was OK. I probably won’t be back to this location. It was across the street from my doctors office and I love pizza so I was like let me stop. The pictures on the page are great probably when it was brand new now all of the seats are worn out dirty in between the cracks and everything. I usually finish two slices of pizza or lunch special. I ate one and a half.

… more

XclusiveEnt
The Pizza I got was excellent wow. I’m from Jersey and wanted some good pizza I heard pizza wasn’t to good down in Florida like it is up here. I wanted something good for lunch so I opened the Uber eats app looked for something good down in Orlando and said let me try this place and see what it’s about. My first bite I was surprised how good it was. Can’t wait to get it again and try other things there.

… more

Logan Schroeder
Amazing pizza, nothing like this in the world, If ur not here eating pizza then where you at????

… more

Shayla F.
I wanted to try a different pizza place and this one always comes up on my search engine. I’ve been hesitant to try but finally did and they did not disappoint. I ordered through Uber Eats and the food was still piping hot even when it arrived at my house 35 mins later! The meat calzone was amazingggg. The flavor it had was great. The pizza sauce they use has a different taste from most which really made me love it here. Will definitely be back to try more menu items!

… more

Google User
The best pizza and Subs in Orlando. We ordered pizza and Chicken Parm sandwich and it was very delicious. Definitely my spot in Orlando. The owner and staff was very attentive and made us feel like family. Hands down the best! Thank you all for having us.

… more

Eric Wolfe
It’s one of those amazing ” mom & pop” pizza joints.

… more

Kaytee Donohue
Usually go to the same pizza places in the area so wanted to try something different. I was pleased with the food and the prices were decent. It was $23.99 for a large one topping pizza. 10 wings and Garlic knots. Also got a small fire. No complaints on the food all was very good. Wings were nice and crispy just the way I like them. I gave 4 stars because the place did not look well kept and could use a deep cleaning. There was also a man sleeping in the booth with half his body hanging on the floor. A worker came over and kept kicking him telling him to wake up. Very odd. If I had children I would think twice to leave them in the car if picking up food.

… more

LISA
I love this place. The food is fresh and sooo good and served hot. The staff is so friendly and helpful, as well. I always get the veggie stromboli with garlic knots. Try it. You will not be dissapointled.

… more

Joel Jongco
I was craving a couple of slices of NY style pizza and found this hidden jem.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions