Anthony’s Restaurant & Catering in Bernardsville has been in the area for many years. We specialize in residential and corporate catering with party platters and party trays…either dropped off at your desired location, or conveniently ready for you to pick up. Let us help make your next gathering more special and certainly easier for you.
We use the freshest and finest ingredients available and we take a great deal of pride in our work. You can order just one or two items to enhance your own menu, or we can assist you in planning the entire menu for your affair.
Based on 61 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
12 Claremont Rd, Bernardsville, NJ 07924
Phone: (908) 766-6535
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kristi MacDonald
I have been let down so many times by this pizza place. I am amazed by any positive responses given we are in Jersey where some of the best pizza can be found. This place: Not fresh cheese, bad crust, meh sauce, and unpredictable by day. Even after a bad pizza experience at Anthony’s we would return once in awhile only to find it was typically bad. I never understood why they didn’t improve their pizza but maybe not many residents gave them feedback.
… more
Jeremy Back
i didnt have the pizza so cant comment on that but got the family meal deal with caesar salad, chicken franchise and penne vodka and wow there is so much food and quite good, def going to be coming back as this was first time coming after getting mailer
… more
Chuck Mound
This was the 2nd Pizzeria on the lunch time Pizza Hunt..O waited a good 10 minutes to be served as they were on the phone fielding a complaint about the food. This gave me time to menyander around the counter area. If this was an episode of Kitchen Nightmares, Gordon Ramsey would have attacked the amount of dust on the shelves and the amount on the fan that was over all of the Pizza. The outside appearance of the building itself was filthy. This is Bernardsville. Anyway, this led to the Pizza, which was not good. Simply as that. The man was pleasant behind the counter and provided good customer service. Maybe I caught them on a bad day.
… more
Pat G
Was driving North Decided to get off highway for some pizza. Meh should have just waited till I arrived up North for good pizza. Not knocking the pizza too much, but have to review. Slice small and very thin, cheese was as thin as a sheet of wax paper and see through, Sauce tasted a little bitter. They stretched a three star because the owner at counter was very nice.. and hec two slices and a soda for $ 5.00 was not bad deal. Still should have continued driving not worth getting off at the exit.
… more
sal tirone
We loved our pie! Thank you! You can taste that they actually use fresh ingredients and not ones that have been sitting in the fridge.
… more
richard abel
Food was fine until we got to the “dessert pizza.” It tasted like lighter fluid/fuel was poured over the crust and covered with nutella which made it inedible. We called Anthony’s to notify them that their oven must have not been lit, causing the crust to be saturated in gas. Their response was condescending and dismissive. My biggest problem was not the terrible tasting Nutella pizza, but the lack of concern the restaurant showed for its own mistake. We were told that we would receive a call from the owner to discuss/rectify the situation, but not surprisingly, we still have not been contacted.
… more
Sameer Malhotra
Took a friend from Texas there for some authentic Jersey pizza and was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the pizza and friendly staff.
… more
Mark C.
Literally thin cardboard. Margarita had no cheese and the back was coated in flour. I’m not one to even leave a review but this was just embarrassing for New Jersey standards.
… more
gilbert thompson
Enough is enough. This place is run by a bunch of yahoos. At times it could be great but 95% of the time the sauce is inconsistent and the pizzas that are shaped like Easter eggs are half raw. The wings feel like they are precooked three days ahead and are on their way out. Keep giving them a try but we are finally done as I clutch the porcelain god.
… more
Decio Gaeta
i get delivery from these guys about once a month. Love the food every time. Everything has been delicious so far and ive tried different pizzas, entrees, and apps.
… more
… View more