Based on 257 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5 York St, Wellsville, PA 17365
Phone: (717) 432-9443
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amber Sowers
I love supporting local business. Tried here and won’t go back. The restaurant itself is in poorly condition. I ordered two Alfredo dinners which cost $30 and the picture is what I got. Spaghetti with milk and a ton of Italian seasoning thrown on top. The “breadsticks” are simple strips of plain pizza dough. I’m not picky by any means and I’m eating it because I’m chunky and starving. Just won’t ever eat there again!
… more
George Potter
I had the mamma special cold cut foot long sub. It was packed with meat and very good. It was so big the next time I go. I’m ordering it again and eating half of it and take the rest of it home. I highly recommend it. Matter of fact I’m going there today.
… more
KL Dean
It’s a Small Town Sub Shop owned by local people, and you will find them answering the phone, making pizza, doing the and even washing the floors….. everything!
… more
Johnny Boy
Food is very fresh and they have great customer service! 4.7 / 5.0 stars would recommend
… more
Richard Schaffstall
Ordered a gluten free pizza and a meat lovers pretzel boli for delivery. Apparently this establishment thinks its ok to substitute a regular personal pizza for a gluten free when they are out. NOT OK! This selection was for a person highly sensitive to gluten and had it been eaten the aftermath would have been devastating. And because it was delivered this person had to wait even longer til proper food was prepared before they could eat. As for the meat lovers pretzel boli. Absolutely not worth the money. Other than arriving at room temperature, What meat? I’ve seen more meat in a regular boli anywhere else. This experience was a deal breaker. WILL NEVER DO BUSINESS AGAIN!!
… more
Joseph Barndt
I grew up a mile from here and used to frequent it quite often under the original ownership. Was recently back in town and had a great experience with my wife and young son. He made friends with the owners’ young daughter while we were taken care of. Everything came out hot quickly and tasted good. It was nice to be able to enjoy our meal and watch the two kids have fun. Great job everyone, especially GiGi!
… more
Brian Miller
Great food for a great price with a great atmosphere, and a wonderful crew running it. Had heard nothing, but great things about the place before this, and I can see why. We got a pan of Lasagna and 50 boneless wings for New Year’s Eve. Both things were delicious to say the least. Layers upon layers in the lasagna, and layers of flavor as well. We drove 27 miles one way to pick up our food, and we are more than willing to do it again after our experience.
… more
Wayne Trump Jr.
Excellent as usual. Great family ran and operated pizza joint. The buffalo chicken pizza and spaghetti sub are amazing!
… more
Scott Clark
Very unimpressed by my experience here. I felt as though the food was not very substantial and definitely not worth its cost. I ordered a cheeseburger sub and felt that there was hardly anything to it and the sub was cold. The restaurant appears to be family run and not very professional. I definitely don’t have a desire to return there.
… more
Derek Markley
The absolute best place for eat in or delivery! You must try the cannolis!
… more
… View more