Based on 465 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1176 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461
Phone: (973) 875-3550
Website: https://www.facebook.com/The-Elias-Cole-296784463771453/
Hours
| Tuesday | 8 AM–3 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–3 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–3 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rose Bailey
It is a cash-only business, but we were on vacation so we were prepared for that. We weren’t prepared for poor service. We came right at the change of shift, and somehow fell through the cracks of service. There was a waitress who was leaving, and she obviously cared, as she came over several times before she left. The younger waitress was apologetic in her words, but she didn’t really check on us, except when she brought our food. I ordered a cup of beef barley soup, but she brought the potato soup and then didn’t come back to check. The other waitress fixed it. The food was good, though.
… more
Mary Muscari
Nice place. Had lunch with an old friend I had not seen in decades. We each got a sandwich platter, tasty and generous for the price. Bread was as delicious as others have said. Would have loved to have tried a piece of one of their scrumptious looking pies, but trying to behave.
… more
suzanne RWD
Food is excellent – tastes homemade – wholesome and flavorful – good sized portions – service is outstanding – prices are fair – the atmosphere is friendly and private with plenty of leg room. Old home feeling with a family friendly atmosphere. You can’t beat it! We’ve moved but plan to go back for a meal as often as we can.
… more
Andrzej
I stop there for breakfast, serve was very quick and friendly and the food was awesome.
… more
priti yadav
It’s been good experience. Had egg salad sandwich which was awesome and quantity wise it was double of what my usual diet is but because it was delicious so I couldn’t resist myself finishing it. Also my group ordered one dish from their specials which was good. Coleslaw was also decent. All in all this place is perfect for light and quality food. Service is good.
… more
Emma Johnson
We stopped in here looking for a new breakfast spot to add to our other local favorites. This family owned restaurant was extremely clean with good coffee and great breakfast We both had omletts. I had tomatoe and spinach and his was Sausage, onion, bacon, and cheese. Both with hashbrowns and toast with homemade bread all of this for about for just about $22.00. We will be back.
… more
holly murtha
Stopped on a ride through nj – ordered Elias burger and fish and chips. Tried the pies blueberry and lemon meringue! They were yummy. The fries were good. The bread was really good. It’s made at the restaurant as are the pies. My burger was killed even though I said rare 3 times. The food was brought and the waitress never came back soooo I ate the burger. They never asked if we wanted another drink. Not sure if was just the tent service since covid and they are discombobulated and things take longer or this is how they usually are.
… more
Fehmi Sami Yasin
I’ve been eating here for over 28 years, and I have to say that it is certainly the taste of home, American style. While the normal fare isn’t necessarily anything special, the baked goods including pies and breads made in-house are fantastic. I believe that this place could become next level if more attention was paid to quality and locality of ingredients. I’d love to have a meal here where all ingredients were sourced from the garden state, or at least the tri-state area. I have very fond memories here nonetheless.
… more
Anthony Grazevich
Good burgers good breakfast bad hash isn’t really open that much anymore. Doesn’t accept credit cards debit cards and cell phone payments. Really good coffee and bread and pie.
… more
Filippo Gentile
Great place for omelette‘ s and eggs with house made bread. The homemade cinnamon buns are outrageous.
… more
… View more