New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant Menu – Petaluma, CA

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Petaluma, CA

Compact, old-fashioned pizza parlor also serving pasta, sandwiches & draft beers. Based on 274 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant 94952

Address:
3 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952

Phone: (707) 762-7595

Website:

Hours

Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Restaurant Tip
Restaurant Tip $5.00
Side Orders
Breadsticks $8.50
Cheesy Pesto Twists $11.00
Chicken Strips (6) $11.00
Chicken Wings $10.00
Chicken Parmigiana – Side Order $14.50
Eggplant Parmigiana – Side Order $14.50
House Made Meatballs $12.50
Garlic Bread $6.50
Sausage And Peppers Side $14.50
Sauteed Spinach $8.00
Side Of Pesto $3.00
Side Of Ranch $1.00
Side Of Pizza Sauce $1.00
Build Your Own Pizza
Mini Cheese Pizza $13.50
12″ Cheese Pizza $19.90
14″ Cheese Pizza $21.90
16″ Cheese Pizza $24.90
Specialty Pizza
Mini Combo Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, green pepper, mushroom, onion, olive, and garlic		 $19.50
12″ Combo Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, green pepper, mushroom, onion, olive, and garlic		 $27.90
14″ Combo Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, green pepper, mushroom, onion, olive, and garlic		 $29.90
16″ Combo Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, green pepper, mushroom, onion, olive, and garlic		 $33.90
Mini Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, and meatball		 $18.50
12″ Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, and meatball		 $27.90
14″ Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, and meatball		 $28.90
16″ Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, and meatball		 $31.90
Mini Veggie Pizza
Mushroom, red onion, green pepper, olive, and garlic		 $17.50
12″ Veggie Pizza
Mushroom, red onion, green pepper, olive, and garlic		 $26.90
14″ Veggie Pizza
Mushroom, red onion, green pepper, olive, and garlic		 $27.90
16″ Veggie Pizza
Mushroom, red onion, green pepper, olive, and garlic		 $30.90
Mini House Pizza
Ham, red onion, eggplant, and tomato		 $17.50
12″ House Pizza
Ham, red onion, eggplant, and tomato		 $25.90
14″ House Pizza
Ham, red onion, eggplant, and tomato		 $26.90
16″ House Pizza
Ham, red onion, eggplant, and tomato		 $28.90
Calzones
Sm. Combo Calzone $27.00
Lg. Combo Calzone $31.20
Sm. Veggie Calzone $24.90
Lg. Veggie Calzone $28.90
Sm. Meat Calzone $23.90
Lg. Meat Calzone $29.90
Sm. Ham Calzone $19.90
Lg. Ham Calzone $26.90
Sm. Spinach Calzone $19.90
Lg. Spinach Calzone $26.90
Sm. Eggplant Calzone $20.90
Lg. Eggplant Calzone $26.90
Sm. Cheese Calzone $17.90
Lg. Cheese Calzone $24.90
Sandwiches
Italian Sausage Parmigiana Sandwich
Sauteed onions, bell peppers, mushrooms, jalapeno peppers, spices and basil. Topped with our fresh marinara and mozzarella.		 $13.90
Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
Topped with our fresh marinara and mozzarella.		 $13.90
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Topped with our fresh marinara and mozzarella.		 $13.90
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
Topped with our fresh marinara and mozzarella.		 $13.90
Chicken Milanese Sandwich
Breaded chicken breast, mayo, lettuce and tomato.		 $13.90
Philly Steak Sandwich $14.90
Turkey Sandwich $13.90
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Heated or cold with lettuce, tomato and vinaigrette.		 $13.90
Submarine Sandwich
Heated or cold with salami, ham, lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone, jalapeno and vinaigrette.		 $13.90
Tuna Sandwich
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, vinaigrette, minced carrot, celery, bell peppers and red onion.		 $13.90
Veggie Sandwich
Cold or Sauteed, lettce, tomato, bell peppers, red onion, mushrooms, olives, jalapeno peppers, provolone and mozzarella. (No lettuce on sauteed)		 $9.50
Pastas
Spaghetti, Linguini, Rigatoni, Parpadelle Or Penne $14.50
Ravioli $15.95
Linguini $16.45
Gnocchi, Tortellini $15.00
Fettuccini $15.50
Parpadelle In Alfredo Sauce With Tiger Prawns $21.95
Baked Pastas & Specialties
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Boneless chicken breast filled with blended Swiss and American cheese and ham, then covered with subtly spiced breading.		 $17.50
Cheese Stuffed Shells
Includes five jumbo shells stuffed with our four cheese and herb stuffing.		 $16.00
Chicken Shells
Includes five jumbo shells stuffed with our seasoned shredded chicken.		 $17.50
Veggie Shells
Includes five jumbo shells stuffed with Swiss cheese and ricotta.		 $17.50
Braciola Eggplant
Lightly breaded eggplant rolled with four cheese and herb stuffing.		 $17.50
Lasagna
Layered lasagna with mozzarella, Parmesan, ricotta, Romano cheese, eggplant, ground beef and ham.		 $17.50
Cheese Manicotti
Egg pasta filled with ricotta, Imported Romano, Parmesan and mozzarella topped with a red sauce.		 $17.50
Meat Manicotti
Egg pasta filled with Italian sausage, ricotta, Imported Romano, Parmesan and mozzarella topped with a red sauce.		 $17.50
Salads
Chef Salad
Mixed greens, mozzarella, olive, onion, bell peppers, tomato, egg, salami, ham, turkey and provolone.		 $15.00
Tuna Salad Platter
Served on a bed of lettuce with mozzarella, olive, onion, bell peppers, tomato, egg and pineapple.		 $13.50
Side Salad
Mixed greens, chopped purple cabbage, carrots, tomato and onions.		 $7.50
Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce with shredded Parmesan and croutons.		 $10.50
Antipasta Salad
Romaine, egg, salami, ham, artichoke, provolone, Kalamata Olives and fresh mozzarella with vinaigrette		 $17.50
Kids Menu
Kids Tortellini
Base price with butter and cheese		 $6.90
Kids Ravioli
Base price with butter and cheese		 $6.90
Kids Spaghetti
Base price with butter and cheese		 $6.90
Desserts
Cannoli
Filled with sweet ricotta, mini chocolate chips		 $6.50
Cheesecake
with chocolate sauce		 $6.50
Chocolate Cake $6.50
Red Velvet Cheesecake $6.50
Beverages
Fountain Pepsi $2.95
Fountain Diet Pepsi $2.95
Fountain Rootbeer $2.95
Fountain Sierra Mist $2.95
Izze Sparkling Juice
Clementine, Pomegranate, Blackberry or Pink Grapefruit		 $2.75
Bottled Still Water $2.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Lana Rivera
Quite place for some good pizza. Owner was there such a cute lady. Had the meatball sandwich good but a little dry. Pizza is good fresh dough. When ordering a salad may want to ask for dresainf on the side they put a lot on. Reasonably priced.

… more

Raymond Leon
ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT! We were trying to decide where to eat dinner while we visited Downtown Petaluma and parked right in front of the restaurant. We were so impressed with the home cooked meals we received, it has this welcome feeling and old fashioned atmosphere that is hard to find nowadays.

… more

Beth Shepard
We have a lot of great pizza in Petaluma but I love the New Yorker. It’s a slightly floppy (less floppy than what I’ve had in NY but I prefer it that way) NY style pizza with a perfect sauce and always consistent with cheese and toppings. I love the oregano sprinkled on top, and they have an amazing family size Fettuccine Alfredo, pesto twists and a nice GF crust if you’re into that. We’ve also really enjoyed a side of meatballs and chicken parm on occasion. Best pepperoni pizza in town!

… more

Joanna Cassese
Pizza was very close to New York Pizza. The ingredients were fresh and very tasty. Service was very friendly!

… more

Maureen Borthwick
Decent pizza, however, business practices are questionable. It’s apparently best to order through Door Dash as they prioritize Door Dash deliveries over direct call in orders. My husband went to pick up our order and the woman at the counter told him that Door Dash orders came in after ours so they pushed our order back… He had to wait an additional 25 minutes for our 2 pizzas (total 60 minutes when we were originally told 20-25 mins on the phone). Again, pizza is good but policies are questionable. **I will note that the Manager did give us one of our pies for free as an apology for what happened.

… more

Roeene Tyler
This is a hidden gem of a restaurant! We usually eat here before seeing a show next door at the Mystic but it’s worth the drive to get the lunch special – only $12 for pizza, salad, and a drink! The sauce is perfect and everything we’ve tried has been delicious, the staff is warm and welcoming. Stop by and support this small, local business. You won’t be disappointed.

… more

Jes Doy
super friendly highly recommended it’s the pizza place of the town. come and try it. they really care.

… more

V Maxeno
Great family pizza place. The space and 1st impressions are not very inspiring but the service and excellent food totally made up for it!

… more

Deanna Chase
The late night pizza urge took over and we remembered pizza by the slice!

… more

Rafael Garcia
Great service/staff. Amazing pizza.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch