Upscale contemporary American menu plus a cocktail lounge featured in a warm, historic hotel. Based on 106 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
1625 Hinman Ave, Evanston, IL 60201
Phone: (847) 570-8400
Website: http://www.hearthrestaurant.net/
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Erin McKeon
Delicious dinner and dessert, amazing atmosphere and service. Would recommend the purple rain cocktail, BBQ shrimp appetizer that comes with fried green tomatoes, the Parmesan crusted filet that comes with mashed cauliflower and broccolini, and both the sorbets are delightful. The staff even signed a birthday card for me – it was so special! We sat on the patio on a nice evening and it was so quiet and peaceful, but the decor inside looked very quaint and comfortable as well. Absolutely top notch in Evanston!
… more
Amy Zanlungo
Love the ambiance of this place; feels like an old southern mansion converted into a hotel/restaurant. Appetizers left a little something to be desired (they were good, not great), but entrees were phenomenal. Cozy, quiet feel, great for dates.
… more
Carrie Katz
Yummy starters! Shared the beets, squash and the winner was the cauliflower. The blood orange Manhattan was not the best twist on a classic, but the wine list was nice. Dinner of scallops and steak, both of which were stellar, with the side of crispy potatoes were rich in depth and layered with flavor. Dessert was a let down, with an extra charge for a substitution of oatmeal ice cream instead of the cranberry sorbet, with the apple pie and the banana bread was ok. The service was fine, but nothing memorable.
… more
David Eldridge
Really enjoyed our dinner. Happy hour beforehand allowed time to relax. Appetizers were all tasty including the “famous” avocado fries, I also enjoyed the pork belly which was a better piece of meat than some bellies around town that are too fatty.
… more
Tanner Pachis
This restaurant doesn’t get enough credit. The cozy and home type feeling of the restaurant is unmatched. We had a drink before in the lobby across from the restaurant and service and drinks were great. Then we were sat and everything we ordered was excellent. Apps- tuna tartar & cauliflower (seriously!). Main: 3 of us had scallops, 1 duck- both excellent!! I live in the City and will be back for sure!!
… more
L S
A friend surprised me for a birthday dinner here! Possibly the best dessert I have ever had. Staff even signed a birthday card, which is totally weird and awesome! The food is beyond fantastic. Drink are amazing! Staff is super friendly. Can not reccomend more highly. The level of cuisine for the price is outstanding.
… more
Samantha Duncan
Love Hearth! I was a couple-time visitor of Quince and loved it, but also love the homey, comfortable hearth. The fireplace is lovely in the winter, and the Homestead is such a great place to enter for a meal! I’ve only been to Hearth for brunch, though I’ve been several times. The menu is succinct, but really well thought out. I’ve also been for a New Years Brunch buffet and loved it!
… more
Evelyn Riedel
Excellent dining experience. The tuna starter was delicious, and both the duck breast and the Wagyu beef entrees were outstanding. Good wine selection. Service was attentive, and I got the impression that the staff genuinely enjoyed working there. The Homestead is my favorite hotel in Evanston, so to have such a quality restaurant on the premises is a much-appreciated bonus.
… more
Brock Maxwell
Delicious food; nice, refined, comfortable setting. Perfect portions, entrees were well-balanced, seasoned nicely, and presented beautifully. Especially enjoyed the short rib entree and the bread pudding dessert. Thanks for a lovely dinner, Hearth!
… more
Kevin K
We enjoyed our dinner here. The wine selection was good and the cocktails were delicious. We had a number of smaller plates and they were all excellent. The beef tenderloin with spaetzle was one of the best dishes i had this year.
… more
… View more