Based on 43 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
Address:
6300 Mechanicsville Tpke B, Mechanicsville, VA 23111
Phone: (804) 522-1358
Website: http://pepicellis.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tonya McKinney
We usually have no complaints about this place. but tonight 12/14/2020 I placed a $60.00 order and gave a nice tip. Well the subs were cold and the bread was hard, the bacon was hard couldn’t eat it was that hard I think the food was from yesterday. The onion rings looked like they were cooked yesterday look at all that grease and last but not least when you leave a $10.00 tip the least you can do is be Nice and say Thank You. She never even spoke
… more
Sean Hill
Ordered a pizza for delivery at 629 online, thesite quoted about 715 for delivery. Called at 740 asking for an update, I was told it was about to be coming. A little late but fine. Pizza finally arrived just before 8, cut off center and cold. The delivery driver blamed the website. If I wanted reheated pizza I would have pulled digorno out of my freezer.
… more
James Boswell
Way cleaner and more professional looking than their Ashland location. Food is nearly identical between locations which is a good thing. Martha is the best assistant manager and worker for Pepicelli’s. The General Manager, Mike, is a bit of a weirdo and can’t take helpful criticism.
… more
Stephanie Linkins
Friendly staff, clean dining area, they have something for everyone! They even have vegan chicken, vegan chorizo and vegan cheese!
… more
Peach Perrychute
Only ate their cheese pizza and the cheese was delicious, the sauce was a little bit on the sweet side which was also delicious, and the crust was exactly how crust should be.
… more
Keith Hennett
Never have eaten here and I did not try the pizza. Instead I tried the Steak and Cheese. First the good. Plenty of steak on the sandwich. Also it is cooked in the oven like their pizzas which creates a nice crusty crunch on the bun. Now the bad. Because it is cooked in the oven the steak is bland. None of the steak seasoning like you get when the steak is grilled. My grilled onions were raw onions. I imagine because again I doubt the oven would cook them enough like a grill. Way too much lettuce enough easily for 3 sandwiches. In the end I just can’t recommend their steak and cheese as it is just not grilled like it should be. Hope the pizza is better.
… more
Angela Al Hasani
It’s amazing pizza Just the right amount of sauce and toppings. We love the fresh crust. And the garlic knots were tasty but they disappeared too quick And, the cinnamon rolls… melt-in-your-mouth delicious with the butter and icing, wow. Delicious experience, with welcoming owners. Congratulations on your new store!
… more
Couyon
Mechanicsville location. First visit. Manager was knowledgeable and very friendly , seemed to be very happy with his job which is a plus. Told me about the fresh ingredients made daily. Good promoter.
… more
Mark Kelly
This is REAL Pizza. I gave five stars to the one in Ashland. Since then I have had two pizzas from the Mechanicville store. Like I said before, this is the best pizza I have tasted outside of New York. I ordered a pepperoni and sausage with extra sauce through one of the delivery companies. Sauce is great. The sausage is not the crumbled up stuff that some places sprinkle lightly on their pizzas. These are ultra-thin slices of links cut at an angle. Then there’s the crust. I hate most crust. I cut it off sandwich bread and throw away most pizza crust around the edges. Not with Pepicelli’s. The crust is slightly chewy and tasty. The difference between this crust and most is like the difference between a great bagel and a store-bought pre-sliced frozen one. Usually my wife won’t eat pizza but she loves these. I used to eat hal of other pizzas,, stick the rest in the fridge and throw it away in a couple of days. Nothing lasts until the next with Pepicelli’s. Do yourself a favor and try it if you really want some good pizza. It’s a couple of miles north of the M-ville Walmart on the same side, set back in a tiny strip mall. Right before Creighton Pkwy. Hurry, it closes at nine o’clock.
… more
Amanda Proost
Awesome pizza!! Highly recommend the margherita pizza!! They also offer vegan cheese. My daughter has a dairy allergy and has tried many different vegan cheese options in the past, but this place is her favorite!! We used the online ordering option and it was super easy and the pizzas were delivered at the promised time.
… more
… View more