Based on 75 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1345 Fairport Rd, Fairport, NY 14450
Phone: (585) 388-7700
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Reviews
racerpoet
Caraglio’s was one of my main spots to get lunch when I used to work in Fairport. Their slice subscription deal is unbeatable. I still stop by sometimes when I’m in Fairport or working on a Saturday.
… more
Dr. T
The combination of sauce, cheese, and bread forms the perfect amalgam that is extremely piquancy. I highly recommend this exceptional establishment for its pizza and wings. My only regret is not ordering more, truly a perfect experience.
… more
Punky Starwood
Lunch-2 slices and 20 Oz. Drink for under 9 bucks! Friendly helpful staff. Quick for take out! Food was awesome. I loved the country sweet chicken pizza. Medium thickness crust style. Will be back for more!
… more
b wright
NEVER AGAIN. 1st time ordering on Saturday November 26 2022. Two boxes were thrown on the front porch in two calzone boxes. One half of the calzone was gone and the box was open.
… more
Sarah Cole
An hour late delivering food. When I ordered at close to 7. Promised food at 7:56. Probably won’t order again. Called to ask where the food was. I was told a few minutes almost 20 later did it show up.
… more
Greg Knicley
While the pizza, wings and sandwiches have been very good, the last two online orders have left food off of when we picked them up. We’ve had to drive back to the restaurant to pick them up with only a ‘sorry about that’. Not expecting anything in return, but definitely disappointing. Check your order before you leave!
… more
Courtney Colletta
Tried this place at first because it was on my way to my grandmas and it was easy enough to grab us something on my way to visit, but I have to say I am so in love with the pizza here. Cooked right ,lots of toppings, and the dough is perfectly balanced with the crispy/chewy. I personally love the deal they have on Wednesday. Also anytime I bring this to someone who hasn’t had it I always get the “where did you say this was from? It’s so good!” And no one has been disappointed. My go to local pizza spot for sure.
… more
sarah
I thought Marks Pizzeria was good… I will not have any other pizza ever again unless it is Caraglios. In my opinion, the dough is the best. Absolutely BEST. I don’t know how to explain it but it chewy but cooked through. I order Pepperoni and always get Cup N Char as the topping. My favorite special is on mondays…a LARGE PIZZA FOR $11!!!! Feeds my whole family along with 2-3 slices to take home for left overs. The left overs are just as good if not better than when firstly cooked and that’s using a microwave to reheat. Everyone has their own preference but you should really try this pizza. Thank you.
… more
Avik Ganguly
Pizza is generally good, we used to order from them in Greece, and since our move to Perinton we started ordering from the new Fairport location. I would say we order a fairly significant amount of pizza and wings in any given year. I was disappointed with the customer service on my most recent order. I ordered a 1 topping sheet pizza deal, however when the pizza was delivered there was no topping. I wasn’t going to bother calling about it, however given the number of times we order I figured I would call and let them know and request a credit for a topping on a future order. The person who answered the phone indicated they were a manager and that although my order (done on the app) was for the 1 topping special, I must not have selected a topping (I believed I had selected pepperoni). When I said I was only looking for a credit for a topping on a future order I was told there was nothing he could do because he can only go off of what I had requested in the order. I asked if that was his customer service solution, basically blame the customer over a $3.49 request. I apologized to him for wasting his time on something that was clearly my fault and that was that. For those who care about good customer service perhaps try another location. If it is not a big deal to you, then you will get a decent pizza from Caraglios.
… more
Bly_The_Wood
Took more than an hour and a half when we ordered hours before hand. I am very disappointed and all they offered us was 25% off the next order. There will be no next order, I will never be going back. Called one of the managers and he basically told me I was being unreasonable. I ended up just picking up the order myself because I obviously could not rely on them. Tried to give the new pizza place a try and I regret it. I wish I could give this place 0 stars.
… more
… View more