We are a family owned pizza restaurant based in the Sarasota, FL area right off of highway 75 and have the best pizza in town! Come in to try for yourself today or check out our delivery times for the day/evening times. We serve delicious NY style pizza, pasta, homemade subs, beer, wine, salads, and more! We also offer indoor and outdoor dining. Contact us today for further information!
Based on 153 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5501 Fruitville Rd, Sarasota, FL 34232
Phone: (941) 378-1126
Website: http://www.pizzachefofsarasota.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
A “FC” S
Family owned ,been there for the past 23 years ,run by Karen and Frank, who are very friendly, the place is so nice and calm, and the food, one of the best meat lasagne and the Italian onion soup we had,waiting to try their pizza too soon, highly recommended.
… more
Martin Armstrong
Came here with some guys from work. Service was decent you have to order first and then they bring your food. Me and a co-worker got the three meat Stromboli it was really good I’d order it again. The other guy with us ordered a Greek salad he said it was good. If I was in the area again I definitely eat here again.
… more
Fatima Konkel
I tried the “Pizza Siciliana”
… more
Donna Wynn
Walked in and was told they were closed, that they close at 7:30, but she had two slices of cheese Sicilian pizza she could put in the oven. I said ok, as I looked around and saw everything had been put away and she was wiping the counters down. She repeated they close at 7:30. I looked at the time and it was only 7:20. She said it was $8.50 and I handed her my credit card. As she was ringing it up she said she made a mistake and it was actually over $11.00. I signed the receipt and waited for the pizza to heat. She handed me the box and while I was walking out she said, “Next time come in earlier.” (There won’t be a next time.) I got home and my husband opened the box and said it was hard as a rock. I looked at it and tasted it – very thick bread, hard, burnt on corners; sauce tasted like pure tomato paste, very little cheese. I did eat a little of the center bread; my husband made a ham sandwich – basically $11+ went in the trash. I don’t usually write bad reviews, and I guess I should have just moved on, but I had told my husband I’d bring pizza home, and I was tired after a long day. Basically this place closes early, not customer friendly, changes prices after you hand them your card, and pizza is one of the worst I’ve tasted!
… more
Dineen Miller
Best pizza in Sarasota. A gem of a find. Can’t believe I did t find this place sooner. Seriously, the best pizza in town.
… more
Victoria Penxa
Pizza in Sarasota doesn’t cut it compared to your typical northern pizza but this is pretty darn good. Great sauce, they don’t skimp on cheese, and the crust is soft but crunchy. Yum.
… more
Apryl Marie
I would really like to leave NO STARS. I am new to the area and wanted to give this place a try. I use to manage a pizzeria in the Tampa Bay area. First off, the lady who answers the phone doesn’t even say the name of the company, nor is very inviting, she answers the phone like as if it’s her own cell phone. The pizza was horrible!! Bland and tasted like straight up tomato sauce! It took a whole hour for my pizza to get delivered to me. I don’t understand why when their not a busy place. The only pleasant thing about my experience was the driver, he was very nice sweet older gentlemen. But really the entire place could do better. I’ll never spend my money there again!! You all get a half star from me. Wasn’t worth the $30 spent at all.
… more
AK KA SRQSKY
Best place to get quality, no nonsense pizza. Karen and her family always deliver amazing pies.
… more
Paige
In town from NY and came here because of the reviews. The pizza did not disappoint. Absolutely delicious
… more
Jim Hoyle
We found this lovely place today. If your from up north and you miss northern Italian food, this is your place. They make there own bread. I had a hot Italian sub and my wife had there pizza. We both loved our food. Owners are super nice.
… more
… View more