Based on 181 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3495 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213
Phone: (614) 564-9438
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
EJ Calderone – Ring
Oh my gosh! 11 out of 10! Since we found this place I have made my husband get it once a week atleast (I’m pregnant, what the baby asks for the baby gets…haha) He orders it at work too for the guys! Hands down my favorite pizza place. The Manhattan is amazing…coming from a Sicilian lady! definitely worth trying if you haven’t…may just become your favorite! Owners are extremely nice too! All around great experience.
… more
David Duff
Would give it 6 stars if I could. Best pizza in Columbus, especially if you like Chicago style. Have been a couple of times for the pepperoni, tomato, crushed garlic deep dish. Tangy sauce, just the right amount of cheese, and a wonderful crust. Dined in the first time – there is only one table, so call ahead if you’re planning this option. The owners are quite friendly and explained the history of how they got their recipe from Mama Nancy, whose recipe was used to found Uno’s in Chicago back in the day.
… more
Tank Bota
If you are sleeping on MaMa Nancy’s pizza then you better wake up and smell the sweet tangy sauce, cause their Pizza is so delicious! So far I’ve tried the 6″ Chicago deep dish cheese pizza. Let me tell ya, with only cheese its amazing, I cant imagine also with toppings! Tangy hearty sauce! Sweet buttery crust! Cheese pull for days! This has become my new fav pizza spot! I tried their traditional style wings with the cajun dry rub and they were so so tastey! Cannot wait to try the other styles of pizza they offer, along w their Stromboli and subs! The family that owns this place is so sweet, precious, polite, and respectful! They provide excellent service! This place also has a drive thru which is so convenient! May God bless Mama Nancys Pizza and the precious owners and their family in abundance in Jesus name! You have won my pizza loving heart yall!
… more
Eric Summers
I absolutely love this place. Their ingredients are very high quality and the sauce is amazing! The Chicago deep dish is authentic and so flavorful. The staff are awesome. I highly recommend. This has become my favorite pizza spot in the entire city hands down.
… more
Sara Lin
Wow, delicious! The owners are very friendly and along with stellar hospitality, they offer many styles of pizza. The Detroit style was especially good with its caramelized cheese crust and rich, saucy homemade tomatoes! We tried the thick and meaty Chicago style as well. We’re from New York, so it was fun to mix it up! I’m so happy we stopped by, thanks for the warm welcome to Ohio!
… more
Timothy Bailey
I love Mama Nancy’s and the owners! Whenever I can, I go in and order a pizza. I also refer them constantly.
… more
Luke Knapke
This place is pretty fantastic. Probably one of the better deep dish Chicago style pizzas out there. We’ll made pizza and the crisp pepperoni is awesome. So good. The crust is not too much bread. I’ll need to try their new York style pizza next time I go there. I also will have to try Meister’s pizza in order to see how they compare. I’ve heard good things about meisters deep dish pizza. Overall though solid place and you can tell the guy that works there really wants to put a good product forward.
… more
Maria Jiannuzzi Johnsen
We tried this pizza based off recommendations of other people who like Lou Malnati’s pizza from Chicago and it did not disappoint! Best deep dish we have had in Columbus! I’m fact we don’t normally eat deep dish here because there’s nothing like the real thing in Chicago but glad we did. The sauce is fabulous and the sausage is very good! This is not exactly like Lou Malnati’s but it is a great Chicago style pizza! Will definitely be back as it is now top on our list of pizza joints in Columbus! The family that operates it is great and very friendly. We open to go in to grab it rather than do the drive through and glad we did so we could chat with them. It’s not fancy and it’s not a dine in place but all we wanted was a pizza we could enjoy at home! Would be awesome if they grew into a sit down place as well.
… more
Zac W
Pizza connoisseur here, and have found another spot to give a try when looking for a solid pie. Saw this place in one of my groups and finally stopped by. Detroit style was a winner in my book. Cooked right, right amount of sauce, good flavor sauce and good portions. Deep dish is good as well but had more of a pasta sauce then a pizza sauce, still good choice IMO. I’ll probably go back and try a Stromboli.
… more
Rick Riley
All three crust styles are amazing. I only wish it was closer to me. Lol
… more
… View more