Based on 356 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1101 York St, Hanover, PA 17331
Phone: (717) 632-0926
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Hicham Maniche
Very nice crew, tasty pizzas and great subs
… more
dawn wildasin
It was a busy lunch time, but we secured a booth! Everything has been remodeled. It’s fresh and clean every time. Booths are comfortable. Food always delicious. Cheeseburger subs are awesome.
… more
David Kessler
Always enjoyed Brothers pizza and subs. The food is great tasting, the service is very good, and is a place we love coming back to.
… more
Dat Steak
Love this place
… more
Maddy Kuhn
Ordered on Doordash. I received someone else’s pizza, so I called back to say that “I think I received someone else’s pizza”. Got petty responses and rude remarks, from I’m guessing the manager. DoorDash did not want to help me, refunded me about half my money, and I’m still waiting on the other half. $42.58 for a pizza I did not eat, and could not eat. Everyone refused to help me when I asked for help. Called DoorDash, got disconnected three times. It’s like the world doesn’t want me to get my money back. Thank you Brothers Pizza! especially for the remarks of ” I didn’t have anything to do with it” “ DoorDash makes your pizza $40” or “ Sorry our menu is confusing.” like what??? still waiting on more than a $9.14 refund because these people refuse to update their doordash options.
… more
Megan Alcott
Wow, what a sloppily made pizza. Stopped here for convenience because it was the only place on the way home. It looks like they put the pizza in the box and swirled it around. There were gaps without any sauce. The crust itself was poorly spread out so that it was extremely flimsy, almost tearing through in places. Again, this was a convenience stop, there are much better pizza places in town. I most likely won’t be back.
… more
Epic Gamer
Ordered large cheese pizza, large pepperoni pizza and a cheesesteak sub. As 37.00$ Sauce was simple (which i prefer)but minimal making pizza dry, cheese was good quality, crust was good. I thought the pizza was burnt on bottom, turned out to be dirty oven char…probably don’t clean ovens enough? Was not appetizing. Would not get pizza here again because I do not like burnt or char on bottom especially for the price.
… more
daddy daughter podcast
The subs were great and the bread is phenomenal. However the men that work there are not very friendly and kind-of creepy. Staring at every date I’ve had or women I’ve walked in with including my mom. Talking in a different language to the other men working and kept looking over and very creepy vibe. I wouldn’t eat there. But if your going to, I would order subs to take home but send your husband or son or a male in to pick up your order.
… more
JB B
Horrible experience. Pizza was absolutely disgusting and cold. Owner did not cook the pizza. It was served RAW! He told us “ no one else complain” so i dont care about you. Our family and friends will never eat here again.
… more
Jason Ewen
Very fast service without compromised taste and quality. Pizza had a really nice crisp, a good amount of sauce and cheese with a very thin crust. We went at a busy time and it seemed like everyone was getting their order promptly. Large indoor and covered outdoor seating area. We will return.
… more
… View more