Based on 114 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
800-6 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967
Phone: (631) 399-2700
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 1–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kevin Breese
Delicious Pizza! We ordered delivery from them twice now and both pies were outstanding. No complaints! And for the record we are kinda finicky with our pizza too. I’m originally from Buffalo, where they have awesome pizza and wings, and I’ve also had a lot of Pizza in NYC too, which of course has the best pizza in the world. Considering that, and being almost 50, I’d say I have a lot of experience and know what good pizza is. 🙂 Only complaint is, both times we requested they text us when they delivered it, and both times they didn’t do it, so our Pizza was sitting out in the cold on our porch for 7-10 minutes each time. Surprisingly, at least it was still warm though, not hot, but warm. I guess because we are so close to them. Still giving them a 5-star rating, because mistakes happen, and hopefully they improve on that.
… more
Henry Canizares
Not the best pizza ever but good
… more
Fronk 2.0
We ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pizza came to $26. I understand inflation and the prices of everything are more now. The pizza was lacking in toppings and was undercooked. We had maybe a chicken cutlet worth of chicken on the entire pizza and the bacon was almost non existent. There are other places in town that can execute a chicken bacon ranch pizza much better. I will give another shot though it was mediocre.
… more
bob smith
I’ve been there twice now and consistently their pizza is very good. I’ve tried a few different types . the owner jerry is a wonderful man. The meatballs were very good. And the sausage and peppers were good as recommend this place
… more
Jacqueline Mckenna
Maybe you should change your hours of business, that way when people come in at 11:23, meanwhile it says open at 11 and your door is open, you don’t get greeted by a rude employee. I order from here alot, but being treated like this, I will give my money to another pizza place that deserves it .
… more
Matt Palladino
Order from here once or twice a week, like clockwork. Mostly the same thing every time, but the consistency is always on point. Friendly staff, the pasta dishes and heroes are great. Haven’t used a different spot in a few years, nor do I plan to. Highly recommend to everyone who asks.
… more
Ben Lembo
This place is terrible. They packaged my food so carelessly it spilled everywhere. Everytime I go there I have to wait twenty minutes to get my food after I already call in and give them almost an hour everytime. And the shrimp parm was absolutely disgusting. The sauce was greasy and the breading was mushy and gross on the shrimp. This pizza place sucks.
… more
Gene Jordan
Went for pizza with the family while visiting the area. Tornado hit while picking up, the staff was kind calm and even finished cooking the pizza and knots! I can’t say enough about how good these people are! The pizza was delicious too!
… more
Alison LaMartina
Great pizza. The regular looked amazing and it was. Every bite had that perfect crunch. Definitely will be back
… more
Ron Santagata
My first time there and was very impressed. Pizza was cooked exactly the way I like it. Sauce was not acidic and pepperoni was delicious. Thank you I will be back.
… more
… View more