We offer authentic New York style atmosphere, pizza by the slice as well as traditional thin crust and specialty thin crust pizza, salads cannoli’s and more. We also offer off-premise catering as well as 2 custom food trucks to cater your next special event.
Based on 496 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1201 Greenwood Park E Dr, Greenwood, IN 46142
Phone: (317) 887-1009
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
William Cary
We found the NY Slice a few weeks ago and my wife and I now come here every Sunday afternoon to pick up a couple NY slices. Their pizza is our new favorite! Definitely worth it!
… more
derrick huesman
Very glad I decided to come here today. I ordered the 16″ big meat Yorker, and it was fantastic. The bread sticks were amazing and fluffy and had lots of flavor. My first time ever enjoying this amazing food and I will definitely come back. The wait was not long at all. Very nice, very nice and delicious
… more
Paige Wyss
Great food… family run business near Greenwood Park Mall. My daughter loves basil and pesto and tomatoes on her pizzas. Anything Margarita Pizza inspired (Pizza Napoleonica) will be her fave flavors. Uncle Dan was so sweet complimenting her choice of toppings and even snapped a pic for himself saying out of all the millions of pizzas he’s ever made, her’s was the best combo, it’s so beautiful. She gave 10 out of 10! High praise from such a persnickety young lady
… more
Miranda Maxwell
Finally, a pizza place in Greenwood for people with taste buds. I got the cheese calzone, roni sticks and a cannoli. Seriously, every single item was made with high quality ingredients, seasoned super well and tastes incredible. Hands down the best Calzone and stuffed breadsticks I’ve ever had. I will probably get 3 meals out of the one calzone, such a generous size and excellent value for the money! I also got my order super quick and the manager was incredibly kind and gracious. 10/10
… more
Brittany Haseman
This is not just a shop serving perfectly cooked and seasoned pies, it is an experience with a chef and staff that truly love their work. Our family loves NY Slice and appreciate how much care and passion comes from Dan when making our pies. We always have a delicious Italian sausage and pepperoni pizza, just the right amount of sauce, and the perfectly cooked crust to enjoy at least once a week! Excellent pie, excellent service and experience. Thank you, Dan!
… more
Zora hodler
Been buying NY Slice at the Greenwood location since they moved there. Top quality pizza. Yes, quality may cost an extra buck or two but way worth it. Spoke to the owner recently that people have been giving bad reviews. The pizza is top notch so don’t go believing every negative review.
… more
Label Guy
I stopped by to grab a few slices to take home to eat later. I originally wanted a slice of cheese and a corner Sicilian piece. I didn’t want it heated up. I was going to eat it later for dinner. The Sicilian was raw and had to be cooked, so I just got one slice of cheese. As soon as I saw it, I had to get another. I could tell it was gonna be good just from the look. I chatted with the owner for a few and headed out. I reheated it up in my oven at 525 degrees until the cheese was bubbling. Even reheated, this might be the best slice of NY style pizza I’ve had. I’ll definitely come back for a large cheese pizza and I’m excited to try the Sicilian. I definitely recommend coming in for a slice or a pie if you’re in the area.
… more
Margarita Santos
We stopped because we were hungry and wanted a taste of home and well they did not disappoint! My family and I are from Queens and we were beyond impressed with the flavor of this pizza. The crust had the perfect amount of crunch and crisp and folded to perfection. We got to meet the owner Dan and he was a swell and genuine guy!! We talked about where he got his ingredients and just felt how much he cared about his craft and pizza shop! If you guys are looking for a New York slice in Indy this is the spot!
… more
Brandon Signorino
A true hidden gem in Greenwood! This counter-serve spot offers tasty pizza, quick service, and reasonable prices. My wife and I were both very excited to try this place and we are very glad we did. I had a slice with bacon and ricotta cheese added and it was truly awesome. We will definitely be back!
… more
Tracy Neihart
I just want to say this is by far the best pizza joint in Indy. The owner Dan is a great guy. He has food trucks available for private events. If you have not tried it yet. Please go!
… more
… View more