Down-to-earth option with patio seating offering classic Italian fare such as pasta & pizza. Based on 603 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
84001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 664-5300
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 8–11 AM |
| Sunday | 8–11 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8–11 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8–11 AM |
| Wednesday | 8–11 AM |
| Thursday | 8–11 AM |
| Friday | 8–11 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Jamie Engel, Florida Keys Real Estate
Fun family style dining experience at The Postcard Inn (AKA The World Camous Holiday Isle). Greetings from the Manager at the door. Friendly service from Kevin who arrived with a great big smile and a wonderful attitude. Delicious food – Chicken Parmigiana, Flatbreads and more. The sound is loud and joyful with everyone sitting and enjoying the food and the company. Stop by and try.
… more
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
Such great food! You will not leave this place still hungry. From the bread that is served that basically melts in your mouth to the chicken parm that has a hint of sweet and the perfect amount of noodles. I ate the entire bowl! It is a bit loud in here as there are no sound barriers so the noise travels. As long as you can get close and talk over the noise the food will make up for it all
… more
Mary Lou
Really delightful dining experience!
… more
Monica Keith
This place is great. Food is soooo delicious! We got the meatballs (yummy) and the prosciutto flatbread. Both were great. And for the drinks we got the mojitos. They’re perfect. Not too sweet, you can taste enough the alcohol without being too much. And the strawberries and mint on it give it a good flavor.
… more
EpikOne
I’ve seen mixed reviews on Google. However, after days of high rated places to great disappointment, this place was a shining star.
… more
Øistein Farmen
Terrible food. The online meny had a lot of courses to choose from, but when we arrived only nine entrees were available. The Bruschetta we ordered was soggy and the parmesan was definetly not parmesan. The main dish, spaghetti and meatballs was even worse. The meatballs seemed like they were cooked in water and just fell apart.
… more
Ĵăķọb Lĕë
Fairly nice place, upscale looks but don’t feel like you have to overdress yourself. Food wasn’t quite up to the price but it was really good and the bacon WAS amazing. The staff was all friendly and the outdoor patio was a pretty enjoyable place go sit and eat.
… more
eri ka
The employees bring me the wrong order . I don’t eat sweets an I did order avocado toast (she bring me after 40 minutes of waiting )French toast so I asked if she would change it she fight me back and said that she write the order right and I did order French toas! I said that I don’t eat sweet and she finally change it . The manager was very polite about it but not the employee. Food looks good.
… more
Sharon Lucas
Andrea gave excellent service today. We were first in the door for dinner. She brought out a basket of bread and olive oil with balsamic to dip in. We had the Portabella mushroom appetizer. Then we split a Caesar salad and each got the lasagna. All huge portions. Kinda wished I’d ordered off the kids menu now. We are part of a large wedding party and the bride came in with her family. Andrea offered us tiramisu or chocolate cake which we sent over to the brides table. Very good food, service and an enjoyable meal tonight.
… more
Hannah Chamberlain
Delightful experience all around! My husband and I are on our honeymoon and stopped in for dinner. The food was fresh, hot, and delicious. Our server Daphne was attentive, friendly, and so much fun!! Thank you Ciao Hound! We will be back before we leave. Definitely one of the best places we’ve eaten so far !!!
… more
… View more