Casual NY Style Pizzeria serving Slices, Salads, Pastas, Heros, Wraps, Soups, Oven Baked Dishes, Classic Chicken, Veal, Eggplant & Seafood Dishes, Desserts, and of course a large assortment of hand crafted specialty pies or build your own. Delivery-Take Out-Catering. Beer & Wine Served. Fast and easy to use ONLINE Ordering system for delivery and pick up orders.
Based on 175 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1372 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 751-3400
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nadine Wilches
The cauliflower pizza is very good (GF). The kids like their regular pizza too. The service is good, easy and quick. The atmosphere leaves a lot to be desired. Aim for take out.
… more
Natalia Ilina
It was delicious pizza for our party. I liked the pizza with pineapple, I’m not sure about the name because I didn’t place the order, but it looks a lot like Hawaiian Pizza (pizza sauce, cheese, cooked ham, and pineapple).
… more
MARIA OLSON
I love this place. I have been going here for years. My favorite… their specialty slices!! All yum!! I have had luncheons here for work related parties, and they do a great job. Luigi’s has a pizza area & and the dining area is a little small but still worth going. You won’t be disappointed.
… more
Jacqueline Rowe
Vegan pizza!! Run, do not walk, for their amazing food. I love their regular pizza but to have a good vegan pizza for my dairy free friends puts them over the top.
… more
Vicky Jones
I used to go to Luigi’s years ago. I came back to LI for a wedding and took my grown children to a “real” pizza parlor, cuz VA does not know what real pizza is. They were blown away and I wanted to move back to LI the next day. I gotta come back up when I have time to kill and eat some of your pizza again.
… more
august west
Gone down hill. The delivery time is getting worse and worse and the price goes up and up . Almost $50 for and half pepperoni pie and a hero delivered. Theres a “delivery fee” on top of the tip so you are in for an extra $8-10 dollars . Our most recent delivery took 1hr and 27 minutes and when I called after an hour and 10 minutes i was offered NO relief . No waiver of delivery fee- nothing . Then our hero was basically cold and pizza was warm , not hot and cheese was different than previous visits. Not sure we will be back . Had they offered a small refund to save a customer maybe it would be a different story.
… more
Afra Rahman
I ordered the Greek wrap and was served the chicken Ceasar wrap instead. When I went back to change it, they argued that because the Caesar had olives, it was the Greek wrap. Then I took the pamphlet to them that described the Greek wrap to be completely different (lamb gyro, tzatziki sauce). They took the wrap to the kitchen to talk with the cook and it was a whole hassle. I offered to eat the food as it was seeing how they were making it a big deal over it and just leaving me hanging. Didn’t offer a refund or anything. Couldn’t finish the rest of the wrap because I didn’t like it. The mozzarella sticks were good. Pricy but good. Very disappointing experience. Will not be back.
… more
David Conde
Not the least expensive place but considering the area and clientele it’s fine. They do have fine in with good service but a significant part of the good is take out and it’s busy! Meatball parmigiana heroes and past rústica are my faves?
… more
C.J. Giordano
I have been a long term customer here and live in the area. Their pene aka asks is great. There garlic knots are also very good.
… more
Carolina Strada
Wow. Very impressed with the quality. We loved the pizza. It is thin, nice texture and the crust is great.
… more
… View more