Based on 47 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
Address:
8990 UT-165, Paradise, UT 84328
Phone: (435) 932-6104
Website: http://www.thestillwatercafe.com/
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bart
This is a quaint little café in the middle of Paradise, Utah. The proprietors are amazing. Super nice to deal with. Super friendly. Down-home country feel here. The food is even more amazing. I’m having the pulled pork sandwich for the second time. It’s a bit of a drive, but come out and give them a chance. OK so this is an update: I just noticed they serve pie here. So I tried the coconut meringue. Looks just as good as it presents itself. It’s actually baked right here in the cafe. OK now you know where to get dinner and dessert.
… more
Edward Hegemann
I heard about Stillwater Cafe from a friend. We decided to make the 15 minute drive from Logan to go try this restaurant we had never heard of before. We were so glad we did!!! There were so many things we liked about our experience. The customer service was excellent. We asked a lot of questions at the counter before we ordered and she answered all of them and didn’t seem annoyed.
… more
Eric Randall
Paradise is beautiful, and I applaud the owners for running a clean, country style establishment with the local feel. I enjoyed walking around and reading a bit about the history and admiring the relics of a simpler life. I can imagine hitching my horse to the post just outside to get a bite to eat. The food, however left more to be desired. The burgers, I had the Wagyu, lacked flavor, moister and sauce. They were also on the expensive side ($14-$15). I would still recommend this place for the experience. You just don’t find local places like this anymore.
… more
D T
Great mushroom burger! Super flavorful and juicy burger! Fries were excellent! Just the right crispness and flavor. Fry sauce was good. The staff was very friendly. Nice little convenience store as well.
… more
Jared Smith
The owner is super nice and always trying new menu items. My food is always tasty and the dessert is always delicious! Nice to have a local place that is really clean and fun!
… more
Bret T.
These guys have pretty good food when you can catch them open. I know it’s crazy to keep up staffing during the pandemic but it’s just a shame that such a fun place to eat is so hit or miss with being open.
… more
Melanie Leonard
Amazing food! We’ve driven by numerous times but unable to stop due to the limited hours, but we timed it perfectly this trip. This is by far the best prime rib sandwich in the state! Tender and juicy and big enough for two adults to share. Rounded out our meal with the to-die-for lemon meringue pie. Four thumbs up!!
… more
Cousin Neo
Amazing food, I have never had better! I hope Stillwater is an amazing diner all over the US one day. Customer service and building is amazing, there burgers are to die for they ground and cut there own beef, and they make there own pies and tarts. There is a little store in the back and it is amazing. I could hang out there for hours, Elon musk needs to try this!
… more
carrot lady :]
It’s a beautiful drive to get to Stillwater Cafe. The place is clean and pretty with a little country store in it for the locals. Our burgers were delicious, big pile of hot seasoned fries. On Thursday’s she makes the best Navajo tacos in town!! You can call in an order and then eat at the park behind the Cafe. Great little cafe, reminds you of the old days where the farmers talk about the weather and water over a cup of coffee!! This place is a must visit!
… more
Stokes Family
Breakfast at Stillwater this morning. Food was great! All you can eat breakfast. Lots of food. The place is in Paradise but well worth the drive. Old country diner feel ,relaxed,friendly. Lisa Gamble and Nicholas Laurence were fun to meet and chat with ,like going to your favorite Aunts for breakfast. Just go!
… more
… View more