Based on 31 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801
Phone: (914) 740-3690
Hours
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 3–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 3–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 2–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Janice Davis
Brother’s Seafood is excellent! Two courteous and friendly young women prepared and packaged our to go order: fried red snapper, teriyaki baked salmon, collard greens, candied yams, and yellow rice. All dishes were delicious and packaged separately! Looking forward to trying other menu items!
… more
Jay Hunt
I saw this restaurant on Uber Eats, but I decided to go into it because I knew it was right there in New Rochelle. The food wasn’t good. The service was excellent. The chicken was old and the fish looked like it was out of a bag of frozen fillets you’d get at the supermarket. I really wanted to patronize a Black restaurant but cmon you have to hire a better cook. I know the owner reads this so I hope he invests in a new cook who will prepare food that tastes good. The folks giving this place great reviews must have never at a quality place. I passed the food to my neighbor’s dog. JH
… more
Craig Kelly
Gave brothers a shot when it first opened wasn’t too impressed at all, decided ill give them another try yesterday & was still disappointed. Dont think they’ll be a 3rd try lol was still hungry after a $35 lobster + shrimp combo plus it just lacked flavor. Great customer service though.
… more
Hope Morgan
The Two young ladies where very knowledgeable about the menu and kind and professional on the phone for I wanted to have my order to go and ready once I arrived….. I tried the catfish with macaroni and cheese and collard greens and all where seasoned perfectly, I also ordered the pineapple ginger juice tasty and yes I will patronize this business for the customer service was awesome kind and welcoming.
… more
Iconic Katia
I cater food from here, and the food was amazing. The fried chicken, Mac and cheese, and jerk chicken was so good. I place the order on Wednesday and it was ready for Friday. I will definitely go back.
… more
Chrystal Ballard
We had Catfish with Cajun fries, Whiting with Cajun Fries, Sweet Chili Salmon with rice, grill shrimp and broccoli. Everything was delicious. I highly recommend it.
… more
Curtis Nelson
I ordered the Whiting combo with potato salad, Cajun fries, and the Shrimp Mac and cheese! Just say this, I have been in the bathroom since 5am this morning. The fish and shrimp tasted old and rubbery. The fries were not good at all. The shrimp Mac and cheese was the worst I’ve ever tasted. To make things worse the two young ladies working there didn’t use gloves to prepare the food. The young lady in the front would take orders then go to the back, without washing her hands; went straight to handling the food preparation with the other female cook. Not a good look! A serve safe food handling course is a must for the woman. I will not be going back and I will not be recommending this food establishment to anyone.
… more
twinmom B
I really hope to increase this rating in a little while because I’ve ordered here a few times now and was excited to have a new spot in the area. The food itself its fine, considering the limited options in new Rochelle. My main concern is with their wait time. 3 times in a row the person I speak with when ordering tells me an inaccurate wait/arrival time. Today the wait was almost 3 times the 15 minutes they quoted. No on provided an update on the food unless i asked. I do only see two people working which is understandable but please be transparent about the wait and a little more courteous while people wait. Willing to try again…Thanks!
… more
Kenisha Smith
I ordered the seafood combo with fried lobster tail and shrimp with fries. The food was delicious, if you want fried seafood but dont live near city island this is the next best thing. I would definitely order again. Only reason i didnt give it 5 stars, was the portions are a bit small but still worth it especially for the price.
… more
Victor Bowman
Well seasoned food with great service on the side.This place restored my faith in quality soul food restaurants. My first time visiting…and the portions and taste were satisfying. I will be sure to return and I encourage you to give Brothers Seafood a try!
… more
… View more