Family-run standby dishing up New York-style pizza, pasta & calzones in a low-key setting. Based on 594 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
411 W College Ave, Appleton, WI 54911
Phone: (920) 955-4444
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Aj Sue
I love this place! Sals pizza is exactly what a downtown College pizza place ought to be… Only the pizza is much better than I ever thought it could be at a college area pizza place!
… more
Wade Schultz
Friendly fast service! Pizza was good. Large pizza is 18″ you can also get a 14″ or pizza by the slice. Large slice of pizza comes with a garlic roll. Most times in and out in 10 minutes. Pizzas and Subs available along with wings, tenders , mozzarella sticks and other appetizers. You can get cannolis , Brownies or an 8 inch chocolate chip cookie for dessert. Unfortunately no alcohol served. Right across from the PAC downtown Appleton. There were 10 different kinds of pizza available to choose from for the by the slice when we’re in there. Workers were friendly and the pizza was good. Reasonable prices also.
… more
Matthew P
Love this by the slice pizza spot.
… more
Scott Travers
Got there early for pickup pizza not quite ready, offered us their famous roll, they were delicious! Pizza was fantastic also! Would go there again!!!
… more
Robert Long
I tried out Sal’s Pizza while visiting Appleton recently. They sell pizza by the slice, and had a variety of options to choose from. I was greeted upon entering the restaurant, and a few people were dining in. The guy behind the counter was friendly and talkative. The pizza comes with garlic knots on top, and both slices and rolls are placed in the oven to warm them up when you order. I found the pizza to be very tasty, with a crisp crust and flavorful toppings. All in all, an excellent experience and great food, will definitely keep Sal’s on my list for future visits.
… more
Tempestt Ballenger
Walked here from my hotel to grab a quick bite to eat. The restaurant was pretty busy when I went and I was still in and out in less than 10 mins. Got two slices, two garlic knots, and a soda for $9.50. Hey it’s nothing to brag about but for that price it’s expected. Nice staff though!
… more
Leesa Adams
It took well over an hour to receive a pizza that was cold. Eat Street delivery. It might have been a good pizza except for that. Sal’s employee who answered my call checking on whether or not they received my order was very polite and helpful. I think it was Eat Street that dropped the ball. I won’t trust a delivery of a pizza from Sal’s after this experience.
… more
Brett Martin
There needs to be one of these in every city world wide. For $5 you can get a slice of pizza the size of your head, a drink, and a garlic biscuit. Their pizza gives so many of the chains a run for their money, they’ve got amazing Mac n Cheese, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken and many more. Go get yourself a slice if you haven’t tried it yet.
… more
Christian Gomez
As a native New Yorker, born and bread in Brooklyn and later in The Bronx, Sal’s of Appleton, Wisconsin is the real deal! It’s authentic New York style pizza just like you would find in almost every neighborhood in New York City. Sal’s is my # 1 go to Pizza place in the northeast Wisconsin. Buy it by the slice! I absolutely love the original plain cheese pizza, but their other toppings are excellent too, like the Margarita slice, BBQ chicken, Mac & Cheese, Baked Ziti, etc… They also make great calzones. My wife loves the garlic knots here too. The ONLY thing missing on the menu are Jamaican Beef Patties. Every NY pizzeria sells pizza, calzones, and yes Jamaican Beef patties. For me Sal’s is a delicious slice of home.
… more
Margaret Namio
We never vist Appleton without stopping at Sal’s for a slice! Generous slices of thin crust pizza. Great variety. Pizza is fantastic and the rolls are amazing. Service is always good. Dining room and restrooms are always clean. Outdoor seating area. Very highly recommend Sal’s Pizza!
… more
… View more