American Pie Co. Menu – Sullivan, MO

Type : Restaurant

Location : Sullivan, MO

Based on 29 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

American Pie Co. 63080

Address:
1017 N Olive St, Sullivan, MO 63080

Phone: (573) 468-2050

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
 Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 7 AM–6 PM
Thursday 7 AM–6 PM
Friday 7 AM–6 PM
Saturday 7 AM–6 PM
Sunday 8 AM–4 PM

Menu

Espresso and Coffee Drinks
Latte
Steamed or iced milk with espresso shots and pumps of flavor if desired		 $4.95
Mocha
White or Dark chocolate sauce in steamed or iced milk with espresso shots and topped with whipped cream		 $4.60
Americano
Espresso shots and water, iced or hot		 $4.60
Macchiato
Caramel, Chocolate or White Chocolate drizzled over espresso sitting on top of iced or steamed vanilla milk		 $4.95
Cappuccino
Espresso shots in steamed milk with lots of foam		 $4.35
Cold Brew Coffee
Dark roast coffee steeped for 20-24 hours. Add flavor and creamer.		 $3.90
Frappe
Caramel, Mocha or Vanilla blended and frozen. Add flavor pumps for extra charge		 $4.75
Chai Tea Latte
Spicy and creamy tea, mixed with iced or steamed milk		 $4.50
Brewed Drip Coffee
Joe’s Blend Highlander Grog French Roast Decaf
Meals
One Entree + Drinks
Your choice of any pie: quiche, pot pie, pizza, fruit or cream with a drink		 $6.95
Two Entree + Drink
Your choice of any two pies: quiche, pot pie, pizza, fruit or cream with a drink.		 $10.50
Endless Garden Bar + Drink
Buffet style salad bar to your hearts content with a drink		 $9.95
Entree + Endless Garden Bar + Drink
Buffet style salad bar with your choice of any pie: quiche, pot pie, pizza, fruit or cream and a drink		 $13.50
Kid’s Meal
Any pie, pizza, or salad with side and a drink		 $6.50
Endless Garden Bar (Ala Cart)
Mixed greens, fresh veggies, house made croutons and dressings		 $8.95
Mini Pies
Granny’s Apple
The American favorite, granny apples mixed with cinnamon and sugar in our homemade flaky crust
St. Louis Blueberry
Sweet blueberries mixed with sugar and a squeeze of lemon juice in our homemade flaky crust
Tart Cherry
A classic with tart cherries mixed in sugar baked in our homemade flaky crust
Spiced Peach
Golden peaches mixed with cinnamon and sugar in our homemade flaky crust
Chicken Pot Pie
Shredded chicken and mixed veggies in homestyle sauce
Shepherd’s Pie
Ground beef and veggies topped with garlic and cheese mashed potatoes
Biscuit And Gravy Pie
Our flaky crust filled with savory smoky sausage gravy
Ham And Cheese Quiche
Diced ham with monterey and jack cheeses
Italian Sausage Quiche
Italian sausage and cheese mixed with sauteed onions and peppers
Mushroom Swiss Quiche
A vegetarian specialty with spinach, mushroom, swiss and feta
Lemon Cream
Perfectly tart and creamy lemon filling, topped with sweet whipped cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate pudding and peanut butter blended perfectly and topped with homemade whipped cream, peanut butter drizzle, chocolate drizzle and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup crumbles
French Silk
Rich chocolate mousse topped with homemade whipped cream and chocolate chips
Coconut Cream
Creamy coconut pudding filling mixed with shredded coconut and topped with homemade whipped cream and topped with toasted coconut.
Pizza
Homemade pizza dough, filled with the best pizza sauce and Italian cheese add up to three toppings
Smoothies
Blueberry Bliss
Blueberries and bananas, mixed with apple juice and yogurt		 $6.50
Peaches N Cream
Peaches and vanilla yogurt blended with apple juice in a whipped cream lined cup		 $6.50
Very Berry
Strawberries, blueberries, and cherries blended with yogurt and apple juice		 $6.50
Mango Tango
Mangos and Pineapples blended with yogurt and apple juice		 $6.50
Build Your Own Smoothie
Choose up to three blend ins: Blueberry Cherry Strawberry Peach Mango Pineapple Banana Spinach Carrot		 $6.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Timothy Helgemo
Just stopped off the interstate because of the billboard east of I44 at Sullivan MO. We had apple pie and tart cherry pies with vanilla ice cream. Great taste and cheerful service. Store is so clean and welcoming. Thank you!

… more

J. Don Book
Fast and friendly service. Clean and orderly (including the restroom). We would recommend the salad bar and Shepherd’s Pie with French Silk pie for desert. Try the jalapeño ranch dressing if you like a little kick to your salad.

… more

Sharon Head
Delicious desserts (I am always trying something new), friendly staff, excellent drinks, wonderful salad bar, one of my favorite places to eat in Sullivan! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

… more

Jen Naslund
Love this place! I have to stop by almost everytime I’m passing through Sullivan. Lots of options I’m always able to try something new! Usually a savory pie and a latte.

… more

Colleen Barclay
They make a fine latte over here!! Literally my #1 reason to go. Their pies are good. I wouldn’t recommend the quiche – it was a bit dry/rubbery. But it’s a nice place to drink a latte and read a book. I look forward to trying their salad bar.

… more

BJD Beautifully Jagged Dolls
Very disappointed. We were driving from St Louis to Rolla and decided to stop to get food. It was before 7:00 pm on a Friday. Their website says they are open until 8:00. They were closed. No sign on door to explain

… more

taetaesminecraftgf
Very good!!! Love the new salad bar. It is cold, fresh and delicious. Also has some new coffees and delicious baked items as well as breakfast items. Dine in area is nice or they have takeout. It’s on the corner back from Jimmy John’s (same building).

… more

Callie Avery
Simple, quality food on the salad bar and in the pies and lovely staff. Definitely a place we will visit again.

… more

Tammy Norris
My first time here. Amazing! From very friendly lady that helped me, to the salad bar and pie. Very clean and great price. Glad to have this option in Sullivan. Cant wait to try the chicken pot pie.

… more

Melissa Young
Oh my goodness, my new favorite pie shop! I’ve tried 6 of them so far and each one was better than the last. Can’t wait to go back and try more of their delicious pies.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch