Based on 564 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
W63N635 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Phone: (262) 375-0011
Website: http://www.salspizzacedarburg.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nathan Wranovsky
My two friends and I went to Sal’s Pizza in Cedarburg for a Sunday lunch. It was really good! The servers were very helpful. You could eat inside or outside. There were lots of different options for unique pizza flavors. You could buy by the slice or a whole pizza. We loved the by-the-slice option—we all had plenty to eat with just one slice! Every pizza slice comes with a roll, too. Stop by Sal’s for tasty gourmet pizza!
… more
James McQueen
We saw Sal’s while walking with my nephews and decided to get some food. The moment we walked in we were greeted kindly and saw some very appetizing pizzas. The staff were super helpful and freindly. Once we ordered and received our food, we got our garlic knots and they were very big and very tasty! Along with some delicious and well made mozzarella sticks and slices of pizza. Not only did we love it, my two year old nephews enjoyed it as well. They rarely eat pizza and hardly ever eat red sauce, but they ate both with no problem! Highly recommended
… more
Denise LG
If you are looking for atmosphere this may not be your first choice BUT if you are looking for great pizza in a simple atmosphere this is your place!
… more
John Thiele
My wife and I will drive from the southwest side of Milwaukee for the sole purpose of taking out two or three slices of pizza from Sal’s. We have never been disappointed in the flavor or quality of the pizza. They offer unique toppings, and the young men working behind the counter are always helpful and courteous. This is a must stop for those hungry and visiting downtown Cedarburg.
… more
Shaun Edwards
While visiting SE Wisconsin from California I stumbled upon this place. Of course I was hungry from all the walking around and pizza seemed like the best fit at the moment. The pizza was fresh and crispy crust which I prefer, even the piece of garlic bread was so good. Service from Ian was excellent and his personality was fitting for the service industry. If you’re in town I would highly recommend this place. There was plenty of seating in the back of the inside and a few tables out front. Give this place a try!
… more
Maggie Ley
Pizza was authentically great. We had one with everything and one with spinach/feta. Garlic knots were divine, clearly from scratch. This will become a regular stop.
… more
Jsteven T
We went to Cedarburg for a day trip and stopped at Sal’s to try it out. Early in the day my wife and I shared a slice, then after shopping we bought a full pizza. We ate some of it in the parking lot where we were parked, and it was fantastic. The employees were cheerful also, nice dudes to talk with. Great job!
… more
Amy Helwig
Sal’s does NOT disappoint .
… more
Justin Zipperer
Stopped by Sal’s for a slice during Strawberry Fest. It was so tasty and delicious!! Looking for good pizza, I recommend checking out Sal’s!
… more
John Curnutt
If you’re from the east coast and you find yourself in the quaint historic town of Cedarburg, you may long for a slice. Sal’s is the only place you can get a slice of NY style pizza. All the other local places only serve squares. It’s pricey, but a large pie is a reasonable deal for 3 or 4 adults.
… more
… View more