Casual pizzeria serving a menu of classic & creative pies, plus subs, pasta & salads. Based on 388 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2 Main St, Tiffin, OH 44883
Phone: (419) 448-1427
Website: http://heavenlypizzatiffin.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Keegan “Biggums” Seaburn
Easily the best pizza i think i’ve ever eaten, along with the cheese bread. The prices aren’t too bad since you’re definitely getting your money’s worth. The only bad thing i could say is the wait because the past couple times i have went i have had to wait 20+ minutes after already waiting an additional 10-15 minutes. But again that still isn’t terrible seeing as you always get your food hot and made the right way instead of them rushing and it being incorrect. The service was very good too! All in all Amazing!
… more
Casey Pressley
Ordered extra sauce and didn’t get any. Person taking my order was rude. No one smiles or acts happy to be there. Definitely not what it used to be! I spelled my name for them but they put it in as something else so when I got there they couldn’t find my order. Wanted to check my order to make sure it was right because it’s been wrong more often than not lately and the I was questioned for doing this. I love the pizza but I need to find somewhere else to go. Not worth giving my money to people that don’t really want my business.
… more
Steve Etter
Pizza is pretty good
… more
Christine Harper
We just love to get AJ’s jumbo Pizza. My husband loves all his veggies and ham and we just love the flavors of AJ’s. I went to Heidelberg so I ordered a ham sub to see if it was similar to when I was in college… Obviously different but still yummy as ever
… more
mark peth
The pepperoni rolls are amazing anytime I’m around tiffin I stop and get some
… more
The Hellcat
Super friendly staff! We wandered by while tackling the Slice of Seneca County Pizza Trail. We weren’t planning to go into this location since we were still full from the last few, but we got talked into some pizza puffs, and we’re glad we did!
… more
Abigail Schichner
the best gluten free pizza hands down. crust is so pillowy and soft. sauce is sweet. always perfect amount of cheese. whenever I’m visiting Tiffin heavenly pizza is my go to.
… more
Karree Munroe
The BEST pizza place in Tiffin. I LOVE LOVE LOVE PIZZA. Heavenly is my favorite pizza of all time. When I move from here I will miss it dearly. I put in a pick up order for 9 pm not realizing they close at 9pm and they still made the pizza for me and let me pick it up!! 10/10 Can’t say enough.
… more
Corey Spencer
Great place to get a jumbo pizza for your party or if you have family intown. Great people producing a great pizza and more!
… more
Drew Paddock
I was excited to have some AJ’s Heavenly Pizza delivered after not having it for a very long time. It took almost two hours to get a hot pizza and garlic bread. I placed my order at 7:10. At 8:00 still no pizza (we live five minutes away off Hedges). I called and she said the driver had left a little while ago. Our order arrived at 8:20 (the driver was very nice). The food was not hot. I called and a man answered. I told him what had happened and he offered no apology. He asked if I wanted to swap it out and I said yes. The replacement order arrived a little before 9:00 (the driver was very nice). I asked why I had to give our original order back and she said she didn’t know and that it would probably be thrown away. The pizza (14″ pepperoni & mushroom) didn’t look or taste like it has in the past (it was hot though). The sauce was super sweet and the cheese came off in one big congealed chunk. The garlic bread was hot and looked good but had little flavor. Sorry for the long rant but wanted to make others aware.
… more
… View more