Umberto’s of Oyster Bay Menu – Oyster Bay, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Oyster Bay, NY

Based on 53 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Umberto's of Oyster Bay 11771

Address:
25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Phone: (516) 922-0434

Website: http://www.umbertosoysterbay.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Pizzas
Regular Pizza
Traditional New York pizza hand tossed and cooked well. An Umberto’s classic. Round.		 $23.55
Sicilian Pizza
Simply the best Sicilian pie in New York! thick, flavorful crust.		 $27.60
Grandma Pizza
Umberto’s created it and Umberto’s does it best! This simple, rustic pizza is just like grandma used to make! thinner than a Sicilian crust, but thicker than classic New York regular.		 $27.60
Pizzetta
Pan cooked version of our regular pie. Round.		 $12.65
Specialty Pizzas
Margherita Pizza
Homemade mozzarella, marinara sauce & basil.		 $27.60
Alla Vodka Pizza
With alla vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella.		 $29.90
White Pizza
Ricotta & mozzarella cheese (no sauce).		 $29.90
Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza $35.65
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken, buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, mozzarella cheese.		 $35.65
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe $37.95
MVP Pie
Marinara, vodka, pesto, mozzarella cheese.		 $35.65
Pesto Pizza
With fresh mozzarella.		 $32.20
Smoked Mozzarella & Marinara Pizza $32.20
Pazzo Pizza
Homemade fresh mozzarella, marinara, sausage, black olives & roasted peppers.		 $37.95
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Tomato sauce, fried chicken & mozzarella		 $35.65
Grilled Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza
With fresh mozzarella.		 $36.80
Meatball Alla Vodka Pizza
With fresh mozzarella.		 $36.80
The Hangover Pizza
Mozzarella sticks, vodka sauce & more mozzarella.		 $36.80
Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken with sweet chili sauce, mozzarella & ranch.		 $35.65
Spicy Stinger Pizza
Mozzarella, tomato sauce, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers, mikes hot honey.		 $35.65
Meat Lovers Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ham, meatballs.		 $37.95
Sausage & Peppers Pizza
Sausage, peppers, onions, tomato sauce & mozzarella.		 $35.65
Papa Pizza
Margherita with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, ricotta, & hot cherry peppers.		 $36.80
Eggplant Pizza
Mozzarella, tomato sauce, fried eggplant, parmesan, ricotta, basil.		 $35.65
Primavera Pizza
Mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, tomato, tomato sauce & mozzarella.		 $34.50
Shrimp Francese Pizza
shrimp with francese sauce & mozzarella.		 $37.95
Shrimp Parmigiana Pizza
Fried shrimp with tomato sauce & mozzarella.		 $36.80
Vegan Pizza
Vegan Primavera Pizza
Mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, tomato, tomato sauce & vegan cheese		 $35.65
Vegan Garden Meatball Pizza
Tomato sauce, homemade garden vegetable meatballs & vegan cheese.		 $35.65
Vegan Eggplant Parm Pizza
Tomato sauce, eggplant & vegan cheese.		 $35.65
Vegan Pesto Pizza $35.65
Regular Vegan Pizza $27.54
Vegan Sicilian Pizza
Our famous Umberto’s sicilian pie made with Daiya vegan cheese		 $31.05
Vegan Grandma Pizza $31.05
Vegan Pizzetta $14.95
Vegan Sicilian Vegetable Pizza $36.80
Vegan Garlic Knots $3.16
Pizzettas
Margherita Pizzetta
Homemade mozzarella, marinara sauce & basil.		 $12.65
Alla Vodka Pizzetta
With fresh mozzarella.		 $13.80
White Pizzetta
Ricotta & mozzarella cheese (no sauce).		 $14.95
Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizzetta $16.10
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Pizzetta $16.10
Pesto Pizzetta
With fresh mozzarella.		 $16.10
Smoked Mozzarella & Marinara Pizzetta $16.10
Pazzo Pizzetta
Homemade fresh mozzarella, marinara, sausage, black olives & roasted peppers.		 $16.10
Chicken Parmigiana Pizzetta
Tomato sauce, fried chicken & mozzarella.		 $16.10
Grilled Chicken Alla Vodka Pizzetta
With fresh mozzarella.		 $17.25
Meatball Alla Vodka Pizzetta $17.25
The Hangover Pizzetta
mozzarella sticks, vodka sauce & more mozzarella.		 $17.25
Sweet Chili Chicken Pizzetta
fried chicken with sweet chili sauce, mozzarella & ranch.		 $16.10
Spicy Stinger Pizzetta
Mozzarella, tomato sauce, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers, mikes hot honey.		 $16.10
Meat Lovers Pizzetta
Sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ham, meatballs.		 $17.25
Sausage & Peppers Pizzetta
Sausage, peppers, onions, tomato sauce & mozzarella.		 $16.10
Papa Pizzetta
Margherita with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, ricotta, & hot cherry peppers.		 $17.25
Eggplant Pizzetta
mozzarella, tomato sauce, fried eggplant, parmesan, ricotta, basil.		 $17.25
Primavera Pizzetta
mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, tomato, tomato sauce & mozzarella.		 $17.25
Shrimp Francese Pizzetta
Shrimp with francese sauce & mozzarella.		 $18.40
Shrimp Parmigiana Pizzetta
Fried shrimp with tomato sauce & mozzarella.		 $17.25
Pizza by the Slice
Regular Buffalo Pizza Slice $5.55
Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Grandma Pizza Slice $5.55
Sweet Chili Chicken Grandma Pizza Slice $5.55
White Regular Pizza Slice $4.50
Vodka Grandma Pizza Slice $4.50
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Grandma Pizza Slice $5.55
Pazzo Grandma Pizza Slice $5.55
Margherita Pizza Slice $4.50
Crostino Pizza Slice $4.76
Pizzeria Favorites
Cauliflower Pizza
With smoked mozzarella and marinara.		 $14.78
Chicken Roll
Include side sauce.		 $10.06
Sausage Roll $10.06
Cheese Calzone
With ricotta and mozzarella.		 $10.64
Cheese Calzone With Meat
Sausage and pepperoni.		 $11.21
Cheese Calzone With Veggies
Spinach and broccoli.		 $11.21
Crostino Pie
Cold with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, & basil.		 $35.65
Buffalo Chicken Roll $10.06
Rice Ball $4.54
Meat Pinwheel $3.85
Vegetable Pinwheel $3.85
Sicilian Vegetable Pie
Spinach, broccoli, eggplant, and fresh mozzarella		 $36.80
Garlic Knots
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked & then topped with melted butter, garlic & parsley. 6 per order		 $3.16
Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks
Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce.		 $14.09
Fried Calamari
Flash fried squid, crunchy on the outside & simply perfect on the inside. Kick it up a notch with a squeeze of lemon.		 $17.77
Calamari Arrabiata
Fried and tossed with marinara, black gaeta olives and cherry peppers.		 $18.92
Buffalo Calamari $18.92
Buffalo Wings
Chicken wings breaded & fried then tossed in buffalo sauce.		 $16.04
Chicken Fingers
Breaded & fried chicken strips.		 $14.32
Garlic Bread
Bread, topped with garlic, herb seasoning, baked to perfection.		 $4.89
Garlic Bread With Mozzarella Cheese $6.04
French Fries
Our delicious French fries are deep-fried ’till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior & a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!		 $6.27
Plant Based Appetizers
Buffalo Cauliflower $16.96
Cauliflower Arrabiata
Sauteed with marinara, black gaeta olives, and cherry peppers.		 $18.69
Cauliflower Oreganata
Sauteed with garlic, oil, Italian seasonings and breadcrumbs.		 $18.69
Garden Meatball Appetizer
Three of our homemade, delicious garden meatless meatballs topped with marinara sauce and Daiya vegan cheese.		 $18.34
Soups
Minestrone Soup
All vegetables and beans. Vegan.		 $8.91
Pasta E Fagioli Soup
Macaroni and beans.		 $8.91
Lentil Soup
Freshly cooked savory lentil soup. Vegan.		 $8.91
Stracciatella Soup
Egg drop soup with spinach		 $8.91
Salads
Tossed House Salad
Vegan		 $8.95
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce with our homemade croutons.		 $10.25
Greek Salad
With cucumber, tomato, carrot, red onion, olives and feta cheese in a vinaigrette dressing.		 $12.10
Avocado Salad
Avocado, red onion, tomatoes, and balsamic dressing. Vegan.		 $12.95
Sides
Side Of Meatballs $7.99
Side Of Sausage $7.99
Vegetables
Broccoli
In garlic & oil. Vegan		 $13.51
Spinach
In garlic & oil. Vegan		 $13.51
Broccoli Rabe
In garlic & oil with cherry peppers. Vegan		 $14.66
Heroes
Grilled Chicken Hero
With lettuce and tomato.		 $12.02
Grilled Chicken With Broccoli Rabe Hero
With cherry peppers.		 $15.81
Fried Chicken With Avocado Hero
Roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella.		 $15.81
Chicken Parmigiana Hero $15.81
Chicken Parmigiana Alla Vodka Hero $16.09
Meatball Parmigiana Hero $12.94
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $15.24
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $12.94
Vegan Eggplant Parm Hero $14.66
Sausage Parmigiana Hero $14.38
Sausage & Peppers Hero $14.38
Sausage With Broccoli Rabe Hero
With cherry peppers.		 $15.81
Garden Meatball Parm Hero
Our homemade, delicious meatless meatballs topped with marinara sauce and Daiya cheese. Vegan.		 $15.24
Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Buffalo chicken with lettuce and tomato with a side of blue cheese dressing.		 $15.24
Grilled Chicken & Avocado Wrap
Grilled chicken, avocado, lettuce and tomato, ranch dressing on the side.		 $15.24
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken with romaine lettuce and caesar dressing.		 $15.24
Shrimp Caesar Wrap
Grilled shrimp with romaine lettuce and caesar dressing.		 $18.69
Pasta
Pasta With Tomato Sauce
Vegan.		 $17.54
Pasta With Sausages $18.92
Pasta With Meatballs $20.18
Pasta With Butter Sauce $15.24
Pasta With Alfredo Sauce $19.84
Pasta With Marinara Sauce
Sauteed plum tomatoes, garlic and olive oil. Vegan.		 $18.11
Pasta With Broccoli
Sauteed broccoli with garlic and oil. Vegan.		 $18.34
Pasta With Broccoli Rabe
Sauteed broccoli rabe with garlic and oil.		 $19.84
Pasta Alla Vodka
With plum tomatoes, onions, and cream.		 $19.49
Pasta With Filetto
Sautéed plum tomatoes with onions and prosciutto.		 $19.84
Pasta Puttanesca
Sauteed plum tomatoes with geta olives, garlic and a touch of anchovies.		 $19.26
Vegan Pasta Puttanesca
Sauteed plum tomatoes with geta olives, garlic.		 $19.26
Pasta Primavera
Mixed vegetables in a light marinara sauce.		 $20.30
Vegan Primavera Pasta
Mixed vegetables in a light marinara sauce.		 $20.30
Vegan Pasta With Meatless “Meatballs”
Three of our homemade, delicious meatless meatballs topped with marinara sauce.		 $20.30
Cheese Ravioli Alla Vodka Sauce $19.49
Cheese Ravioli With Tomato Sauce $17.19
Baked Pasta
Baked Cheese Ravioli
Served with tomato sauce.		 $19.49
Baked Cheese Ravioli Alla Vodka Sauce $21.79
Baked Ziti
Served with tomato sauce.		 $19.26
Baked Ziti Alla Vodka Sauce $21.56
Baked Ziti Siciliana
Ricotta, tomato sauce, eggplant, and melted mozzarella.		 $20.41
Chicken Entrees
Chicken Parmigiana $25.59
Chicken Alla Vodka
Fred chicken topped with vodka sauce and mozzarella cheese.		 $27.31
Chicken Francese
Breast of chicken dipped in egg and flour, sauteed in a white wine, lemon and butter sauce.		 $25.59
Chicken Marsala
Sauteed in marsala wine with mushrooms, diced prosciutto and onions.		 $25.59
Chicken Milanese
Fried and topped with tomato sauce.		 $25.59
Chicken Piccata
sautéed in a lemon & butter sauce with capers.		 $26.16
From The Sea
Shrimp Parmigiana
Breaded and fried with melted mozzarella and tomato sauce.		 $26.39
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
In a spicy marinara sauce.		 $26.39
Shrimp Marinara
In a mild marinara sauce.		 $26.39
Shrimp Francese
Dipped in egg and flour, sauteed in white, lemon and butter.		 $26.39
Fried Calamari $24.09
Calamari Marinara
In a mild marinara sauce.		 $25.59
Calamari Arrabiata
Fried and tossed with marinara, black gaeta olives and cherry peppers.		 $26.39
Grilled Entrees
Grilled Chicken Breast
Choose your vegetable: spinach, broccoli, or broccoli rabe & cherry peppers. Also comes with a side of pasta or salad!		 $27.31
Grilled Homemade Sausage
Choose your vegetable: spinach, broccoli, or broccoli rabe & cherry peppers. Also comes with a side of pasta or salad!		 $25.24
Eggplant Entrees
Eggplant Parmigiana $21.79
Vegan Eggplant Parm $23.40
Eggplant Rollatine $23.63
Vegan Food
Vegan Garlic Knots $3.45
Vegan Cauliflower Arrabiata
Sauteed with marinara, black gaeta olives, and cherry peppers.		 $18.35
Vegan Cauliflower Oreganata
Sauteed with garlic, oil, Italian seasonings and breadcrumbs.		 $18.35
Vegan Garden Meatball Appetizer
Three of our homemade, delicious garden meatless meatballs topped with marinara sauce and Daiya vegan cheese.		 $18.15
Vegan Buffalo Cauliflower $16.40
Vegan Minestrone Soup
All vegetables.		 $8.60
Vegan Lentil Soup
Freshly cooked savory lentil soup.		 $8.60
Vegan Avocado Salad
Avocado, red onion, tomatoes, and balsamic dressing.		 $14.10
Vegan Tossed House Salad $9.50
Vegan Eggplant Parm Hero $14.45
Vegan Pasta With Tomato Sauce $16.40
Vegan Pasta With Marinara Sauce
Sauteed plum tomatoes, garlic and olive oil.		 $17.00
Vegan Pasta With Broccoli
Sauteed broccoli with garlic and oil.		 $17.20
Vegan Pasta With Broccoli Rabe
Sauteed broccoli rabe with garlic and oil.		 $18.70
Vegan Primavera Pasta
Mixed vegetables in a light marinara sauce.		 $19.15
Pasta Vegan Puttanesca
Sauteed plum tomatoes with geta olives, garlic.		 $16.85
Vegan Pasta With Meatless “Meatballs”
Three of our homemade, delicious meatless meatballs topped with marinara sauce.		 $19.85
Vegan Eggplant Parm $22.95
Vegan Eggplant Roll $9.50
Vegan Broccoli $12.65
Vegan Spinach $12.65
Vegan Broccoli Rabe $13.80
Vegan 10″Pizzetta $13.50
Vegan Neapolitan Pizza
Regular pie with Daiya Vegan Cheese		 $25.00
Vegan Sicilian Pizza $27.75
Vegan Grandma Pizza $27.50
Vegan Sicilian Vegetable Pizza $32.50
Beverages
Soda $3.00
Lemonade $3.00
Gold Peak Lemon Iced Tea $3.20
Apple Juice $3.20
Poland Spring $2.55

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jennifer Roper
Nice to see that Ninos was replaced with another pizzeria. However, the flavor on the regular slice and sausage roll was underwhelming. I tried them on a previous occasion and our entire pie was burnt. It was inedible.

… more

Lori Hellen
I ordered $185 worth of food. 3 pizzas and an order of garlic bread with mozzarella cheese arrived so burnt that we had to dissect them to eat them and a lot of it went in the garbage. I contacted Umberto’s through the slice app i ordered it on and they only issued me a $10 credit. i asked them to please reconsider the small amount of the credit and they refused.

… more

Ivan Ledyashov
Just a really good slice. A buddy of mine and I used to stop by here on the way back from a 40 mile bike ride from Queens to Sagamore Hill. Even though we knew eating the pizza was a bad idea because our energy would go to digesting the slices and we knew we would crawl back at 50% the original speed, suffering immensely in the process, we still stopped every time.

… more

Stefanie D
I live in NJ but whenever I’m in Long Island I make it a point to stop at umbertos and buy a few pizzas, and freeze them since I don’t have the luxury of living near a location . The Sicilian slice is the main thing that sets them apart from other pizza spots

… more

Angelo Gesmundo
They’re regular is amazing! And I also like their Buffalo slice. Great service, great people.

… more

Thomas D
Very happy Umberto’s has arrived in Oyster Bay. Love that they offer options for thin crust on pies, and particularly a choice to have a pie well done. We can’t choose between the Margarita and grandma pies, so have to order both! Their sausage rolls and pinwheels are great also. This is our only choice for local area pizza!

… more

Nicky Mazz
To have a local Umbertos is amazing. Pizza was excellent. Welcome to the neiborhood

… more

donna dee
It’s a store front with only outside tables. If it was bigger, they could add tabled inside.

… more

Theresa E Sweeney
Whilst working on the stained glass windows at Christ Church (a few doors down from Umberto’s) we discovered this best-kept secret in Oyster Bay. All the dishes here are outstanding, and the staff lovely, generous and kind. The prices are wonderful, too.

… more

Jay Bo99
First time here. Simple large pie well done and dz knots. Best pie I had in a long time in this area. Knots were soft with just enough of oil/garlic. Will need to try some dishes and salads next time to keep the 5 .

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch