After 36 years, we are now in an “express” take-out only location at Shop-N-Save market while we await the build of our new Home! In the meantime, you can still call-in, or order online to get your favorite pizza! We can’t thank you folks enough for the support given during the move and the closing of our original location, and we can’t wait to serve you at our new home at 250 S. Main Street in the Summer of 2023! Hope to see you soon.
Simple eatery offering pizza, subs & homemade meatballs in a down-to-earth dining room. Based on 260 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1105 Mecklenburg Hwy, Mooresville, NC 28115
Phone: (704) 663-7189
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday |
11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Saturday |
4–7:30 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–7:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christopher Williams
On July 22 around 434pm my wife and I ordered a pizza from Pie in the Sky and I would say it was a big disappointment. The lady that took our order was hateful, and she rushed us like we were a bother. The pizza was burnt a little and it tasted like a cardboard box. You can tell the ingredients was old. I will never recommend this pizza place until the owners know what customer service is and what fresh ingredients is. Very Disappointed don’t waste your money. I didn’t place an order over the phone we came in and placed the order. They never asked for our names. The amount was 27 dollars and we ordered a medium pizza all the way
… more
Patra Stone
Very disappointed. I’ve been to Pie In The Sky many times and it’s always exceptional but this is the only time I’ve been disappointed. 2 pizzas, 1 order of cheese bread $44.50 and I drove a hour to get it and an hour back home. I ordered ham and extra cheese on one and there was barely any ham or cheese on it. I’m hoping this was just a fluke.
… more
Sheldon Blythe
Awesome family owned business with the best subs in the southeast. Food, service, prices are always on par. Counting down the days for the opening of the new location!
… more
Cobey Riley
Great oldschool authentic pizza joint in the center of town. Perfect personal sized pies. I did the 10″ with three toppings and a drink for $15. Next time I’ll go after work and enjoy a cold beer with my pizza.
… more
Patrick Knapp
Great local pizza place. They are family owned business and great people. The crust is not too thin, not Papa Doms. So no sogginess and not over full. The pizza is fast so hot. Twice mine has taken 15 minutes. They are building a second place in the old dry cleaners.
… more
richard grack
The owners are great.
… more
Kristhian Garay
Best place to eat in mooresville! They treated us very well and we can’t wait for them to reopen!
… more
General Email Account
Delicious pizza. Ready on time. The staff was friendly and efficient. Great job! Can’t wait to visit you in your new building soon.
… more
Mandy Cook
It’s always great to visit a hometown favorite when I’m in town. We stopped in after the cruise in. Tim has done well to build a community presence and great pizza.
… more
Crystal Parks
Great pizza place. We loved the garlic cheese bread. So yummy! The Supreme pizza was delicious. You can buy by the slice and choose your toppings at lunch. My 4 year old son got cheese pizza and they even offered to cut up his slice into smaller pieces for us so we wouldn’t have to cut it. Such friendly staff
… more
… View more
