Black-Eyed Susan’s Menu – Nantucket, MA

Type : New American restaurant

Location : Nantucket, MA

Popular for breakfast, this down-to-earth New American eatery also offers BYOB-friendly dinners. Based on 229 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Black-Eyed Susan's 02554

Address:
10 India St, Nantucket, MA 02554

Phone: (508) 325-0308

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
5–10 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 5–10 PM
Thursday 5–10 PM
Friday 5–10 PM
Saturday 5–10 PM
Sunday 5–10 PM

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Robyn Em
Coming under new ownership, this spot has remained a Nantucket staple. Fantastic to get fish that really tastes fresh. Strong menu left me struggling to narrow down my choices! I definitely was ready to come back and order anything I did not get to try. Good portions and a casual environment for dinner. Make sure to book ahead as this place is certainly popular. I am excited to see what is to come for this spot and the return of breakfast!

… more

Daniel Zezheng Jiang
My girlfriend loves the restaurant and the staff provided excellent service and they are very friendly. They often checked in on us for food and water. My favorite dish was the fresh tomato pork curry. I was amazed by the creativity of the chef. It blends the authentic Asians flavors into the dish and presentation was on point. The spice was mild, pleasant and unexplainable like they dropped a magical pouch of goodness! I strongly recommend this restaurant for dates and family meet ups.

… more

Zoe Larson
Absolutely delicious menu, paired with intimate and inviting environment.

… more

Reel Viewer
Brought my family here two years ago and had a memorable experience, from the food to the service. I was excited to return.

… more

Mercy Morganfield
Racially Insensitive Behavior

… more

Christopher Wofford
Really glad the restaurant has re-opened. Prices are way up, however, so value prop has eroded — for a casual, open kitchen format. Not everything was equally good, but we are glad that old faithful’s like the tuna tartare and the linguine with clam sauce have been kept on the menu! Great that they’re now taking credit cards, however.

… more

Laurence Banville
Saw the reviews so figured I would try it out. There was a short wait on a Sunday morning to get a seat. Place is small. Sat at counter. Had a guy wait on us, he seemed a little grumpy. In any case, I ordered the sourdough french toast and it was awesome. As were the sides. Overall it was a great spot to eat. I enjoyed the food. Coffee was also good.

… more

Julia Caroline
Very disappointed by our experience. An expensive restaurant with nice service and yet owners think it is OK to squeeze 3 of us on a table for 2 by the bathroom at the back (having got up early to book first and request being near a window). We used to love coming here but this has gone the way of many Nantucket restaurants where any respect for the customer has vanished.

… more

Alexander Moschella
This place has been an island mainstay for my family for a long time, but our last few visits have been underwhelming.

… more

Rodney Yoswig
Breakfast was simply amazing. Highly recommend. This is a small diner which appears to have a seating capacity of about 40 people indoors. They do rotate people through rather quickly, so the wait isn’t long at all. The only thing you need to know, is this is a cash only business. Food was great.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions