Hopping pizzeria with classic leather booths serving coal-fired Neapolitan pies & more. Cash only. Based on 368 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 206-1060
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Leresa Pearson
Atmosphere was very nice and cozy. The service was excellent. The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. Excellent place to bring family and friends or if someone’s coming from out of town. I ordered the meat lovers and if you want anything extra you just have to pay a little more.
… more
J F
I stopped in for lunch and had the Baked Ziti Salvatore. It was a bit soupy for my taste and the tiny bits of sausage were kind of a disappointment. There was a hint of spice in the sauce which was a pleasant surprise. With that being said I will drop by again in the future and check them out.
… more
Nick Bierman
We got the neopalitin and loved it! They serve it so hot that you need to let it rest for about five or 10 minutes. The garlic bread was awesome! There were three of us and we were satisfied with a large pizza and garlic bread. Very nice atmosphere inside and definitely a place I would come with my lady. If I had a lady… but seriously this place was awesome! Great service too
… more
Kary D
Omg the best pizza ever!!! I did half white/half Napolian and the greek salad with the tastiest olives- to. die. for!!! My bf raved about the baked clams and his clam pizza all day! Also we enjoyed the pinot grigio. This was our first stop after arriving in the Islip Airport from GA. Recommend by my google best match restaurants, and it was 100% on point! Service was perfect! The town table view was perfect! A TOTAL MUST TRY!
… more
Barbara Spencer
My family has been coming to this restaurant for about 15 years. – we used to love this place. We rode through a few bad “periods” of poor waitstaff, and burned pizzas, then the pandemic, but we always returned. We came back 3 times in the past few weeks, and sadly, decided that we won’t be coming back. Tonight the wait staff was friendly but otherwise terrible. No one ever came back to check on us. We had to go find our own forks and napkins when we needed more. A cup of water was spilled and we went to find our waitress – she said, “oh I’ll clean it up after you leave.” Meanwhile, our guest had their feet in a puddle! On top of that, there was no offer to replace the glass of water. The dinnerware is very stained and scratched and the utensils are so thin that my fork literally bent in half when cutting my pizza. Unfortunately, the place is just filthy – there is dust on all the booths, pictures, and even the fixtures in the bathroom, grimy floors. The pizza was just ok, not as good as years past. It’s a shame – this was once a really great place to eat out.
… more
Gail Melisa
The clams casino pie was tasty and full of fresh clams. I added some red pepper, which brought out the flavor of the pie. I love clams, so next time I will ask for extra.
… more
Eddy M
I can’t tell you enough how much I love this pizza, the only thing that is keeping me away is the fact that if I eat this every day, I will be enormous but other than that. This is my place to go for a Neapolitan pizza! So good! The lady in the front is always so kind.
… more
Lola
The food here is Delicious! The atmosphere feels warm and comfortable, like an Italian grandmothers kitchen ✨. They don’t sell single pizza slices which is a bummer, they only sell the entire pie which is not bad either, Must go if you’re a pizza lover.
… more
Glittering Farmer
I’ve had delivery and takeout here – both were very tasty! Alas 3rd time was not the charm – burnt chicken roll and the eggplant parm had no bread or pasta, LOTS of sauce. The chicken roll was black at the edges and along the bottom, plus it was not hot and had to been warned up. The eggplant slices were perfectly thin and tasty when I got to them. Still a single roll would’ve been nice. We’ve tried the pizza and pasta dishes and felt the prices matched the quality and flavors. This trip was so disappointing I took away a star.
… more
Emma Schmich
We ordered takeout, and despite waiting for over 10 minutes when we got there it’s still a 5 star review. Delicious crust, very thin and crispy. The garlic bread was extremely good the next day out of the fridge and I’m not sure how they mastered that. Will definitely go there and eat in one day as I’m sure the food is even better eaten right away.
… more
… View more