Local counter-serve chain that’s a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats. Based on 95 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
791 Udall Rd, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 321-4100
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Ricardo Lugo
My wife wanted a broccoli roll so I decided to try this pizzeria. I asked if they had broccoli rolls and was told they’re made to order. They said it would take 10-12 minutes. No big deal waiting for fresh food. I’d rather get something fresh than something sitting. It was the worst broccoli roll ever. It was boiled broccoli with no seasoning in a ball of dough that wasn’t cooked through. Stay away!
… more
Lisa Palermo (Assoc Real Estate Broker)
This is by far my favorite pizzeria.
… more
K O
They have the best pizza. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese.we have not been disappointed yet with their food. Great meals, everything reasonably priced and the owner and staff are the nicest people.
… more
BCW Promotions
Pizzaria never have more options then regular, Sicilian and white slices in the window. I have gone here during the day and at night. Surrounding pizzarias have more options in the windows…buffalo, bbq, pasta, salad slices etc. i live 2 mins up the road and pizzaiola and other places have more options. Very disappointed
… more
kevin abrams
Quality pizza, delicious garlic knots and a Sunday deal that can’t be beat! They lost a star because they don’t deliver to apartments and parking there is rough, but those are the only negative things I can say about the place. Have not tried their kitchen food, but if they maintain the same level of quality with the entrées as they do with the pizza, I imagine it is delicious. Look for great deals in the local papers. You owe it to yourself to try it out!
… more
Gary Looman
These reviews are NOT correct. Anthony (the owner) has been nothing but great to me. The first time I went he was nothing but NICE and WELCOMING guy. The pizza was served fresh and the hero’s were very good. I recommend the meatball parmigiana hero. The employees were very respectful and the owner seems to respect them. If you were torn between which pizza shop and one of these were your choice, Pick anthony’s!! ALWAYS pick anthony’s.
… more
Carlos Jimenez
This place was amazing I was driving by and my baby had a diaper blow out I pulled over they were kind enough to provide me with gloves gloves napkins and trash bags I highly recommend this based off the service alone it’s hard to find a place that will go above and beyond for someone who is not even a customer at the moment I guess I can tell you this much they gained a loyal customer for life
… more
Ryan R
no idea about the quality of the pizza but from what I can tell the owner is nasty. I pulled up to the shop to get a bite when I got out of my car I couldn’t believe what I was hearing the owner was YELLING at a customer of the nail salon directly next too the pizzeria in a very angry tone telling the young lady that she had to move her car or it would be towed. The young lady gave in to his demands and moved her car but that experience turned me off from pizza and I decided to go to the Chinese place near it instead. The owner definitely needs to stop being so controlling about the parking situation I front of his shop and frankly needs to grow up. The tone at which I saw him conduct himself was just childish and sad hopefully he can get his act together and mature himself.
… more
Chez Trap
The place has good food too bad the owner is not so friendly or nice so I go elsewhere!! You figure you see the same customer come in you would acknowledge him /her and say hello good morning good evening . It’s not like I haven’t been there before I’ve been there 20-30 times just got tired … and when the owner does help you he has an attitude or a chip on his shoulder or had a bad day or night ,I take it my money is not green enough or I’m funny looking , And the Spanish guy making the pizza and helping the customers is the only one that shows respect!! Good job !! Keep up the good work !!
… more
Jocelyn Bleiwas
Great food. But owner has some type of anger issues he’s always got an attitude idk why. Sometimes it makes me uncomfortable
… more
… View more