Sticky’s Finger Joint Menu – New York, NY

Type : Chicken restaurant

Location : New York, NY

At Sticky’s Finger Joint we serve up The Best Damn Chicken Finger. We offer an abundance of homemade dipping sauces, inspired by worldwide cuisines. Our menu includes chicken fingers, chicken poppers, chicken sandwiches, wraps, salads, and french fries. We source ingredients locally and use farm-raised, antibiotic-free, hormone-free chicken.

Based on 680 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Sticky's Finger Joint 10038

Address:
21 Maiden Ln, New York, NY 10038

Phone: (917) 639-3837

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 12–9 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Featured Items
Classic Sandwich Basket
Sticky’s sauce, purple slaw, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun, and classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $11.95
Spicy Chicken Sandwich Basket
Sticky’s sauce, nashville numb, cumin, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun, and classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $11.95
Chicken Thighs
Hot Honey Thigh Basket (8 Pc)
8 piece crunchy chicken thighs drizzled with Hot Honey Sauce, dusted with Carolina Reaper flakes and garnsihed with scallions; serived with classic or cajun fries		 $14.90
Chicken Thigh Basket (8 Pc)
8 piece crunchy chicken thighs with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $13.15
Chicken Thigh (8 Pc)
8 piece crunchy chicken thighs with your choice of two sauces.		 $10.25
Hot Honey Thigh (8 Pc)
8 piece crunchy chicken thighs drizzled with Hot Honey Sauce, dusted with Carolina Reaper flakes and garnished with scallions		 $12.00
Wraps
Classic Wrap
Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie with greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, purple slaw vinaigrette in a whole wheat wrap		 $11.65
Ranch BLT Wrap
Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie with greens, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar, chopped bacon, buttermilk baby ranch in a whole wheat wrap. Make it spicy by adding buffalo balsmic maple.		 $12.85
Chicken ‘n Fry Baskets
Large Crunchy Poppers Basket (16 Pc)
16 chicken poppers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $15.65
Medium Crunchy Poppers Basket (12 Pc)
12 chicken poppers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $13.15
Small Crunchy Poppers Basket (8 Pc)
8 chicken poppers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.		 $10.85
Large Crunchy Fingers Basket (5 Pc)
5 crunchy fingers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $15.65
Medium Crunchy Fingers Basket (4 Pc)
4 crunchy fingers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $13.15
Small Crunchy Fingers Basket (3 Pc)
3 crunchy fingers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.		 $10.85
Large Grilled Fingers Basket (5 Pc)
5 grilled fingers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $15.65
Medium Grilled Fingers Basket (4 Pc)
4 grilled fingers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $13.15
Small Grilled Fingers Basket (3 Pc)
3 grilled fingers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.		 $10.85
Vegetarian Classics
Large Mushroom Popper Basket (16 Pc)
[Vegan] 16 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.		 $15.65
Medium Mushroom Popper Basket (12 Pc)
[Vegan] 12 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $13.15
Small Mushroom Popper Basket (8 Pc)
[Vegan] 8 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $10.85
Large Mushroom Poppers (16 Pc)
[Vegan] 16 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of one sauce.		 $12.75
Medium Mushroom Poppers (12 Pc)
[Vegan] 12 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of two sauces.		 $10.25
Small Mushroom Poppers (8 Pc)
[Vegan] 8 bite-sized crunchy crimini mushrooms with your choice of three sauces.		 $7.95
Large Veggie Finger Basket (5 Pc)
5 vegetarian fingers with your choice of three sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $15.65
Medium Veggie Finger Basket (4 Pc)
4 vegetarian fingers with your choice of two sauces and either classic or cajun fries.		 $13.15
Small Veggie Finger Basket (3 Pc)
3 vegetarian fingers with your choice of one sauce and either classic or cajun fries.		 $10.85
Large Veggie Fingers (5 Pc)
5 vegetarian fingers with your choice of three sauces.		 $15.65
Medium Veggie Fingers (4 Pc)
4 vegetarian fingers with your choice of two sauces.		 $10.25
Small Veggie Fingers (3 Pc)
3 vegetarian fingers with your choice of one sauce.		 $7.95
Chicken
Large Crunchy Fingers (5 Pc)
5 crunchy fingers with your choice of three sauces.		 $12.75
Medium Crunchy Fingers (4 Pc)
4 crunchy fingers with your choice of two sauces.		 $10.25
Small Crunchy Fingers (3 Pc)
3 crunchy fingers with your choice of one sauce.		 $7.95
Large Crunchy Poppers (16 Pc)
16 chicken poppers with your choice of three sauces.		 $12.75
Medium Crunchy Poppers (12 Pc)
12 chicken poppers with your choice of two sauces.		 $10.25
Small Crunchy Poppers (8 Pc)
8 chicken poppers with your choice of one sauce.		 $7.95
Large Grilled Fingers (5 Pc)
5 grilled tenders with your choice of three sauces.		 $12.75
Medium Grilled Fingers (4 Pc)
4 grilled tenders with your choice of two sauces.		 $10.25
Small Grilled Fingers (3 Pc)
3 grilled tenders with your choice of one sauce.		 $7.95
Sandwiches
Classic Sandwich
Sticky’s sauce, purple slaw, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $9.65
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Sticky’s sauce, nashville numb, cumin, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $9.65
Bacon Mac Sandwich
Mac Sauce, chopped bacon, caramelized onions, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $10.85
Honey BBQ Club Sandwich
Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, cheddar, pickles and your choice of two fingers: crunchy, grilled or veggie in between a potato bun. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $10.85
Signatures
Large Thai Fiesta
Mac sauce, thai sweet chili, taco seasoning, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 5 tenders or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $14.50
Medium Thai Fiesta
Mac sauce, thai sweet chili, taco seasoning, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 4 tenders or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $12.00
Small Thai Fiesta
Mac sauce, thai sweet chili, taco seasoning, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 3 tenders or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $9.70
Large Buffalo Ranch
Buffalo balsamic maple, Buttermilk baby ranch, carrots on side and parsley over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $14.50
Medium Buffalo Ranch
Buffalo balsamic maple, Buttermilk baby ranch, carrots on side and parsley over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $12.00
Small Buffalo Ranch
Buffalo balsamic maple, Buttermilk baby ranch, carrots on side and parsley over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $9.70
Large General Sticky Tso’s
General t’sticky sauce, scallions, hot peppers, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $14.50
Medium General Sticky Tso’s
General t’sticky sauce, scallions, hot peppers, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $12.00
Small General Sticky Tso’s
General t’sticky sauce, scallions, hot peppers, B&W sesame seeds over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $9.70
Large Honey BBQ
Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, shredded cheddar over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $15.50
Medium Honey BBQ
Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, shredded cheddar over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $13.00
Small Honey BBQ
Sassy BBQ, honey, chopped bacon, shredded cheddar over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $10.70
Large Vampire Killer
Vampire aioli, grated parmesan, garlic chips, pink peppercorn flakes over your choice of 5 fingers or 16 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $14.50
Medium Vampire Killer
Vampire aioli, grated parmesan, garlic chips, pink peppercorn flakes over your choice of 4 fingers or 12 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $12.00
Small Vampire Killer
Vampire aioli, grated parmesan, garlic chips, pink peppercorn flakes over your choice of 3 fingers or 8 poppers. Add classic or cajun fries to make it a basket.		 $9.70
Specialty
Popper Nachos
Homemade Tortlla Chips, chicken poppers, pico de gallo, mac sauce, cray sauce, B&W sesame seeds.		 $12.35
Pumpkin Pie Chicken & Waffles
Pumpkin Pie Frosting, graham crackers, and crushed red pepper flakes over a mix of chicken poppers and bite-sized waffles.		 $12.95
Salads
Classic Salad
Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie over a bed of greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, purple slaw, vinaigrette.		 $12.75
Ranch BLT Salad
Two fingers: crunchy, grilled, or veggie over a bed of greens, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar, chopped bacon, buttermilk baby ranch. Make it spicy by adding buffalo balsamic maple.		 $13.75
Fries
Large Classic Fries
3/8th” straight cut fries with crispy batter.		 $4.75
Large Cajun Fries
3/8th” straight cut fries with cajun seasoning.		 $4.75
Bacon Mac Fries
3/8th” straight cut fries dressed with mac sauce and chopped bacon, parsley.		 $7.05
Truffle Parm Fries
3/8th” straight cut fries tossed in truffle salt and parmesan cheese, parsley		 $6.25
Fiesta Fries
3/8th” straight cut fries dressed with Thai SweetChili sauce and mac sauce, and topped with taco seasoning and B&W sesame seeds, parsley.		 $6.25
S’more Fries
3/8th” straight cut fries dressed with marshmallow sauce, chocolate sauce, crushed graham crackers and mini marshmallows, parsley.		 $7.05
Sauces
Buffalo Balsamic Maple
Homemade buffalo w/a splash of balsamic and maple syrup.		 $0.85
Buttermilk Baby Ranch
The anti-hidden valley ranch.		 $0.85
Caribbean Sweet Heat
Hot pineapple mango chutney.		 $0.85
Chipotle Aioli
Creamy chipotle pepper dip.		 $0.85
Cray
Peruvian inspired cilantro jalapeño sauce.		 $0.85
General T’Sticky
A sticky’s take on the traditional american-chinese sauce.		 $0.85
Hot Asian BBQ
Pan Asian sweet and spicy BBQ.		 $0.85
Lemon Piccata
Light & fresh lemon aioli with garlic & capers.		 $0.85
Mac Sauce
Cheddar cheese sauce w/diced jalapeño.		 $0.85
Nashville Numb
Southern & szechuan inspired hot sauce.		 $0.85
S’more Sauce
Chocolate + marshmallow.		 $0.85
Salsa Verde
Spicy Mexican roasted green pepper sauce.		 $0.85
Sassy BBQ
Sweet and tangy BBQ sauce.		 $0.85
Sticky’s Sauce
Creamy white BBQ sauce, our namesake.		 $0.85
Sunny Mustard
A soon-to-be-classic honey mustard.		 $0.85
Thai Sweet Chili
Sweet-n-sour w/mild chili flakes.		 $0.85
Vampire Aioli
Creamy roasted garlic dip.		 $0.85
Waffle Sauce
Sweet maple frosting.		 $0.85
Drinks
Strawberry Lemonade
Homemade lemonade made with meyer lemons and strawberries.		 $3.95
Mango Mint Splash
Homemade mango nectar with mint leaves and a splash of lemon juice.		 $4.95
Slightly Sweet Tea
Homemade black pekoe tea with honey and lemon.		 $3.65
Bottled Water $2.05
Watermelon Lemon Lime Soda
Sticky’s Own Watermelon Lemon Lime Soda		 $3.43
Pineapple Ginger Ale Soda
Sticky’s Own Pineapple Ginger Ale Soda		 $3.43
Sides
Side Pickles
Sliced crunchy dill pickles in a 4oz container.		 $2.12
Side Coleslaw
Vinegar based red cabbage slaw with herb seasoning in a 4oz container.		 $2.12
Side Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, carrots and red onions. Comes with sticky’s vinaigrette.		 $5.28
Desserts
Chocolate Whoopie Pie $5.00
Party Cake Whoopie Pie $5.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

shloka shetty
Super fast and delicious food. The Cajun fries were perfectly spiced and the sprinkle of coriander leaves on top was chef’s kiss.

… more

Dennis Galante – Mr. Manhattan
Yes its true Sticky’s is awesome And the sauces are good too. Great quality for a quick bite Is it the best damn chicken ?

… more

Cavin Daniel
Tender. Juicy. Delicious. Amazing fries. Sticky’s has all you would expect from a chicken joint. Bumped into this place while walking down the street. Chicken was flavourful and they have got out of options for sauces as well. Only feedback is that would prefer the chicken a little more crispy. Not sure if it was just mine which wasn’t super crispy but it was still tasty!

… more

Nia E
The food is okay but I needed lunch not a snack. My meal was not fortifying… I was still hungry after I ate. I’ve eaten here twice but not sure if I’ll return. There are other places to go to with same price points but you can get more servings.

… more

Nao Nio
The cashier (young lady) is an absolute disaster. Very negative persona with terrible attitude. Good food tho.

… more

Matthew Struble (Stroobz Beats)
Chicken is super tasty. Sauces incredible. My go to? Poppers with Cajun fries and sticky sauce.

… more

M& I
We are fans of fried chicken and we were excited to try Sticky Fingers bc of the reviews.

… more

Muhammad Faateh Malik
First time I ever at a Sticky’s Finger Joint was back in 2012. Being from Canada, I have been waiting to finally eat it again aftwr 10 years! The flavour amd taste is just as amazing as it was back then. Love it!!♥

… more

Vennela Gadde
The fries are so good! The chicken is good too but id definitely come back for the fries 🙂 only giving 4 instead of 5 star because they dont offer a bathroom or any hand sanitizer for people even though this location isnt a hole in the wall spot and has enough room for a bathroom for customers. The fiesta fries are amazing!!

… more

Nicolas Gomez (Food On The Spectrum)
One word! Delicious!! If only I could have such a delicacy in Florida so it can compete with PDQ and Huey Magoo’s I’d pull up here and show them who’s boss! Tonight I ate the Spicy Chicken Sandwich with some French fries. The fries were hella crispy and the sandwich was juicy and had the best bold flavor of any spicy sandwich! Thank you for a great experience!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch